Columbus City Council
Regular MeetingColumbus, OH · April 13, 2009
Minutes
Office of City Clerk
City of Columbus 90 West Broad Street
Columbus OH
43215-9015
columbuscitycouncil.org
Minutes - Final
Columbus City Council
ELECTRONIC READING OF MEETING DOCUMENTS
AVAILABLE DURING COUNCIL OFFICE HOURS. CLOSED
CAPTIONING IS AVAILABLE IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS. ANY
OTHER SPECIAL NEEDS REQUESTS SHOULD BE DIRECTED
TO THE CITY CLERK'S OFFICE AT 645-7380 BY FRIDAY
PRIOR TO THE COUNCIL MEETING.
Monday, April 13, 2009 5:00 PM City Council Chambers, Rm 231
REGULAR MEETING NO. 15 OF COLUMBUS CITY COUNCIL, APRIL 13,
2009 at 5:00 P.M. IN COUNCIL CHAMBERS.
ROLL CALL
Absent: 1 - Andrew Ginther
Present: 6 - Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
READING AND DISPOSAL OF THE JOURNAL
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Tavares, to
Dispense with the reading of the Journal and Approve. The motion carried by
the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
C0009-2009 THE FOLLOWING COMMUNICATIONS WERE RECEIVED IN THE
CITY CLERK'S OFFICE AS OF WEDNESDAY APRIL 8, 2009:
New Type: C1, C2
To: Abomalik Inc
5593 Chatterton Rd
Columbus OH 43232
Permit # 0025943
New Type: C1
To: El Nuevo Naranjo LLC
DBA El Nuevo Naranjo LLC
4234 Eastland Square Dr
Columbus OH 43232
Permit # 2470255
City of Columbus Page 1
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
Stock Type: D1, D2, D3
To: Babberts Club of Columbus Inc
2114 Groveport Pike
Columbus OH 43207
Permit# 0356747
Advertise: 04/18/2009
Return: 04/28/2009
RESOLUTIONS OF EXPRESSION
MILLER
0037X-2009 To honor the Columbus Blue Jackets on the occasion of their first
playoff appearance in franchise history.
A motion was made by Miller, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that this
matter be Adopted. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
TAVARES
0034X-2009 To proclaim the month of April 2009 as DONATE LIFE MONTH in the
City of COLUMBUS.
A motion was made by Tavares, seconded by Tyson, that this matter be
Adopted. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
TYSON
0035X-2009 To celebrate the Big Read in the City of Columbus.
A motion was made by Tyson, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that this
matter be Adopted. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
ADDITIONS OR CORRECTIONS TO THE AGENDA
FIRST READING OF 30-DAY LEGISLATION
City of Columbus Page 2
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
DEVELOPMENT: GINTHER, CHR. CRAIG TYSON MENTEL
FR 0542-2009 To designate Masonic Lodge #7 Prince Hall Free & Accepted Masons
(PHF&AM), 988 East Long Street as an Individually Listed Property on
the Columbus Register of Historic Properties.
UTILITIES: PALEY, CHR. CRAIG GINTHER MENTEL
FR 0410-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into contracts for the purchase of Luminaires with General
Supply and Services, Inc. dba Gexpro, Edison Equipment, Graybar
Electric Co., Inc., and Consolidated Electrical Distributors, Inc. for the
Division of Power and Water; and to authorize the expenditure of
$259,498.50 from the Electricity Operating Fund. ($259,498.50)
FR 0424-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter into a professional
engineering services agreement with Brown & Caldwell Ohio, LLC, for
the Town St./Fourth St. Inflow Redirection Project; to authorize the
transfer and expenditure of $1,762,305.17 within the Sanitary Sewer
Revenue Bonds Fund; and to amend the 2008 Capital Improvements
Budget, for the Division of Sewerage and Drainage. ($1,762,305.17)
FR 0434-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter into a professional
engineering services agreement with EMH&T, Inc., for the Mound
Street east of Interstate 71 (e/o I-71) Sewer Separation Project; to
authorize the transfer and expenditure of $284,311.00 within the
Sanitary Sewer Revenue Bonds Fund; and to amend the 2008 Capital
Improvements Budget, for the Division of Sewerage and Drainage.
