Muyni
← Back to DeKalb

Planning & Zoning Commission

Regular Meeting

DeKalb, IL · May 17, 2017

AgendaMinutes

Minutes

MINUTES CITY OF DEKALB PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION May 17, 2017 The Planning and Zoning Commission held a Meeting on May 17, 2017 at the City of DeKalb Municipal Building, 200 S. Fourth St., DeKalb, Illinois. Chair Atherton called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM. A. ROLL CALL Natalie Nelson called the roll. Members of the Planning and Zoning Commission present at roll call: Katharina Barbe, Vicki Buckley, David Castro, Matthew Crull, Deborah Nier, Jerry Wright, and Chair Christina Atherton. No members were absent. Elected official present was Mayor Jerry Smith. City staff present were Community Development Director Jo Ellen Charlton, Principal Planner Dan Olson, and Administrative Assistant Natalie Nelson. B. APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA (Additions/Deletions) Chair Atherton requested a motion to approve the May 17, 2017 agenda as presented. M. Crull motioned to approve the agenda, K. Barbe seconded the motion, and the motion was approved by unanimous voice vote. C. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION (Open Floor to Anyone Wishing to Speak on Record) Jerry Smith, resident of 139 Buena Vista Drive and DeKalb’s Mayor Elect, introduced himself. He stated he would be meeting with each commission and board. He commended the Planning and Zoning Commission members for their attendance and willingness to serve the community and praised City staff who work with the Commission. Chair Atherton said she is proud to serve with the Commission members, and she thanked Mayor Smith for attending. D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. April 26, 2017 – V. Buckley motioned to approve the minutes as presented, D. Castro seconded the motion, and the motion was approved by unanimous voice vote. E. OLD BUSINESS None F. NEW BUSINESS 1. Workshop regarding text amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance. Planning and Zoning Commission May 17, 2017 Page 2 of 8 DISCUSSION Principal Planner Dan Olson presented to the Commission proposed amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO). UDO Article 3 “Definitions” and Article 5 “Zoning District Regulations” Mr. Olson asked for feedback and direction for improving the regulations for Social Clubs and Banquet Halls. He reported that Municipal Code Chapter 32 “Business Regulations” addresses Social Clubs, including definitions and licensing regulations, one of which is a prohibition against having a liquor license. He stated that the UDO does not include Social Club as a permitted or special use in any zoning district. He noted a concern with the current language, a Social Club could be categorized as a Banquet Hall. He noted that Banquet Halls are a special use in LC and a permitted use in the CBD and GC districts. He asked the Commission consider the following: • Adding to a definition for Banquet Hall in Article 3, • Categorizing Banquet Hall as a special use in the CBD and GC districts, • Adding a definition for Social Club, similar to Chapter 32, • Categorizing Social Club as a special use in the GC district or any other zoning district the Commission desires. He stated an existing Banquet Hall would become legal non-conforming and subject to the provisions in Article 19 if the Commission approves the proposed amendments. D. Nier asked for clarification of the difference between a Banquet Hall and a Social Club. D. Olson responded that a Banquet Hall may obtain a liquor license, but a Social Club cannot. He noted that the Commission may add other differentiating criteria. D. Castro asked if a Banquet Hall currently exists. D. Olson responded that Faranda’s operates as a Banquet Hall in the CBD. He stated that creating a Banquet Hall definition is not intended to exclude existing establishments. He added Faranda’s would become a legal non-conforming use if the Commission moves it to a special use in the CBD district. V. Buckley asked if a Social Club currently exists and whether problems prompted the discussion. Director Charlton reported that a business claiming to be a Banquet Hall recently located downtown but actually operated more like a Social Club. She reported that the lack of clarity in the Municipal Code and the UDO prevented the City from regulating the business appropriately, which is the reason for the discussion. The differences between a Social Club and a Banquet Hall were further discussed. Director Charlton cited the Social Club definition in Chapter 32, which prohibits liquor of any kind under any circumstances. She reported that original intent for the Social Club category was for venues serving patrons under the age of 21, but the Banquet Hall category is for venues serving all ages. She stated that a Banquet Hall is typically a meeting place rented for a specific event while a Social Club provides regular Planning and Zoning Commission May 17, 2017 Page 3 of 8 entertainment like a bar, but without alcohol. She noted that the City met recently with NIU students, and they requested more liquor-free venues and events. D. Nier suggested that a Social Club’s primary purpose is to host entertainment while a Banquet Hall’s primary purpose is to host special events and meetings that serve food. K. Barbe asked if fraternal organizations are categorized as Banquet Halls since they are allowed to serve liquor and rent out their facilities for special events. Director Charlton responded that they are a different category in the UDO, and renting out their facilities for special events is considered an accessory use, not a primary use. M. Crull recommended carefully crafting language for each category’s definition to include a list of criteria and the number of items that must be fulfilled for each category. He suggested designating the number of events during a certain period might be a useful for differentiating between a principal use and an accessory use. V. Buckley suggested that the definition for Social Clubs might specifying that patrons under the age of 21 are permitted. J. Wright asked if fraternal organizations are categorized as Social Clubs. Planner Olson responded that they are not; they are categorized as Clubs, Lodges, and Meeting Halls in the UDO. J. Wright asked how the proposed revisions will affect the Social Club that prompted the discussion. Director Charlton responded that the business owners have already ceased operation at the current location for a variety of reasons. J. Wright asked if the CBD district is the only one under discussion. Planner Olson responded that Banquet Halls are a permitted use in the CBD district and a special use in the LC district. He recommended Social Clubs be a special use in the GC district where zoning regulations for lighting, visibility, and sufficient parking are more easily met. He stated that the LC district is often closer to residential uses and not suitable for the use and the LI district does not usually provide adequate visibility and parking. Planner Olson reiterated that Faranda’s will not be affected if the Commission decides Banquet Hall should remain a permitted use in the CBD district. Chair Atherton asked if a Banquet Hall was denied a liquor license could it operate as a Banquet Hall without a liquor license. Director Charlton responded that liquor license approval is treated separately from zoning. She did not recommend including liquor license approval in the Banquet Hall definition. She said she would consult with the City Attorney for guidance about including liquor license regulations in the Social Club definition. V. Buckley asked for the chronology of liquor license and zoning approval. Planner Olson responded that both applications can be submitted at the same time, but they are considered separately initially. When presented to the City Council for final approval, they are usually presented at the same meeting. Planning and Zoning Commission May 17, 2017 Page 4 of 8 Article 14 Permits and Article 18 Appeals and Variances Planner Olson explained that for each Special Use, Rezoning, and Variance petition, the City requires public notification in the newspaper and letters to surrounding property owners. The City currently prepares and publishes the notice in the newspaper and mails the notice to property owner. Mr. Olson asked the Commission to consider approving the following procedural changes to reassign these tasks to applicants: • Notice of Public Hearing: Applicants would arrange and pay for the newspaper to publish their notices; City staff would continue to draft the text of the notices. • Property Owner Notification Letters: Applicants would print and pay the postage for the property owner notification letters; City staff would continue to review the address list, draft the text of the letters and provide the map(s) to be included in the letters. Director Charlton added that many municipalities already require applicants to perform these tasks, which protects the City from liability if a public hearing is delayed or if notification is questioned, and it will save City staff time and money. Chair Atherton asked what happens if an applicant does not publish a notice on time. Planner Olson responded that the applicant would receive instructions from the City for publishing the public notice and provide a copy of the certification of publication provided by the newspaper. The applicant will also sign an affidavit attesting to when and to whom the property owner notification letters were mailed. He stated that the City will inform the applicant of the deadlines that must be met, but if the applicant does not meet them, the hearing would need to be rescheduled, and the applicant would need to republish the notice and re-mail the letters. Planner Olson also asked the Commission to consider removing the requirement to include property legal descriptions in the notices, which state law no longer requires to be included, as long as a property’s common address and PIN is provided. He noted that the cost of publishing and mailing the notices for applicants will be less if lengthy legal descriptions are omitted. Article 20 Amendments Planner Olson stated that currently only the Planning and Zoning Commission and City Council can initiate petitions for text amendments and zoning map (rezoning) amendments. He asked the Commission to consider allowing City staff to initiate these petitions as well, which would speed up the hearing and approval processes. He noted that the public hearing process would continue to occur. In addition, he asked for approval of the following provisions: • If anyone other than City staff initiates a text amendment petition, that person would be responsible for the public hearing notice publication; City staff would continue to draft the notice text. • If anyone other than City staff initiates a zoning map (rezoning) amendment, that person would be responsible for printing and mailing the property owner notification letters; City staff would continue to draft the letter text, review the address list, and provide the timeline. Planning and Zoning Commission May 17, 2017 Page 5 of 8 He added that City staff would provide instructions and deadlines for the applicant, and the applicant would be required to sign an affidavit indicating the mailing was performed and a copy of the notification letter was sent to the City. D. Nier asked if there are disadvantages to these proposed amendments. Planner Olson responded that if the City oversees these processes, he anticipates no problems. He stated that it is possible but very unlikely for an applicant to make a mistake discovered afterwards. Mr. Olson assured the Commission that City staff would continue to help first-time applicants with each step of the process. D. Castro asked how much the notices cost the City. Planner Olson replied that the cost of publishing the notice varies depending on the length of the legal description, and the cost sending the letters varies depending upon the number of properties within 250-foot of the subject property. Director Charlton added that omitting the legal description in the newspaper notice and the letters will make them shorter and less expensive for applicants. D. Castro also voiced concern about relying upon the applicants to perform these tasks, especially ones unfamiliar with the process who are more likely to make a mistake. Planner Olson responded that the City would provide detailed instructions and provide help to the applicant whenever necessary. He added that he worked in a community where applicants performed these same tasks without significant difficulty. Director Charlton acknowledged that big developers have more experience than homeowners. She reported that City staff meets more frequently with less experienced applicants to ensure the process moves along smoothly. Mr. Planner Olson agreed that the City would continue to provide oversight to ensure completion of each step. Chair Atherton recommended that the City provide to applicants a document that outlines the process and a checklist and make it available online as well. V. Buckley related her experience in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida, where online documents and processes were available to applicants, who had no difficulty with the processes. Chair Atherton voiced concern about applicants having difficulty. Planner Olson explained that only the responsibility for delivery and payment for these items would change. The