($284,311.00)
ZONING: TYSON, CHR. CRAIG GINTHER MILLER PALEY TAVARES
MENTEL
FR 0154-2009 To grant a Variance from the provisions of Section 3356.03, C-4
Permitted Uses, of the Columbus City Codes for the property located
at 253 EAST ELEVENTH AVENUE (43201), to conform a single-unit
dwelling in the C-4, Commercial District. (Council Variance
#CV08-038)
FR 1420-2008 To rezone 5598 OLENTANGY RIVER ROAD (43235), being 4.51±
acres located east of the intersection of Olentangy River Road and
Meeklyn Drive, From: R , Rural, RR, Rural Residential, LRR, Limited
Rural Residential, and R-1, Residential Districts, To: L-R-1, Limited
Residential District (Rezoning # Z08-033).
CA CONSENT ACTIONS
City of Columbus Page 3
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
FINANCE: MENTEL, CHR. TAVARES CRAIG PALEY
CA 0469-2009 To authorize the Finance and Management Director to enter into a
contract on behalf of the Office of Construction Management with
Ultimax, Inc., for the renovation of the Administrative Building, 2100
Alum Creek Drive, for the Refuse Collection Division; to authorize the
reallocation of $31,000.00 from an existing Auditor's Certificate; to
authorize the Finance and Management Director to expend $3,100.00
or so much thereof as may be necessary to reimburse the General
Fund for construction and building renovation expenses incurred by
the Office of Construction Management; to authorize the expenditure
of $77,620.00 from the General Permanent Improvement Fund.
($77,620.00)
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0511-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance & Management Director to enter
into a contract for the option to purchase Pest Control Services with
AAA General Services, Inc.; to authorize expenditure of one dollar to
establish the contract from the Mail, Print Services and UTC Fund;
and to declare an emergency. ($1.00)
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0516-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into three (3) contracts for the option to purchase Street
Sweeper Parts from Jack Doheny Supplies Ohio Inc., Old Dominion
Brush Co (ODB), and The McLean Company, to authorize the
expenditure of three (3) dollars to establish the contracts from the
Mail, Print Services and UTC Fund; and to declare an emergency.
($3.00).
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0520-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into one (1) contract for the option to purchase Aftermarket Boat
Parts from Delta Marine Enterprises Inc., to authorize the expenditure
of one (1) dollar to establish the contract from the Mail, Print Services
and UTC Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($1.00).
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0524-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance & Management Director to modify
past, present and future purchase orders with Burns Body Shop, to
reflect a name change and Federal Identification number change to
the company; and to declare an emergency.
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
City of Columbus Page 4
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
CA 0525-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into four (4) contracts for the option to purchase Vehicle Towing
from Eitel's Towing Inc., NoTow LLC DBA Noble's Towing, Rusty's
Towing Service Inc., and Pro-Tow, Inc., to authorize the expenditure of
four (4) dollars to establish the contracts from the Mail, Print Services
and UTC Fund, and to declare an emergency. ($4.00).
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0530-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance & Management Director to modify
past, present and future purchase orders with D & D Retreading Inc.,
to reflect a name change and FID number change to the company;
and to declare an emergency.
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0533-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into two (2) contracts for the option to purchase Oils and
Greases from Four O Corporation dba: Oil Distribution Company, to
authorize the expenditure of two (2) dollars from the Mail, Print
Services and UTC Fund; and to declare an emergency. ($2.00).
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0536-2009 To authorize and direct the Finance and Management Director to
enter into a contract for the option to purchase Flygt Pump Parts and
Services with ITT Flygt Corporation, to authorize the expenditure of
$1.00 from the Mail, Print Services and UTC Fund Account; and to
declare an emergency. ($1.00).