City would still draft the text to ensure the language is accurate. M. Crull recommended staff to put in place a vigorous verification process to ensure no property owner is excluded from the mailing. He asked how the City would address a complaint that someone had been excluded from the mailing. Planner Olson responded that the likely course of action would be to continue the hearing to a later date, with publication of an updated public meeting notice and mailing of updated letters. Director Charlton added that the burden would be placed upon the complaining party to provide evidence of being harmed by not receiving the notice letter. Planning and Zoning Commission May 17, 2017 Page 6 of 8 M. Crull asked for clarification of how the City would confirm a mailing was performed. Planner Olson responded that the applicant’s signed affidavit with the list of addresses will be sufficient. Director Charlton added that the applicant would also mail the letter to the City, which will postmarked. Article 19 Non-Conforming Situations – Non-conforming Use of a Building Planner Olson ask the Commission to consider amending the UDO requirement that a nonconforming use of a building be discontinued upon change of ownership, use, or tenancy. He stated that the City does not receive notification prior to a change of ownership on properties, so this is difficult to enforce. He recommended retaining the requirement for nonconforming uses to discontinue upon change of use or tenancy or if the nonconforming use is discontinued for more than six months. Director Charlton added that this problem arises often when a single-family residential zoned property with a nonconforming two-flat changes ownership. She reported that the new owner has two options: (1) to discontinue the two-unit use or (2) petition for rezoning. She noted that the City does not require a property transfer stamp, so 90% of property ownership changes go unnoticed by the City. Chair Atherton recalled when the Commission discussed if a restaurant’s nonconforming patio would be allowed to continue to be used if a new owner purchased the restaurant. She also recalled when the Commission decided that a nonconforming two-unit home was not allowed to continue to be used by a new owner. D. Castro asked if allowing nonconforming uses to continue after a sale would prevent neighborhoods from moving toward the goal of conformity with the UDO. He stated that his neighbors want nonconforming two-units in his neighborhood to revert to single- family homes. He stated that allowing new owners to inherit a legal nonconforming status may not be beneficial to the City. He suggested that better tracking of property sales, which is public information, could help the city enforce nonconforming use regulations. Planner Olson responded that property sales are public information after a sale is final, and it would not be ideal to notify a new owner of the requirement to end a property’s nonconforming use after the fact. D. Nier suggested that allowing a nonconforming uses to continue after a sale conflicts with the Comprehensive Plan’s goal to remove undesirable and incompatible land uses. She voiced concern that grandfathering nonconforming uses as legal for new owners could be detrimental to surrounding properties. D. Castro suggested that if the City does not enforce the regulation for nonconforming uses to revert to conforming uses, the whole City could become legal nonconforming. Director Charlton stated that the best means to enforce the regulation of nonconforming uses would be to institute a property transfer stamp, which the Commission could discuss with the City Council. Planning and Zoning Commission May 17, 2017 Page 7 of 8 D. Nier noted that other municipalities require a transfer stamp, but it is not a popular discussion. She added that if even 1% of properties sold with nonconforming uses are reverted to conforming uses, the regulation can be considered successful. V. Buckley said that many homes in her neighborhood were divided into multiple units long ago, and requiring new owners to renovate these back into single-family may be difficult. Director Charlton reported that bank and insurance agents frequently contact the City to ask if a nonconforming building is destroyed can it be rebuilt as it is today. She explained that extensive supporting documentation from the owner would be necessary to confirm if a nonconforming use were legally established. She added that many new owners are unaware they have purchased properties with nonconforming uses, and they are unhappy when they call the City for assistance to learn they must discontinue nonconforming uses. D. Castro stated that some real estate agents educate buyers about nonconforming use regulations while others are motivated to make sales without regard to those regulations. V. Buckley asked if legal nonconforming properties are currently a big problem or if the City is looking forward to possible future issues. Planner Olson responded that it is hard to tell how many nonconforming uses continue after ownership changes, but the City does receive many phone calls asking if they are allowed. He noted the RC-1 zoning district allows nonconforming uses to continue provided the designated land use category allows it, but single-family zoning districts currently require multi-unit uses be discontinued upon change of ownership. Director Charlton added that tracking illegal nonconforming uses is also a challenge. She explained that illegal uses are never transferrable to new owners. She reported that the City often becomes aware of illegal uses when buyers ask the City if building permits were issued for the renovations that created additional units. She explained that the burden is upon the property owner to prove a nonconforming use is legal. If no proof exists, owners must discontinue illegal uses and make the property comply with zoning regulations. V. Buckley asked if current property owners are creating new nonconforming uses. Planner Olson responded that these are hard to track unless an owner applies for rezoning or a permit. Director Charlton added that when the City discovers new nonconforming or illegal uses, the City cites owners for code violations and instructs them they must discontinue the nonconforming uses and bring the properties back into compliance. V. Buckley asked if the City approves new legal nonconforming uses. Planner Olson responded that the City is not normally aware when a new nonconforming use is created. Director Charlton added that the City does not grant legal nonconforming uses, but a property owner may apply to rezone the property. Planning and Zoning Commission May 17, 2017 Page 8 of 8 Director Charlton reported that the City recently became aware of an illegal nonconforming dwelling above a garage. A former property owner obtained a building permit to construct a new garage with storage space above. Years later, when a new property owner applied for a building permit to perform work in the unit above the garage, the City informed him that it was an illegal use and required him to discontinue using it. All Articles of UDO Planner Olson reported that current positions, titles, departments, commissions, and the name of the Kishwaukee Water Reclamation District should be updated in the UDO. G. REPORTS / ITEMS FOR NEXT MEETING Upcoming Commission meetings • June 7 – No hearings are scheduled, but a meeting may be necessary. • June 21 – Public hearing on proposed UDO text amendments. City Council action • May 8 – Mobil gas station proposed at N. First St. and Hillcrest Dr. I. ADJOURNMENT K. Barbe motioned to adjourn, V. Buckley seconded the motion, and the motion was approved by unanimous voice vote. The meeting adjourned at 7:11 PM. Respectfully Submitted, Natalie Nelson, Administrative Assistant Minutes were approved by the Planning and Zoning Commission on June 21, 2017.

Agenda

Council Chambers 200 S. Fourth St., 2nd Floor DeKalb, IL 60115 AGENDA Planning and Zoning Commission May 17, 2017 6:00 PM A. ROLL CALL B. APPROVAL OF AGENDA (Additions or Deletions) C. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION (Open Floor to Anyone Wishing to Speak on Record) D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. April 26, 2017 E. OLD BUSINESS None F. NEW BUSINESS 1. Workshop Text amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance. G. REPORTS/ITEMS FOR NEXT MEETING H. ADJOURNMENT MINUTES CITY OF DEKALB PLANNING AND ZONING COMMISSION April 26, 2017 The Planning and Zoning Commission held a Meeting on April 26, 2017 at the City of DeKalb Municipal Building, 200 S. Fourth St., DeKalb, Illinois. Chair Atherton called the meeting to order at 6:00 PM. A. ROLL CALL Natalie Nelson called the roll. Members of the Planning and Zoning Commission present at roll call: Katharina Barbe, David Castro, Matthew Crull, and Chair Christina Atherton. Members absent were Vicki Buckley, Deborah Nier, and Jerry Wright. City staff present were Community Development Director Jo Ellen Charlton, Principal Planner Dan Olson, and Administrative Assistant Natalie Nelson. B. APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA (Additions/Deletions) Chair Atherton requested a motion to approve the April 26, 2017 agenda as presented. K. Barbe motioned to approve the agenda, D. Castro seconded the motion, and the motion was approved by unanimous voice vote. C. PUBLIC PARTICIPATION (Open Floor to Anyone Wishing to Speak on Record) None. D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES 1. March 29, 2017 – Chair Atherton requested a motion to approve the March 29, 2017 minutes as presented. M. Crull motioned to approve the minutes as presented, K. Barbe seconded the motion, and the motion was approved by unanimous voice vote. 2. April 12, 2017 – Chair Atherton requested a motion to approve the April 12, 2017 minutes as presented. M. Crull motioned to approve the minutes as presented, D. Castro seconded the motion, and the motion was approved by unanimous voice vote. E. OLD BUSINESS None Planning and Zoning Commission April 26, 2017 Page 2 of 6 F. NEW BUSINESS 1. Public hearing on a petition by Blackhawk Road, LLC, represented by Stefan Wereminski, for a Zoning Map Amendment from the “MFR2” Multiple Family Residential District to the “PD-R” Planned Development - Residential District, approval of Planned Development Preliminary Plans to allow for the reestablishment of a fraternity on the subject site located at 1114 Blackhawk Road. Waivers to the Unified Development Ordinance are being requested for the minimum lot size for a Planned Development, the number of required parking spaces, parking lot design and locational requirements, landscaping and other approvals as required for redevelopment of the property. PETITIONER PRESENTATION Stefan Wereminski, President of the Alumni Housing Association for Sigma Nu at Northern Illinois University, presented before the Commission. He stated that the subject property will be the fraternity house for the NIU-recognized fraternity Sigma Nu. Mr. Wereminski discussed the planned interior and exterior improvements. The plans include resurfacing the existing parking lot and expanding it to provide 42 parking spaces, reconfiguring the access drive at Kimberly Dr., and adding a new access point to Edgebrook Dr. He explained the planned landscaping improvements, including pruning existing plantings, removing two existing trees, and adding four new trees. Safety improvements will include exterior LED lighting and security cameras, which will be available for DeKalb Police Department review. Interior improvements include LED lighting, boiler replacement, radiator repairs, new high-efficiency water heaters, fire sprinkler installation, and fire alarm warning system replacement. To comply with ADA accessibility requirements, two accessible parking spaces and an exterior ramp to access the first floor will be added. In addition, the common restrooms and one dorm room on the first floor will be renovated to become accessible. STAFF REPORT Principal Planner Dan Olson presented on behalf of the City of DeKalb. He reported that the proposed improvements to the subject property will cost approximately $340,000. He stated that the building has 29 bedrooms, which will be allowed to house up to 45 residents. He summarized the petition for rezoning the property from the MFR-2 district to the PD-R district, approving the preliminary plan, and approving certain waivers to UDO requirements. Mr. Olson reported that the petitioner’s initial parking plan proposed only resurfacing the current lot with 21 spaces, to which staff responded that more parking was need and access to Edgebrook Dr. should be added. Although the UDO requires 45 parking spaces for 45 residents, Mr. Olson stated that staff is Planning and Zoning Commission April 26, 2017 Page 3 of 6 satisfied with the revised plan to provide 42 parking spaces, including two new ADA accessible spaces. He noted that the petitioner researched parking at fraternities and sororities in DeKalb and in other university communities and found that the UDO requires significantly more parking. Mr. Olson emphasized importance of providing adequate off-street parking in the area, which limits street parking. Mr. Olson stated that the fraternity plans to move from their current apartment complex to the subject property, which will require a City-issued rooming house license. He noted that past rooming house licenses permitted up to 61 occupants in the building; the proposed 45 occupants is significantly less. He added that the building will comply the pending State of Illinois fire sprinkler regulations and the current ADA regulations. Mr. Olson summarized the petitioner’s requested waivers to UDO regulations: • To allow a planned development on a subject site that is .7 acres; the UDO requires a minimum size of 2 acres. • To allow 42 parking spaces to serve 45 occupants; the UDO requires one parking space per occupant. • To modify required parking lot design elements and landscaping, and to omit required curbs and gutters; the UDO requires certain setbacks, curbs and gutters, and landscaping. He also reported that the City Engineer reviewed the parking lot plan, two-thirds of which is already paved, and approved the omission of curbs and gutters due to nearby catch basins that can handle the property’s storm water runoff. Mr. Olson discussed how the petitioner’s plans meet the Standards of Rezoning and the objectives set forth in the City’s 2005 Comprehensive Plan. He cited the Greek Row Neighborhood Revitalization Plan from 2002, which supports the re- establishment of a fraternity on the subject property. He reported that adjacent properties have similar zoning and uses. He stated that the improvements will have a positive effect on the neighborhood, and existing utilities and public facilities currently serve the site. He provided a summary of Exhibit A, which lists the preliminary site plan and floor plan, the permitted uses, the prohibited uses, and the development standards. He noted the permitted uses regulations for maximum number of occupants per room, maximum number of residents, maximum number of bedrooms, and existing group meeting areas and food service facilities. He also summarized Exhibit B, including required submissions of a photometric plan, landscaping plan, trash enclosure design, addition of the parking lot formula to the site plan, the vacation of a utility easement, and final engineering plans. Mr. Olson stated that City staff recommends approval of the petition. Planning and Zoning Commission April 26, 2017 Page 4 of 6 CITIZEN COMMENTS At 6:17 PM, Chair Atherton noted three individuals in the audience chose not to speak and closed the public hearing. COMMISSION DISCUSSION Chair Atherton invited Commission discussion. Commissioner Castro asked if the lighting plan has been submitted. Mr. Olson confirmed it has not yet been received. Mr. Castro noted that the current lighting in the area is poor at night, and the proposed improvements will help alleviate the problem. Mr. Castro asked for clarification of required number of parking spaces. D. Olson replied that the UDO requires fraternities and sororities to provide one parking space for each occupant. Mr. Castro thanked the petitioner and staff for working together to develop the revised parking plan. He also thanked the petitioner for providing for Commission consideration the research on parking requirements at similar locations. Mr. Castro asked about the plans for area in which the subject property is located. Director Charlton replied that the property is located within the Northwest Corridor or Annie Glidden North. She reported that the City will be working with a consultant to evaluate the area’s existing conditions and develop future plans. She noted that the area was initially developed to serve student populations, but due to declining university enrollment, many families with different needs have moved into the area. She reported that every City department is committed to addressing the area’s unique challenges. She stated that the planning project will begin in July and continue into the first quarter of 2018, and the City will invite members of campus populations and different interest groups to participate. Mr. Castro added that the subject property’s planned improvements and use are similar to that of other nearby properties. Commissioner Barbe asked why the data presented in the research for other Greek housing includes the number of parking spaces but not the number residents. Mr. Olson replied that the petitioner tried to obtain that data but was unable to do so. Ms. Barbe asked for a description of the current condition of the property. Mr. Wereminski replied that the landscaping has been neglected and the building has been vacant for about two years, leading to weed overgrowth and some interior building damage. However, he noted, the building’s concrete block construction is sound and the mechanical work will be easy and fast. Planning and Zoning Commission April 26, 2017 Page 5 of 6 Ms. Barbe asked if the budget will be sufficient for the proposed improvements. Mr. Wereminski reported that remodeling two restrooms and upgrading the mechanical systems will be the largest expenses, but painting and installing new LED light fixtures in the 29 unfurnished bedrooms will be economical. Ms. Barbe asked for clarification of the purpose for rooms in the basement. Mr. Wereminski replied that a building manager, house parent, or live-in graduate advisor may use them. Ms. Barbe asked if a door will be installed in the basement between the office area and the living area. Mr. Wereminski confirmed that a door will be installed. M. Crull voiced approval of the plans and stated that although sufficient off-street parking is an issue, the building will likely not be at maximum occupancy any time soon due to university enrollment. He asked if public parking exists nearby for overflow vehicles and how a future increased demand for parking will be addressed. Mr. Wereminski reported he has discussed future parking plans with City staff. He noted that a nearby strip mall offers a limited number of rental parking spaces. He reported that many of the current fraternity members do not own cars, and their current apartment complex’s 22 parking spaces have been sufficient for them. He stated that the new fraternity house lease will require a resident with car to obtain a parking permit for the fraternity house lot or provide proof of a school- year parking permit from the university. Chair Atherton asked for clarification of the list of permitted uses in Exhibit A, specifically the maximum numbers of bedrooms and occupants. Mr. Wereminski explained that each of the 29 bedrooms will have one or two occupants, never three, with a maximum of 45 total residents. Chair Atherton asked if the petitioner has obtained the appropriate approval to allow the fraternity to move into the building on the subject property. Mr. Wereminski responded that the fraternity’s national organization has enthusiastically approved the plan. D. Castro asked if the building may be occupied while the work is performed. D. Olson responded that occupancy approval will not be granted until all work is complete, which is expected in August before the fall semester begins. He added that the fraternity closed on the purchase of building earlier in April, so work can commence as soon as the current petition is approved. Director Charlton announced that an individual joined the audience during the Commission discussion and asked if he might comment. Chair Atherton replied that the public hearing portion of the meeting was closed and could not be reopened. Hearing and seeing no further Commission or City staff discussion, Chair Atherton requested a motion. Planning and Zoning Commission April 26, 2017 Page 6 of 6 MOTION M. Crull motioned that, based upon the submitted petition and testimony presented, he moved that the Planning and Zoning Commission forward its findings of fact and recommend to the City Council approval of a Zoning Map Amendment from the “MFR2” Multiple Family Residential District to the “PD-R” Planned Development - Residential District and approval of Planned Development Plan to allow for the re-establishment of a fraternity on the subject site located at 1114 Blackhawk Road per the Planned Development Plans and standards listed on Exhibit A of the Staff Report and subject to the conditions listed on Exhibit B of the Staff Report. K. Barbe seconded the motion. VOTE Chair Atherton requested a roll call vote. Yea – K. Barbe, D. Castro, M. Crull, and Chair Atherton. Nay – none. Absent – V. Buckley, D. Nier, and J. Wright. The motion passed 4-0-3. G. REPORTS / ITEMS FOR NEXT MEETING Principal Planner Olson announced that the May 3rd Planning and Zoning Commission meeting will be canceled. He also reported upon recent City Council actions: • Approval of the annexation and rezoning of Kishwaukee Country Club, • Approval of rezoning of 1015 Blackhawk Road, • First reading of the special use permit petition for the Mobil gas station, and the second reading will take place at the first City Council meeting in May. Chair Atherton thanked Mayor Rey for his service to the City. She noted that Mayor Rey was responsible for appointing everyone on the Commission except for her, and she thanked him for appointing her fellow Commission members, which she commended for their work as well. I. ADJOURNMENT Seeing and hearing no further comments, Chair Atherton requested a motion to adjourn. Barbe motioned to adjourn, Castro seconded the motion, and the motion was unanimously approved by voice vote. The meeting adjourned at 6:35 PM Respectfully Submitted, Natalie Nelson, Administrative Assistant Minutes were approved by the Planning and Zoning Commission on . City of DeKalb Planning and Zoning Commission Staff Report DATE: May 12, 2017 TO: Planning and Zoning Commission Members FROM: Jo Ellen Charlton, Community Development Director Dan Olson, Principal Planner SUBJECT: Discussion - Text Amendments to the Unified Development Ordinance GENERAL INFORMATION: The staff wanted to bring forward to the Planning and Zoning Commission some possible text amendment to the Unified Development Ordinance (UDO) for further discussion. REVIEW AND ANALYSIS: Article 3 “Definitions” and Article 5 “Zoning District Regulations” – Social Clubs and Banquet Halls Chapter 32 “Business Regulations” of the Municipal Code has provisions for Social Clubs, which was added to the Code in 2014 (see attached Chapter in packet).There is a definition provided and licensing procedures. However, Social Club is not listed in the UDO as a permitted or special use in any zoning district. There are potential issues and conflicts with classifying a Social Club under one of the uses currently listed in the UDO. Banquet Halls is a use that could encompass a Social Club, however there is no definition for Banquet Halls in the UDO. Banquet Halls are currently listed as a Special Use in the “LC” Light Commercial District and a Permitted Use in the “GC” General Commercial District and the “CBD” Central Business District. We would recommend that a definition for Banquet Halls be provided that distinguishes itself clearly from Social Clubs and that it be moved from a Permitted Use in the “GC” and “CBD” Districts to a Special Use. We would also recommend that Social Clubs be added to the UDO as a special use in the appropriate zoning PZC073-16 district(s) and the definition be added. If the amendments are approved, any existing Banquet Hall in the City would be considered a legal non-conforming use and would fall under the regulations of Article 19 “Non-Conforming Situations” of the UDO. Article 14 Permits and Article 18 Appeals and Variances The current regulations require the Community Development Director to publish a notice for a special use permit or variance request in the newspaper and send it to the property owners within 250 feet of the subject site. We are proposing that Article 14 and 18 be amended so that the applicant who initiates a special use permit or variance request be responsible to publish the hearing notice in the newspaper and send the notice to property owners within 250 feet of the subject site. The City staff will still draft the public hearing notice, but the applicant will be responsible to submit it to the newspaper and mail it to surrounding property owners and will therefore be responsible for the cost of publication and mailing. To verify the property owners were mailed a notice by the applicant, we will require an affidavit be signed by the applicant indicating the mailing was performed. State law allows for a public hearing notice for a special use permit or variance need not include a metes and bounds legal description of the area provided the notice includes: 1) the common street address or addresses and 2) the property index number (“PIN”) or numbers of all the parcels of the area. We are proposing language be added to the Article to allow this as an option for public hearing notices. Article 19 Non-Conforming Situations Article 19.05 provides regulations for non-conforming uses located in buildings and structures (Article 19 provided in packet). One of the regulations states “When a non-conforming use of a building or structure changes ownership, use or tenancy, the legal non-conforming use must be discontinued”. The UDO does require a Certificate of Use and Occupancy to be issued by the City prior to the use or occupancy in a newly constructed building, altered building or change in a building, or of a property. We do not, however, have a good way to track changes of ownership of property if nothing else changes on the site. We propose that Article 19.05 be amended to remove the requirement that a legal non-conforming use of a building or structure must be discontinued if a change of ownership occurs. We would recommend that changes in use or tenancy remain in the language as they can be tracked by the Certificate of Use and Occupancy. Consideration should be also given