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0547-2009 To authorize the appropriation and expenditure of $10,000.00 from the
portion of the Hotel/Motel tax devoted to the specific purpose of
expanding cultural services for the enrichment of the community to
Compete Columbus (Easy Columbus) for the development of the
Columbus Student Engagement project; to authorize and direct the
City Auditor to reduce the available funds within the Office of City
Council, Hotel/Motel tax fund by that same amount; to authorize and
direct the City Clerk to enter into a contract with Compete Columbus
for the development of said project; and to declare an emergency.
($10,000.00)
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
SAFETY : GINTHER, CHR. PALEY CRAIG MENTEL
CA 0476-2009 To amend the 2008 Capital Improvements Budget; to authorize the
City Auditor to transfer $254,050.00 between projects within the Safety
Voted Bond Fund; to authorize the Finance and Management Director
City of Columbus Page 5
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
to enter into a contract on behalf of the Office of Construction
Management with Radico, Inc., for HVAC renovations at Fire Station
No. 1; and to authorize the expenditure of $254,050.0 from the Safety
Voted Bond Fund.
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0529-2009 To authorize and direct the Director of the Department of Public Safety
to pay the City's proportionate share for operational and administrative
support activities of the Franklin County Emergency Management and
Homeland Security program, to authorize the expenditure of
$505,102.00 from the General Fund; and to declare an emergency.
($505,105.00)
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
JUDICIARY & COURT ADMINISTRATION: PALEY, CHR. CRAIG TYSON
MENTEL
CA 0028X-2009 To declare the necessity and intent to appropriate permanent and
construction easements in, over, under and through real estate in
connection with the Merwin Hill Area Sanitary Improvement Project,
and to declare an emergency.
This Matter was Adopted on the Consent Agenda.
CA 0437-2009 To formally accept those deeds for real property from various
grantees, which have already been granted to the City of Columbus
and recorded with the proper county recorder's office, to be used for
the purposes of improving storm and sanitary sewer lines and
appurtenances thereto.
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
UTILITIES: PALEY, CHR. CRAIG GINTHER MENTEL
CA 0431-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter into an agreement
with Cues Incorporated for Telemonitoring Equipment Parts and
Repair Services in accordance with the provisions of sole source
provisions of the Columbus City Codes for the Division of Sewerage
and Drainage; and to authorize the expenditure of $60,000.00 from
the Sewerage System Operating Fund. ($60,000.00)
This Matter was Approved on the Consent Agenda.
APPOINTMENTS
CA A0040-2009 Appointment of Richard Barnhart of Schottenstein, Zox & Dunn 250
West St. PO Box 165020 Columbus, Ohio 43215 to serve on the
Columbus Franklin County Finance Authority with a term expiration
City of Columbus Page 6
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
date of April 30, 2013 (replacing A0031-2009) (resume attached).
This Matter was Read and Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA A0041-2009 Appointment of Eveyln Smith of 5460 Bourbon St. Columbus, Ohio
43221 to serve on the Columbus & Franklin Councty Finance Authority
with a term expiration date of April 30, 2013 (replacing A0032-2009)
(resume attached).
This Matter was Read and Approved on the Consent Agenda.
CA A0042-2009 Appointment of Delena Edwards, 2694 Floribunda Drive, Columbus,
Ohio 43209 to serve on the the Civil Service Commission replacing
Eileen Paley for the duration of her unexpired term ending January 31,
2014 (resume attached).
This Matter was Read and Approved on the Consent Agenda.
Passed The Consent Agenda
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
EMERGENCY, TABLED AND 2ND READING OF 30-DAY LEGISLATION
FINANCE: MENTEL, CHR. TAVARES CRAIG PALEY
0484-2009 To authorize the issuance and sale of special assessment bond
anticipation notes in the amount of $286,000 for the Lockbourne Road
Area Sanitary Sewer Assessment Project. ($286,000). Section 55(b)
of the City Charter.