to amending Article 19.03 so that changes in the use or tenancy of a non-conforming use of a parcel, on which no building exist, must be brought into compliance with the UDO. Page |2 Article 20 Amendments Text Amendments The current regulations allow text amendments to be initiated by the City Council or the Planning and Zoning Commission, or which may be initiated by them in response to a request by any City Board or staff member. We are proposing that language be added to allow staff to initiate text amendments. Any amendment would still require a public hearing in front of the Commission and final approval by the City Council. This amendment could potentially reduce the time to have a text amendment approved through the process. Text Amendments may also be initiated by any other person as long as an application and filing fee is submitted. A text amendment is required to be published in the newspaper at least 15 days prior to the public hearing. We would propose the language be amended to require that if any other person initiates a text amendment (beyond the City) that they publish the notice in the newspaper. The City staff will still draft the public hearing notice, but the applicant will be required to submit it to the newspaper and will therefore be responsible for the cost of publication. Map Amendments The vast majority of map amendments (re-zoning) are initiated by the property owner. As with the text amendments, proposed map amendments can also be initiated the City Council or the Planning and Zoning Commission, or which may be initiated by them in response to a request by any City Board or staff member. We are proposing that language be added to allow staff to initiate map amendments also. Any amendment would still require a public hearing in front of the Commission and final approval by the City Council. We are also proposing that the applicant who initiates a map amendment request be responsible to publish the hearing notice in the newspaper and send the notice to the property owners within 250 feet of the subject site. The City staff will still draft the public hearing notice, but the applicant will be required to submit it to the newspaper and mail it to surrounding property owners and will therefore be responsible for the cost of publication and mailing. To verify the property owners were mailed a notice by the applicant, we will require an affidavit be signed by the applicant indicating the mailing was performed. State law allows that any public hearing notice for map amendments need not include a metes and bounds legal description of the area provided the notice includes: 1) the common street address or addresses and 2) the property index number (“PIN”) or numbers of all the parcels of the area proposed for the map amendment. We are proposing language be added to the UDO to allow this as an option for public hearing notices. Page |3 All Articles of UDO Correct references to appointed bodies, City departments and positions should be updated. For example the Planning and Zoning Commission is referenced as the Plan Commission in several areas of the UDO. The Department of Planning should be replaced with the Community Development Department. The DeKalb Sanitary District recently changed their name to the Kishwaukee Water Reclamation District and their reference in the UDO should be updated. SUMMARY/RECOMMENDATION: No official action or motion is required. Staff asks the Commission to provide comments per the discussion items in the memo. With the Commission’s input and authorization, staff will prepare and process a text amendment application and public hearing notice, which would allow for additional public comment via the hearing process. Final authority to amend any regulations regarding the UDO rests with the City Council. We plan to set a public hearing date of June 21, 2017 in front of the Commission regarding the proposed text amendments. Page |4 Municipal Code - City of DeKalb Chapter 32, “Business Regulations” Chapter 32 BUSINESS REGULATIONS Revision Date: 8-30-14 Sections: 32.01 AUCTIONEERS. (Deleted 00-44) 32.02 PAWNBROKER REGULATION ACT. 32.02-5 RECORD IN INK -- IDENTIFICATION REQUIRED. 32.04 LICENSE. 32.05 BUILDING MOVERS. 32.06 GARAGE SALES (04-65) 32.07 GOING OUT OF BUSINESS. 32.08 SOCIAL CLUBS. (2014-28) 32.01 AUCTIONEERS. (Deleted 00-44) 32.02 PAWNBROKER REGULATION ACT. a) Pawnbroker Defined. Every person or company engaged in the business of receiving property in pledge or as security for money or other thing advanced to the pawner or pledger, shall be held and is hereby declared and defined to be a pawnbroker. b) It shall be unlawful for any pawnbroker to charge or collect a greater benefit or percentage upon money advance and for the use and forbearance thereof, than the rate of 3% per month. Nothing in this Section shall be construed so as to conflict with the law pertaining to usury and the person receiving money so advanced may hold such moneys to pay any fees in addition to interest as herein provided. c) Each pawnbroker may contract for and receive such fees in addition to interest authorized by this section, as set forth herein, for investigating title, storage and insuring the collateral, closing the loan, making daily reports to local law enforcement officers, and for other expenses and losses of every nature whatsoever, and for all other services. Such fees, when made and collected, shall not be deemed interest for any purpose of law. d) Every pawnbroker, when making a loan under this Section, shall be entitled to charge and collect a one time fee for each loan for services rendered as set forth in the following schedule. 1. For loans not exceeding $100 a fee not to exceed $12. 2. For loans exceeding $100 but not over $250, a fee not to exceed $25. 3. For loans exceeding $250 but not over $500 a fee not to exceed $35. 4. For loan exceeding $500 but not over $1000 a fee not to exceed $50. Chapter 32 - 1 Municipal Code - City of DeKalb Chapter 32, “Business Regulations” 5. For loans exceeding $1000 a fee not to exceed 5% of the loan principal. (93-41) 32.02-5 RECORD IN INK -- IDENTIFICATION REQUIRED. a) Every pawn and loan broker shall keep a standard record book that has been approved by the Police Chief for the purpose of his business, in which shall be written in ink, at the time of each and every loan or taking of a pledge, an accurate account and description, in the English language, of all the goods, articles and other things pawned or pledged, the amount of money, value or thing loan thereon, the time of pledging the same, the rate of interest to be paid on such loan, and the name and residence of the person making such loan or pledge. Such entry shall include the serial number or identification number of items received which are required to bear such number. Every pawnbroker shall also record in his book, an accurate account and description, in the English language, of all goods, articles and other things purchased or received for the purpose of resale or loan collateral by the pawnbroker from any source, not in the course of a pledge or loan, the time of such purchase or receipt and the name and address of the person or business which sold or delivered such goods, articles, or other things to the pawnbroker. No entry in such book shall be erased, mutilated or changed. b) Every pawnbroker shall require 2 forms of identification to be shown him by each person pledging or pawning any good, articles or other things to the pawnbroker. Any of the two forms of identification must include his or her residence address. These forms of identification shall include, but not be limited to, any of the following: driver's license, social security card, utility bill, employee or student identification card, credit card, or a civic, union or professional association membership card. c) Inspection. The said book, as well as every article or other thing of value so pawned or pledged, shall at all times be open to the inspection of the sheriff of the county, his deputies or any members of the police force of any city in the county in which such pawnbroker does business. d) Daily Report. It shall be the duty of every pawnbroker to make out and deliver to the sheriff of the county in which such pawnbroker does business, on each day before the hours of 12 o'clock noon, a legible and exact copy from the standard record book, as required above in this ordinance, that lists all personal property and other valuable things received on deposit or purchased during the preceding day, together with the exact time when received or purchased, and a description of the person or person by whom left in pledge, or from whom the same were purchased; provided that in cities or towns having twenty-five thousand or more inhabitants, a copy of the such report shall at the same time also be delivered to the police chief of such city or town. e) Property From Minor. No pawnbroker shall take or receive an pawn or pledge for any advancement or loan, any property of any kind from any minor who is under 18 years of age, or the ownership of which is in, or which is claimed by, any such minor, or which may be in the possession or under the control of any such minor. f) Property From Intoxicated Person Or Thief--Return Of Stolen Property. No pawnbroker shall purchase or take any article in pawn or pledge from nay person appearing to be intoxicated, nor from any person known to have been convicted of theft. A law enforcement officer may provide such criminal conviction information to a pawnbroker. When any person is found to be the owner of stolen property which has been pawned, such property shall be returned to the owner thereof without the payment of the money advanced by the pawnbroker thereon or any costs or charges of any kind which the pawnbroker may have placed upon the same. g) Sale of Property. No personal property received on deposit or pledge, or purchased by any such Chapter 32 - 2 Municipal Code - City of DeKalb Chapter 32, “Business Regulations” pawnbroker, shall be sold or permitted to be redeemed or removed from the place of business of such pawnbroker for the space of twenty-four hours after the delivery of the copy and statement required above by this Ordinance to be delivered to he officer or officers named therein; and no personal property pawned or pledged shall be sold or disposed of by any such pawnbroker within one year from the time when the pawner or pledger shall make default in payment so advance by such pawnbroker, unless by the written consent of such pawner or pledger. h) Violations. Every pawnbroker who knowingly violates the provision of this Ordinance shall, for the first offense, be guilty of a Class C misdemeanor, with a fine of not less than $100.00, and for each subsequent offense shall be guilty of a Class A misdemeanor, with a fine of not less than 500.00. (93-41) 32.04 LICENSE. a) It shall be unlawful for any person to engage in the City of DeKalb in the business for a pawnbroker, as defined by the laws of the State of Illinois and the ordinances of the City of DeKalb, without a license therefor issued by the City of DeKalb. (81-64) b) Application for License. Applications for a pawnbroker's license shall be made to the City Clerk of the City of DeKalb on forms provided by the City Clerk. Said application shall be in writing; signed by the applicant, if an individual, or by a duly authorized agent thereof, if a club, partnership, or corporation, verified by oath or affidavit; and shall be accompanied with a non-refundable application fee of Fifty Dollars ($50.00). Said application shall be referred to the City Manager, who shall grant or deny said license. Upon approval by the City Manager, said license shall be issued by the City Clerk. Said license shall be valid for one (1) year, commencing on the first day of May and ending on the last day of April. Said license may be renewed upon the licensee submitting an application for a license to the City Clerk. There shall be a renewal fee of Twenty Five Dollars ($25.00). Said application for a pawnbroker's license shall contain the following information and statements. (81-64) 1. The name, age, and address of the applicant in the case of an individual; in the case of a partnership, the persons entitled to share in the profits thereof, and in the case of a corporation, for profit, or a club, the date of incorporation, the objects for which it was organized, the names and addresses of the officers and directors, and if a majority in interest of the stock of such corporation is owned by one person or his nominees, the name and address of such person; (81-64) 2. The citizenship of the applicant, his place of birth, and if a naturalized citizen, the time and place of naturalization; (81-64) 3. The character of business of the applicant; and in case of a corporation, the objects for which it was formed; (81-64) 4. The length of time that said applicant has been in business of that character; or in the case of a corporation, the date on which its charter was issued; (81-64) 5. The amount of goods, wares, and merchandise on hand at the time the application is made; (81-64) 6. The location and description of the premises or place of business which is to be operated under such license; (81-64) 7. A statement whether applicant has made similar application for a similar license on premises other than described in this application, and the disposition of such application; (81-64) Chapter 32 - 3 Municipal Code - City of DeKalb Chapter 32, “Business Regulations” 8. A statement that the applicant does beneficially own the premises or does have a lease thereon for the full period for which the license is to be issued; (81-64) 9. A statement that the applicant has never been convicted of a felony; (81-64) 10. A statement that the applicant has never been convicted of the following offenses: Theft; Theft of Lost/Mislaid Property; Forgery; Deceptive Altering/Sale of Coins; Robbery; Armed Robbery, Burglary; Possession of Burglary Tools; Unlawful Sale of Firearms; Criminal Usury; Juice Racketeering. 11. A statement that the applicant has never been convicted of violating any municipal or county pawnbroker’s ordinance. (81-64) 12. A statement that if a partnership, all members of the partnership shall be qualified to obtain a license; and, whether a previous license by any state or subdivision thereof, or by the federal government has been revoked, and the reason therefor. (93-41) 32.05 BUILDING MOVERS. Building Movers deleted. Refer to Chapter 24.04. c) 9. "Moving a Structure;" Chapter 24.03, Bonds; & Chapter 6.11. "Street Construction, Maintenance Operations & Utility Work". (93-64) 32.06 GARAGE SALES. a) It shall be unlawful for any person, group of persons, or organization to sell or offer for sale any secondhand household goods, clothing or other articles of personal property at what is commonly called a rummage, yard or garage sale on more than three (3) occasions in a calendar year if such sales are conducted in any residential zoned (SFR-1, SFR-2, TFR, or MFR) district of the City. Each of the three (3) allowable occasions in a calendar year shall be limited to not more than three (3) consecutive days. b) Any person, group of persons, or organization who knowingly violates this provision shall be fined not less than One Hundred Dollars ($100.00) nor more than Five Hundred Dollars ($500.00) for each offense and a separate offense shall be deemed committed on each day during, or on which a violation occurs or continues. (04-65) 32.07 GOING OUT OF BUSINESS. There is hereby adopted by reference the provisions of Illinois Revised Statutes, Chapter 121-1/2, Section 157.1-157.12 (815 ILCS 350). Three copies of such statute are on file and kept in the office of the City Clerk and available for public use, inspection and examination, and have been so on file for a period of thirty days prior to adoption of this ordinance incorporating such Statute. (78-20) Duration of Sale - License Fee. A fee of Twenty-five Dollars ($25.00) shall be charged for a license period of sixty (60) days from the start of such sale, with an additional thirty (30) days granted, if necessary, at no charge. (88-57) 32.08 SOCIAL CLUBS (2014-28) a) Definition of Social Club: Any business or organization which is open to the public (either generally open or available through the purchase of tickets or entry), the primary function of which is to offer, provide, Chapter 32 - 4 Municipal Code - City of DeKalb Chapter 32, “Business Regulations” procure, make available, allow, suffer or permit entertainment to patrons, consisting of dancing and/or the enjoyment of live or pre-recorded music, and/or the enjoyment of entertainment provided by dancers, comedians, fighters/boxers/martial-artists or other performers, with or without food, in an indoor venue. A Social Club shall not include: a) an establishment with a valid liquor license issued by the City of DeKalb; b) theaters which seat patrons in parallel rows of fixed seats, with seating capacity of 1,000 patrons or more; c) outdoor performances; d) any business, organization or event conducted by a component part of a unit of government; e) full service restaurants that feature background music incidental to the primary function of serving food; f) movie theaters with at least 4 separate theaters, each with fixed seating for 100 patrons or more; or, g) fraternities or sororities that are recognized by, registered with and affiliated with Northern Illinois University and which have a then-current charter/approval from the University. b) License Required: It shall be unlawful to operate a Social Club, either as a fixed use within an establishment or as a temporary or special event, without first obtaining a license issued by the City of DeKalb. Violation of this Ordinance shall be punishable by a fine of not less than Seven Hundred and Fifty Dollars ($750.00) per occurrence, and each day that a violation exists shall be deemed to be a separate occurrence. In addition, in the event that the City proves a violation of this Ordinance, the City shall be entitled to recover any costs incurred by the City in responding to the violation or the entity generating the violation, including but not limited to personnel and equipment costs for police or fire department responses to the establishment, or to patrons entering or exiting the establishment. c) License Application and Process: 1. Application shall be made to the City of DeKalb for a license under this Ordinance on a form acceptable to the City Manager, substantially in the form of a liquor license application and containing the same information as required on a liquor license application, with such additional information as shall be required by the City Manager or designee (including details of operation, parking arrangements and any other required information). The applicant shall be required to provide a detailed security plan for review and approval by the Chief of Police or designee, and shall be required to designate one or more managers, at least one of whom shall be on premises at all times that the establishment is in operation. 2. Applicants shall be required to comply with the provisions of City Code Section 38.06 for provision of insurance (other than dram shop insurance). Proof of insurance shall be required at time of application. 3. Applicants shall be required to obtain a Fire Life Safety License for their proposed establishment prior to applying for a license under this Ordinance. Applicants shall also be required to complete any other City applications and obtain any other City permits, permissions or inspections prior to application for a license under this Ordinance. 4. Prior to issuance of a license under this Ordinance, the proposed establishment shall be fully built- out and shall have been issued a certificate of occupancy. The establishment must be in full conformance with all applicable local, state and federal regulations. 5. After satisfying all conditions precedent as outlined above, successfully completing a background check for all owners and managers of the facility (utilizing the procedure utilized for liquor license applications) and then submitting a completed application and posting the application deposit, the City shall thereafter have a period of forty-five (45) days for staff review and evaluation of the application. Staff review shall include any recommendations regarding public safety concerns, appropriateness of siting and zoning, available parking, proximity to schools or other age-sensitive installations, noise generation, adequacy of site lighting, and any other relevant considerations. If any conditions are discovered during such review that Chapter 32 - 5 Municipal Code - City of DeKalb Chapter 32, “Business Regulations” constitute a violation of any applicable law, code, regulation or ordinance, the forty-five (45) day review period shall be tolled until such point as the premises is brought into compliance with applicable codes. 6. Following staff review, the matter shall be forwarded to the City Council of the City of DeKalb at a meeting occurring within forty-five (45) days of the date on which staff review is completed. The City Council shall be provided with all staff recommendations and shall make the ultimate decision as to whether a license should be granted or denied. 7. Submission of a signed application for a license and/or acceptance of a license under this ordinance constitutes the applicant’s consent to an inspection of any and all portions of the licensed premises by the City: 1) at any time during the normal business hours of the licensed premises, with or without advance notice; or, 2) at such other time as the City shall designate to the applicant/licensee in writing, with not less than 48 hours advance notice. Inspections pursuant to this consent may be conducted by any City personnel, including Police Department, Building, Public Works, or Fire Department staff, the City Attorney, the City Manager or other staff authorized by the City Manager, for purposes of determining compliance with the provisions of this ordinance, or for purposes of determining compliance with any other applicable code or regulation. The consent for inspection shall extend to any portion of the premises. An applicant or licensee’s refusal to grant access to the premises for an inspection shall constitute grounds for denial of a pending application (without refund of any posted application fees), and shall constitute a violation of this ordinance for license holders, which may subject a licensee to suspension or revocation of their license, imposition of fines and penalties under this ordinance, or both. All holders of a license must also hold a valid Fire Life Safety License issued by the City. d) Issuance of License: Upon conclusion of any consideration of a license application, the City Council may grant or deny the license application. A license application may be continued from time to time, and the City Council may require the conduct of a public hearing on the application; any publication or notice costs for the public hearing shall be borne by the applicant. In approving a license, the City Council shall be authorized to impose conditions on the license issuance relating to the conduct of the Social Club, the provision of parking, security, site improvements, or such other terms as the City Council shall determine are necessary and appropriate to ensure public safety. A license approved under this Ordinance may have a term that requires the license to be submitted to City Council for renewal, or may be subject to renewal by the Mayor or City Manager; the mechanism for renewal shall be described at the time of initial issuance. 1. Conditional Approval of License: The City Council may, but shall not be obligated to, approve social club licenses for licensees who are otherwise eligible for issuance of a license, but whose place of business has not been built-out, has not received a Fire-Life Safety License, is not yet eligible for issuance of a final certificate of occupancy or is otherwise ineligible for operation because of non-compliance with any other City Code or requirement. Such conditional licenses shall not permit occupancy of the premises until such point in time as all required City permits and approvals have been received by the Licensee. At such time as all other required City permits and approvals, including but not limited to a certificate of occupancy and final inspection, have been provided, a conditionally issued license shall convert to an unconditional license, subject to the terms of this Chapter 32. Should a Licensee fail, within a time specified by the City Council, to obtain all required City permits and approvals including but not limited to a certificate of occupancy, the City Manager shall be authorized to revoke the conditional license without any requirement of holding a public hearing or providing any due process. Any applicant/Licensee who requests a conditional license under this subsection shall execute a waiver agreeing and acknowledging the terms of this subsection, including the provisions relating to revocation. e) License Fees: The fee for applying for, obtaining and renewing a Social Club License, and the term of such license, shall be the same as that utilized by the City of DeKalb for a Restaurant Liquor License under the Chapter 32 - 6 Municipal Code - City of DeKalb Chapter 32, “Business Regulations” then-current terms of Chapter 38 of the City Code of Ordinances. f) Suspension or Revocation of License: The City may utilize any process outlined in City Code for the suspension or revocation of any City-issued license as the process for suspension or revocation of the license contemplated herein. Licenses may be suspended or revoked for any violation of any applicable code, ordinance or statute. g) Additional Restrictions: 1. It shall be unlawful to possess, sell, dispense, or permit to be possessed, sold or dispensed any item at a Social Club which is either unlawful to sell or dispense, or which is regulated for distribution by age (e.g. alcohol, tobacco or similarly age-restricted items). The licensee shall maintain adequate security procedures to ensure that no person enters the establishment in violation of these provisions. 2. Once admitted to the Social Club, a person shall not be permitted to exit and re-enter the premises sooner than the following business day (with business day defined based upon the hours of operation of the establishment, and not occurring before such time as the establishment has fully closed and subsequently reopened). 3. The hours of operation for a Social Club shall be fixed by the terms of licensure. 4. Any Social Club shall have illumination of at least 5 foot candles at floor level at all times that the Social Club is in operation. 