A motion was made by President Mentel, seconded by Tavares, that this
matter be Waived the 2nd Reading. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
A motion was made by President Mentel, seconded by Paley, that this matter
be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
PUBLIC SERVICE & TRANSPORTATION: CRAIG, CHR. MILLER TAVARES
MENTEL
0426-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Public Service to
City of Columbus Page 7
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
execute those documents required to release specific one (1) foot
wide portions of a fifteen (15) foot wide platted easement across Lots
179 through 210 of the subdivision titled "Lakes of Worthington,
Section 4", of record in Plat Book 108, Pages 89-90 of the Franklin
County, Ohio, Recorder's Office.
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Paley, that this
matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
DEVELOPMENT: GINTHER, CHR. CRAIG TYSON MENTEL
0542-2009 To designate Masonic Lodge #7 Prince Hall Free & Accepted Masons
(PHF&AM), 988 East Long Street as an Individually Listed Property on
the Columbus Register of Historic Properties.
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Tyson, that this
matter be Waived the 2nd Reading. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Tavares, that
this matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
ADMINISTRATION: MILLER, CHR. PALEY TAVARES MENTEL
0425-2009 To authorize the Director of the Department of Technology to modify,
increase and extend a contract with Lawson Software to continue
services and deliverables for the Central Payroll and Human
Resources Information Management System; to authorize the
expenditure of $99,465.00 from the Information Services Bond Fund;
and to declare an emergency ($99,465.00)
A motion was made by Miller, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that this
matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
JUDICIARY & COURT ADMINISTRATION: PALEY, CHR CRAIG TYSON
MENTEL
City of Columbus Page 8
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
0499-2009 To authorize the appropriation of $200,000 from the indigent driver
alcohol treatment fund to the Franklin County Municipal Court Judges,
pursuant to the requirements of O.R.C. 4511.191 (N); and to declare
an emergency. ($200,000.00)
A motion was made by Paley, seconded by President Pro-Tem Craig, that this
matter be Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
UTILITIES: PALEY, CHR. CRAIG GINTHER MENTEL
0374-2009 To authorize the Director of Public Utilities to enter into a construction
contract with Dreier & Maller, Inc. for the Clintonville Private Source I/I
Project; to authorize the transfer and expenditure of $1,250,160.00
from within the Sanitary Sewer Revenue Bonds Fund; and to amend
the 2008 Capital Improvements Budget, for the Division of Sewerage
and Drainage. ($1,250,160.00)
A motion was made by Paley, seconded by Tyson, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
0452-2009 To authorize the City Attorney to acquire fee simple title and lesser
interests, to contract for professional services, to authorize a transfer
and an expenditure of $8,450.00 within the Water Works Enlargement
Voted Bonds Fund; to authorize an amendment to the 2008 Capital
Improvements Budget; for costs in connection with the Cleveland
Avenue Area Water Line Improvements Project, and to declare an
emergency. ($8,450.00)
A motion was made by Paley, seconded by Tyson, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
RECREATION & PARKS: TYSON, CHR. TAVARES PALEY MENTEL
0378-2009
To authorize and direct the Director of Recreation and Parks to grant
consent to various organizations to apply for permission to sell
alcoholic beverages at the following 2009 events: WaterFire
Columbus and Oktoberfest.
City of Columbus Page 9
Columbus City Council Minutes - Final April 13, 2009
A motion was made by Tyson, seconded by Tavares, that this matter be
Approved. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
ADJOURNMENT
ADJOURNED: 6:13 P.M.
A motion was made by President Pro-Tem Craig, seconded by Tavares, to
adjourn this Regular Meeting. The motion carried by the following vote:
Absent: 1- Andrew Ginther
Affirmative: 6- Charleta Tavares, Hearcel Craig, Priscilla Tyson, Michael Mentel, A. Troy
Miller, and Eileen Paley
City of Columbus Page 10