5. It is the licensee’s duty to prevent loitering, nuisances or disturbances of the peace by patrons of the Social Club on the premises or in the immediate vicinity thereof, and to clean all litter and remediate all graffiti or other damage generated by patrons of the Social Club on the premises or in the immediate vicinity thereof, within two hours of Social Club closure on any given day. 6. No licensee, his agent or employee shall allow or permit any person to perform acts of or acts which simulate: a) sexual intercourse, masturbation, sodomy, bestiality, oral copulation, flagellation or any sexual acts which are prohibited by law; b) the actual or simulated touching, caressing or fondling of the breast, buttocks, anus or genitals; c) the actual or simulated displaying of the pubic hair, anus, vulva or genitals; d) the actual or simulated displaying of the breast so as to expose the nipple of the female breast; e) the displaying of films or pictures depicting acts, a live performance of which is prohibited by a), b), c) or d) above. No licensee, his agent or employee shall allow or permit any person to remain in or upon the licensed premises who exposes in public view any portion of his or her genitals or anus. 7. Each licensee shall provide at least one public telephone for outgoing calls only for each 125 patrons (based upon the maximum occupancy of the premises). No licensee shall permit sound or vibration exceeding 90 decibels measured with a standard meter "A" scale within two feet of any public telephone receiver or audible at such level on the outside of any exterior wall of the premises located more than ten feet from a doorway of the licensed premises. No public telephone shall be provided on the premises for incoming calls 8. The license issued hereunder shall be non-transferrable and non-assignable, issued to the license holder only. The determination of what constitutes a transfer or assignment of the license shall utilize the same procedure and regulations as applicable to a liquor license. 9. The licensee shall deliver to the chief of police, no later than 72 hours before any scheduled Chapter 32 - 7 Municipal Code - City of DeKalb Chapter 32, “Business Regulations” special event occurring at a licensed premises, true and accurate copies of any and all advertisements of whatever nature therefore used to advertise or promote the event. The licensee shall also include prior to any such advertised event: (a) The number of employees and/or performers to be used for the event; (b) Designation of the individual who will be available prior to and during the event and who shall have authority to accept complaints, notice of violations, or take corrective action as required by proper officials of the city; (c) A security plan with an acknowledgment that any changes to the security plan must be submitted to the chief of police in writing one business day before the event, and the security plan must be followed without any changes unless such change has been submitted to the chief of police in writing and he has approved it prior to the event being opened; (d) Security personnel shall be required for the maximum capacity of the event as determined by the maximum occupancy of the premises under city's ordinance unless attendance is limited to a lesser number; (e) Inspections may be conducted by the city to ensure compliance with its codes and ordinances; (f) No members of the general public shall be allowed admittance prior to the opening of the event; (g) Only one such event per evening shall be allowed; (h) Automatic counters are required to be used prior to entry into the licensed premises to determine occupancy of the premises; (i) Tickets may be sold before the event with the number of tickets sold limited to the occupancy limit of the premises for patrons, and after all said tickets have been sold, the licensee shall post a sign stating that the event is "Sold Out." Chapter 32 - 8 ARTICLE 14 PERMITS The use made of property may not be substantially changed; substantial clearing, grading or excavation may not be commenced; and buildings or other structures may not be constructed, erected, moved or substantially altered, without obtaining a permit (or permits) as specified below. 14.01 Building Permit It shall be unlawful to construct, enlarge, alter or demolish a structure; or change the occupancy of a building or structure requiring greater strength, exit or sanitary provisions; or to change to another use; or to install or alter any equipment for which provision is made or the installation of which is regulated by the City's Building Code, without first filing an application for a building permit per Chapter 24 "Building Code" of the DeKalb Municipal Code. In addition to the requirement that the application meets building code and other applicable codes, it shall also be in compliance with the provisions of this Ordinance. 14.02 Certificate of Use and Occupancy 14.02.01 Certificates 1. A Certificate of Use and Occupancy shall be issued by the Director of Community Development prior to the use or occupancy, in whole or in part, of a newly constructed building, altered building or change in use made in a building, or of a property. Said certificate shall be issued in accordance with Chapter 24 "Building Code" of the DeKalb Municipal Code. 2. Prior to the issuance of a Certificate of Use and Occupancy, the Applicant shall provide the City Engineer a Certificate of Compliance, completed and certified by a licensed surveyor or a registered civil engineer, verifying that the parcel’s final elevations are in compliance with the permit grading plan elevations. Finished ground elevations, with sod in place or area having evidence of turf, shall be within 0.10 foot of proposed grading elevation. Finished foundation wall elevation shall be no greater than 0.10 foot lower or 0.25 foot higher than the permit grading plan elevation. (ORD 06-19) 14.02.02 Temporary Certificate The Director of Community Development may issue a temporary Certificate of Use and Occupancy where the approved plan has been substantially complied with, but the owner or developer is prevented from complete compliance by reasons of occurrences beyond his control. Prior to issuance of the temporary Certificate of Use and Occupancy, the owner shall file with the City, for the use of the City, one of the following: a corporate surety bond issued by an Illinois insurance company or one licensed to do business in the State of Illinois; a letter of credit from an appropriate financial institution; or a cash deposit. Forms for these financial assurances are available from the Director of Community Development. 14.03 Special Use Permit 14.03.01 Purpose In addition to those uses specifically classified and permitted in each district, there are certain additional uses which may be desirable to allow because of the service they provide to the public. However, because of their unusual and unique characteristics and impacts, these "special uses" (to some referred to as "conditional uses") require particular consideration as to their proper location in relation to adjacent established or intended uses or with respect to site layout, traffic circulation, etc. The special uses itemized in each zoning district (see Article 5, "Zoning District Regulations") require a special use permit. The ordinance adopted by the City Council that authorizes a special use shall serve as the special use permit. Updated June 2013 14-1 January 2007 Edition 14.03.02 Initiation of a Special Use Permit Special Use Permits may be initiated by the City Council or the Plan Commission, or which may be initiated by them in response to a request by any City Board or staff member. A Special Use Permit may also be requested by the owner(s), or authorized representative(s) of the owner(s), of the property proposed for the Special Use Permit provided an appropriate application for such is submitted in accordance with this section. 14.03.03 Application for a Special Use Permit 1. An application form for a Special Use Permit shall be filed with the City Clerk. The application form is available from the Department of Community Development. In addition to submitting the completed application, the applicant shall be required to submit the following information: a. Legal owners of the property(s) proposed for the Special Use Permit. If the property is held in an Illinois Land Trust, a Statement of Beneficiary Interest is also required. b. Legal description of the property(s) proposed for the Special Use Permit. c. Common street address of the property(s) proposed for the Special Use Permit. d. Size of the property (in square feet or acres). e. Current zoning of the property and its proposed special use. f. Narrative description of the various specific components of the special use and the reasons for requesting the Special Use Permit. g. Estimated impact of the special use on the surrounding properties. h. Vicinity map showing the property proposed for the Special Use Permit and its surrounding area. 2. The applicant for a Special Use Permit shall submit a site plan that includes, but is not necessarily limited to, the following information. a. The approximate location, designated uses, and square footage of floor areas of existing and proposed buildings and structures. b. Where applicable, the approximate location of all existing and proposed curbcuts, driveways, off- street parking spaces and loading areas, traffic circulation patterns, adjoining street pavement and right-of-way widths, sidewalks, landscaping, screening, open space areas, signage, lighting, sanitary sewer and water utilities, and other related site plan features. c. The property's existing and proposed grades, the direction of stormwater flow, and the appropriate location of existing and proposed drainage facilities. d. Two (2) cross section profiles through the site showing preliminary building form and other structural elevations. e. Tree survey, which means an aerial photograph or drawing to scale (one inch equals 200 feet or smaller ratio) which provides the following information: (1) Location of all trees, (2) Common names of all trees, (3) Diameter breast height of each tree (4) Age of tree (5) Overall health of the tree (6) Life expectancy Updated June 2013 14-2 January 2007 Edition 3. At the time of submitting an application for a Special Use Permit, the applicant may submit to the City certified petitions of signatures of area residents supporting the proposed Special Use Permit. Such petitions are optional. 4. At the time of submitting an application for a Special Use Permit, the applicant shall also furnish to the City a list of owners and their mailing addresses of all property within two-hundred fifty (250) feet of the property that is the subject of the proposed special use. This distance shall be measured in all directions from the boundaries of the subject property and shall not include distances devoted to adjoining or nearby public right-of-ways. In all instances, the furnished list shall include the names and addresses of a minimum of ten (10) property owners. Should the two-hundred fifty (250) foot notification area not result in list of ten (10) property owners, then the notification area shall be appropriately expanded until this minimum has been met. In expanding the notification area, preference shall be given towards those properties comprised of urban-sized lots or in areas most likely to be affected by the proposal. 14.03.04 Public Notice Requirement 1. The Director of Community Development shall be responsible that notice of the time, date, and place of required public hearing, along with a legal description of the property that is the subject of the public hearing, be given not more than thirty (30) nor less than fifteen (15) days before the hearing by publishing a notice thereof at least once in a newspaper having general circulation in the City of DeKalb. 2. The Director of Community Development shall mail a notice of the public hearing to those property owners whose names are furnished by the applicant. Notice of the public hearing shall also be mailed to all applicable governmental agencies, including but not limited to: School District, Park District, Sanitary District, Drainage District, and the Soil and Water Conservation District. 3. The Director of Community Development may require the applicant to erect a sign or signs on the subject property not less than fifteen (15) days before the scheduled public hearing by the Plan Commission. The sign(s) shall have on their surface a notice that the property is to be the subject of a public meeting and shall not be removed until the City Council has taken final action on the special use permit. There shall be one (1) sign erected for every public street frontage and it shall be clearly visible from the adjacent or nearest public rights-of-way. All signs shall be furnished by the City after receiving from the applicant any appropriate deposits. The deposits shall be returned to the applicant upon the timely return of the sign or signs in good condition. 14.03.05 Special Use Permit Review Procedure 1. The Director of Community Development shall review the application for the Special Use Permit. The Director of Community Development shall solicit the opinions and comments of other City staff members and, along with the comments received from property owners, governmental agencies, etc., shall forward to the Plan Commission his/her recommendations of approval or denial of the Special Use Permit or approval with conditions placed on the Special Use Permit. 2. The Plan Commission shall hold a public hearing and shall consider the Special Use Permit and relevant facts presented by the applicant or his/her representative, City Staff, other governmental agencies, or by any interested citizen. Once the Plan Commission is satisfied that they have heard all relevant facts, they shall recommend to the City Council that the Special Use Permit be approved or denied. Alternatively, the Plan Commission may approve the Special Use Permit with conditions. Such conditions may include, but are not limited to, one or more of the following: size, height, and location of proposed buildings and structures; landscaping and screening; parking and loading areas; signage; traffic flow and access requirements; lighting; hours of operation; open-space areas; drainage and stormwater facilities; or architectural and engineering features. These conditions shall be in addition to any regulations contained in the underlying zoning district or other applicable regulations of the City. In making their recommendation, the Plan Commission shall consider and adopt findings in each of the following: Updated June 2013 14-3 January 2007 Edition a. The proposed special use complies with all provisions of the applicable district regulations. b. The proposed special use will not be unreasonably detrimental to the value of other property in the neighborhood in which it is to be located or to the public welfare at large. c. The location and size of the special use, the nature and intensity of the operation involved in or conducted in connection with it, and the location of the site with respect to streets giving access to it are such that the special use will not dominate the immediate neighborhood so as to prevent development and use of neighboring property in accordance with the applicable zoning district regulations. In determining whether the special use will so dominate the immediate neighborhood, consideration shall be given to: (1) The location, nature and height of buildings, structures, walls and fences on the site; and (2) The nature and extent of proposed landscaping and screening on the proposed site. d. Adequate utility, drainage and other such necessary facilities have been or will be provided. e. The proposed use, where such developments and uses are deemed consistent with good planning practice, or can be operated in a manner that is not detrimental to the permitted developments and uses in the district; can be developed and operated in a manner that is visually compatible with the permitted uses in the surrounding area; shall in all other respects conform to the applicable regulations of the district in which it is located; and is deemed essential or desirable to preserve and promote the public health, safety and general welfare of the City of DeKalb. 3. Upon receipt of the Plan Commission's recommendation, the City Council shall consider the proposed Special Use Permit. The adoption of an ordinance that affirms, affirms in part, or reverses the Plan Commission's recommendation on the Special Use Permit shall require a favorable vote of a simple majority of the City Council members present. 14.03.06 Special Use Permit Terms and Limitations 1. Permit Effective Date. The permit shall become effective upon adoption of the appropriate ordinance by the Council. In the event that a Special Use Permit is filed in conjunction with a change of zoning, the permit shall not become effective until the date of enactment of the ordinance authorizing the zoning change. In the event that some additional approval is required by some other governmental authority or agency, the permit shall not become effective until that approval is received. 2. Site Plan Approval. Upon issuance of a Special Use Permit, but prior to the issuance of a building permit, the petitioner shall submit a site plan which conforms to the conditions of the Special Use Permit and the underlying zoning district regulations for review and approval in accordance with the procedures established in Article 17, "Site Plan Review Requirements." 3. Time Limit of Special Use Permits. Special Use Permits shall be valid for an unlimited period unless a lesser period shall be provided in a particular permit. Prior to the expiration of the time limit specified in a particular permit, the property owner may request that the Special Use Permit be reviewed by the Council, which may extend it for an unlimited period or for a specified additional period of years. 4. Failure to Commence Construction or Operation. Unless otherwise stated in the conditions of a particular Special Use Permit, substantial construction or operation of the special use where construction is not required shall commence within two (2) years of the effective date of the permit unless such time period is extended through appeal to and approval by the Council. If no appeal is made or no extension of time is received or granted, the permit shall immediately terminate upon expiration of the one (1) year period. 5. Revocation of Special Use Permit. Upon a finding that an approved Special Use Permit will or has become unsuitable and/or incompatible in its location as a result of any nuisance or activity generated by Updated June 2013 14-4 January 2007 Edition the use, the Council shall have the authority to revoke the permit after affording the current property owner the right to be heard. 6. Transferability. All Special Use Permits shall be approved for the specific tract or parcel of land, and may not be transferred to any other location. An approved Special Use Permit is transferrable to any subsequent land owner. 7. Procedure to Amend Approved Special Use Permit. Any expansion, increase in extent of operation, or other changes made to a special use beyond that which was designated on the original Special Use Permit application and/or authorized by ordinance by the City Council, shall be considered an amendment to the Special Use Permit. In order to amend an existing Special Use Permit, the application procedures, required materials, and approval process shall be the same as for a new permit. 14.04 Floodplain Permit No person shall commence any construction, substantial improvement, subdivision of land, placement of manufactured homes or other development in areas located in a floodplain (A Zone) without first obtaining a floodplain permit from the Director of Community Development. The Director shall not issue such permit for any construction, substantial improvement or other development that does not comply with the provisions of Article 11 "Floodplains, Floodways, Stormdrainage and Erosion", or that has been denied a permit required by Federal or State Law, including Section 404 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, 1972, 33 U.S.C. 1334. 14.05 Flood Elevation Certificate When construction is proposed on a lot which is partially within the floodplain and no change or construction is proposed involving land below the floodplain elevation, a flood elevation certificate may be issued by the Director of Community Development. Prior to issuance of the permit, the owner shall submit a plan, sealed by a Illinois Registered Land Surveyor, certifying the location of the floodplain and any proposed construction or improvements. 14.06 Grading Permit No person shall construct, alter, relocate, remove or destroy any ditch, drain or drainage structure upon any real property within the City, whether subdivided or not, without obtaining a grading permit. No person shall alter the contours of any real property within the City, whether subdivided or not, so as to change the flow of water into or through any ditch, drain or drainage structure without obtaining a grading permit. Any person desirous of obtaining a grading permit shall make application to the Director of Community Development on a form provided by said Director. Said Director shall not issue a grading permit if the application does not comply with the provisions of Article 11, "Floodways, Floodplains, Stormdrainage and Erosion", Section 11.02. 14.07 Temporary Use Permits The Director of Community Development is authorized to issue a permit for a temporary use provided it meets the requirements of this section. The permit shall be issued for a specified period of time; shall contain health, safety and traffic provisions; and may require such assurances or guarantees of compliance with stated provisions as is reasonable and appropriate under the circumstances. 14.07.01 Temporary Uses Permitted 1. Christmas Tree Sales: Christmas tree sales for a period not to exceed sixty (60) days. Display of Christmas trees need not comply with the applicable yard setback requirements provided that no display will encroach within the required yard setback for any district by more than fifty (50%) percent and no display or equipment shall be located within the twenty-five (25) foot sight distance triangle of a street intersection as defined in this Ordinance. A deposit of one hundred ($100) dollars shall be made to the Director of Community Development at the time of issuing the temporary use permit for Christmas tree sales. Updated June 2013 14-5 January 2007 Edition If the site is promptly cleared and cleaned (within ten (10) days after the permit expires), then the Director shall return the deposit, in a timely manner, to the individual, corporation or organization to which the permit was issued. 2. Contractor's and Real Estate Sales Offices: Temporary buildings or trailers may be used as construction offices, real estate sales offices, field offices or for storage of materials to be used in connection with the development of a tract of land, provided that said temporary structures are removed from said tract within thirty (30) days after completion of the project development. Temporary buildings or trailers must also be removed from said tract within thirty (30) days after voluntary suspension of work on the project or development or after revocation of building permits, or on order by the Director of Community Development upon a finding by him/her that said temporary structure is deemed hazardous to the public health and welfare. A bond in the amount of one thousand ($1,000) dollars for their removal shall be posted with the City. 3. Amusement Devices: The Director of Community Development is authorized to issue a permit for the installation of amusement devices on a temporary basis within any zoning district, provided that said permit shall not be valid for more than ten (10) consecutive calendar days and further provided that no permit shall be valid without a license to operate said amusement devices as required by Chapter 34, "Amusements", of the Municipal Code. The Director may, in regard to any given site, designate the hours and days of the week of operation and the specific location of the amusement devices on the property. No more than two such permits shall be issued in any calendar year with regard to any particular property. For the purpose of this paragraph, "amusement device" includes those devices enumerated in Chapter 34 of the Municipal Code. 4. Amusement Activities: The Director of Community Development is authorized to issue a permit for the operation or conducting of an amusement activity on a temporary basis within any zoning district. For the purpose of this paragraph, "amusement activity" includes a circus, carnival, fair, art display, trade or animal show, concert, dance, rally, parade, athletic competition and any similar activity not involving the erection of any permanent structure or facility. The permit shall be issued for a specific period of time not exceeding ten (10) days. The permit shall contain such conditions as are necessary for the protection of public health, safety and welfare. The Director may require such assurance or guarantee of compliance with conditions as is reasonable and appropriate under the circumstances. This permit is in addition to any building permit, air pollution device construction or operating permit, highway special use permit, or other permit or license required by law for any proposed activity or facility. No more than two temporary amusement activity permits shall be issued in any calendar year with regard to any particular property; provided, however, that this limitation with respect to the number of temporary amusement activity permits shall not apply to public property, nor to property not held for private or corporate profit and used exclusively for religious worship, for schools and colleges, for purposes purely charitable, or for agricultural and horticultural societies. 5. Temporary Outdoor Sales: The Director of Community Development is authorized to issue a permit for temporary outdoor sale activities. For purposes of this paragraph, "Outdoor Sales" includes sidewalk sales, roadside sales and tent sales. The Directory may designate the hours and days of the week of operation. The permit shall be issued for a specific period of time and contain such conditions as are necessary for the protection of public health, safety and welfare. The Director may require such assurance or guarantee of compliance with conditions as is reasonable and appropriate under the circumstances. 14.08 Sign Permits It shall be unlawful for any person to erect, alter, or relocate within the City, any sign as regulated in Article 13, "Signs", without first obtaining a sign permit or a temporary sign permit, as the case may be, from the Director of Community Development. All illuminated signs, shall, in addition, be subject to all the applicable electrical provisions of Chapter 25, "Electrical Regulations", of the DeKalb Municipal Code. 14.08.01 Application for a Sign Permit Updated June 2013 14-6 January 2007 Edition Application for a sign permit shall be made upon forms provided by the Director of Community Development and shall contain or have attached thereto the following information: 1. Name, address and telephone number of the applicant. 2. Location of building, structure, or lot to which or upon which the sign or other advertising structure is to be attached or erected. 3. Position of the sign or advertising structure in relation to adjacent property and/or buildings or structures. 4. Two blue prints or ink drawings to scale of the plans and specifications and method of construction, attachment to the building or other structure or placement in the ground. 5. Structural components shall comply with Chapter 24, "Building Code", of the DeKalb Municipal Code. 6. Name of person or company intending to erect the sign. 7. Such other information as the Director of Community Development shall require to show full compliance with this Article and any of the ordinances of the City. 14.08.02 Permit Issued if Application in Order It shall be the duty of the Director of Community Development, upon the filing of an application for a sign permit, to examine such plans, specifications, and other data, and the premises upon which it is proposed to erect the sign. If the proposed sign complies with the requirements of this Article and Article 13, "Signs", of this Ordinance and if the appropriate permit fee has been paid, a sign permit shall be issued. 14.08.03 Revocation of Permit Any permit issued shall become invalid if the authorized work is suspended or abandoned for a period of six (6) months after the time of commencing the work, or of obtaining the permit. Upon the termination or revocation of the permit, the permittee shall remove the sign and supports without cost or expense of any kind to the City; provided that in the event of the failure, neglect or refusal on the part of the permittee to do so, the City may proceed to remove the same and charge the expenses to the permittee. 14.09 Permit Fees The fees for all permits herein addressed shall be as established by the City of DeKalb in Chapter 9, "Establishment of Fees", and Chapter 24, "Building Code", of the DeKalb Municipal Code as revised. A fee schedule is available for review at the Department of Community Development office. 14.10 Permissible Uses Not Requiring Permits Notwithstanding any other provisions of this Ordinance, or the DeKalb Municipal Code, no building permit or special use permit is necessary for the following uses: 1. Streets; 2. Electric power, telephone, telegraph, cable television, gas, water, and sewer lines, wire or pipes, together with supporting poles or structures, located within a public right-of-way or an easement; 3. Neighborhood utility facilities located within a public right-of-way or an easement with the permission of the owner (state, county, township or city) of the right-of-way. 14.11 Who May Submit Permit Applications Updated June 2013 14-7 January 2007 Edition 1. Applications for permit(s) will be accepted only from persons having the legal authority to take such action. By way of illustration, in general this means that applications should be made by the owners or lessees of property, or their agents, or persons who have contracted to purchase property contingent upon their ability to acquire the necessary permits under this Ordinance, or the agents of such persons (who may make application in the name of such owners, lessees, or contract vendees); 2. The Director of Community Development may require an applicant to submit evidence of his authority to submit the application in accordance with paragraph 1 whenever there appears to be a reasonable basis for questioning this authority. 14.12 Permit Denial Application for any of the permits listed herein shall be denied if it does not comply with the applicable code or this Ordinance, subject to the right of appeal to the Zoning Board of Appeals or Building Board of Appeals. Additionally, if the applicant is a defaulter of the City, the permit shall be denied. For purposes of this Section, "defaulter" shall mean: 1. The applicant or owner of the property did not make a required payment under the Rehabilitation Loan Program, or any similar program on the date the payment was due; or 2. The applicant or owner of the property has any outstanding financial obligation to the City of DeKalb, including, but not limited to, past due water bills, past due special assessment payment, past due tax payments, past due license fees, past due loan payments, parking ticket violations, weed and nuisance abatement fine or liens, ordinance violation fines, or any other payment owed to the City of DeKalb. Updated June 2013 14-8 January 2007 Edition ARTICLE 18 APPEALS AND VARIANCES 18.01 Board of Appeals The Board of Appeals has been duly established by the City Council of DeKalb, Illinois. Except as provided for in Article 16, "Administration and Enforcement," the Board of Appeals is authorized to take action on appeals and variances with regard to this Ordinance and other applicable Illinois State Statutes. Rules and procedures governing the conduct of the Board are contained in its adopted bylaws and as may be amended from time to time. 18.02 Appeals An appeal may be taken to the Board of Appeals by any person aggrieved, or by an officer, department, board or commission of the City affected by a decision of the Director of Building and Community Services or other City staff member relative to this Ordinance. Such appeal shall be taken within forty-five (45) days of the action complained of by filing with the Director of Building and Community Service a notice of appeal, specifying the grounds thereof and by paying a fee to the City of DeKalb of such amount as may be established from time to time by the City Council. The Director of Building and Community Services shall forthwith transmit to the Board all of the papers constituting the record upon which the appeal action was taken. An appeal shall stay all proceedings in furtherance of the action that has been appealed, unless the Director of Building and Community Services certifies to the Board of Appeals, after the notice of appeal has been filed with him, that by reason of facts stated in the certificate, a stay would, in his opinion, cause imminent peril to life or property, in which case the proceedings shall not be stayed otherwise than by a restraining order, which may be granted by a court of record on application, on notice to the Director of Building and Community Services and on due cause shown. The Board shall hear appeals under this Ordinance and as to any such appeal shall follow the rules herein contained. 18.02.01 Hearing Required The Board shall hear an appeal at one of their regularly scheduled meetings and give due notice thereof to the parties and shall render a decision of the appeal without unreasonable delay. No hearing shall be held upon an appeal unless the parties thereto receive at least seventy-two (72) hours notice of such hearing. Any party to the proceeding may appear and testify at the hearing, either in person or by duly authorized agent or attorney. 18.02.02 Decision 1. The Board may reverse or affirm wholly or partly or may modify or amend the order, requirement, decision, or determination appealed from to the extent and in the manner that the Board may decide to be fitting and proper, and to that end the Board shall also have all the powers of the officer from whom the appeal is taken. The concurring vote of four (4) members of the Board shall be necessary to reverse any order, requirements, decision or determination of the Director of Building and Community Services or other City staff member or to decide in favor of the applicant. 2. All final orders, requirements, and decisions of the Board shall bear the signature of the Chairman (or Acting Chairman if the Chairman is unavailable). It shall be the duty of the secretary of the 18-1 January 2007 Edition Board to give proper notification of the final orders, requirements, and decisions and draft them if so instructed by the Board. 18.03 Variances When a property owner shows that a strict application of the terms of this Ordinance relating to the construction or alteration of buildings or structures imposes upon him practical difficulties or particular hardship, then the Board may determine and vary their application of the regulations of this Ordinance in harmony with their general purpose and intent when the Board is satisfied under the evidence heard before it that a granting of such variation will not merely serve as a convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate some demonstrable hardship or difficulty so great as to warrant a variation from the strict letter of the regulations of this Ordinance. No variance shall authorize a use not among the uses specified by this Ordinance, as permitted in the zoning district in which such property is located. 18.03.01 Hearing Required. No variation shall be made by the Board of Appeals except after a public hearing of which notification of time and place of the hearing shall be provided in the following manner: 1. At the time of submitting an application for a variance, the applicant shall furnish to the City a list of owners and their mailing addresses of all property within two-hundred fifty (250) feet of the property that is the subject of the proposed variance. This distance shall be measured in all directions from the boundaries of the subject property and shall not include distances devoted to adjoining or nearby public rights-of-way. In all instances, the furnished list shall include the names and addresses of a minimum of ten (10) property owners. Should the two-hundred fifty (250) foot notification area not result in list of ten (10) property owners, then the notification area shall be appropriately expanded until this minimum has been met. In expanding the notification area, preference shall be given towards those properties comprised of urban-sized lots or in areas most likely to be affected by the proposal. 2. The City shall have published in a newspaper having general circulation in the City of DeKalb a notice of the public hearing. Said publication shall appear not less than fifteen (15) days nor more than thirty (30) days prior to the scheduled public hearing and shall contain the time, date, location, and purpose of the public hearing and a legal description of the property that is the subject of the public hearing. 3. The City shall mail a notice of the public hearing to those property owners whose names are furnished by the applicant. The City shall also mail a notice of the public hearing to all applicable governmental agencies, including but not limited to: School District, Park District, Sanitary District, Township, Drainage District and Soil and Water Conservation District. 18.03.02 Application Procedures 1. Application: The petitioner shall submit an application, on forms available from the Department of Building and Community Services. The application shall also include the following information. a. The legal and common description of the property on which the variance is to be considered. b. The variance requested, and the reasons for the request. c. The property's present zoning classification. 18-2 January 2007 Edition d. A site plan showing the subject property and its dimensions. e. The location of all existing and proposed buildings, structures and other improvements, building sizes including square footage, and their distances from adjacent lot lines. f. List of owners and their mailing addresses as required in Subsection 18.03.01. g. Any other information which the Board of Appeals requests. 2. Burden of Proof: In submitting an application for a variance, the burden of proof shall rest with the applicant to clearly establish that the findings of fact required in Subsection 18.03.03, Paragraph 2 are met. 18.03.03 Hearing Procedures 1. The procedure for a hearing shall be as follows: a. Parliamentary procedure for all Board meetings shall be governed by Robert's Rules of Order when not addressed by this document or other applicable State Statute or local ordinance. b. All witnesses shall be sworn, and all parties or persons who are not attorneys shall be sworn. c. The appellant shall begin by presenting his case which may include the presentation of documents, etc., and the calling of witnesses for examination by the appellant. d. The appellee shall have an opportunity to cross-examine all witnesses after each has testified and examined all documents. e. The appellee shall present his case which may include the presentation of documents, etc., and the calling of witnesses for examination by the appellee. f. The appellant shall have an opportunity to cross-examine all witnesses after each has testified and examined all documents. g. The appellant shall be given fifteen (15) minutes to summarize as shall the appellee, in that order. h. A representative of the City of DeKalb may testify for either party or appear on behalf of the City of DeKalb. i. No person not a party to the hearing or a representative of the City shall have a right to testify unless formally called by a party to the hearing or the City at the appropriate times mentioned above. The Board reserves the right to call expert witnesses or postpone a hearing date until such time as said witness may be contacted to testify. j. The Board reserves the right to question the appellant, appellee, and/or witnesses who may give testimony at any time during the hearing. k. The Board reserves the right to impose time limits upon any party giving testimony. (Ord. 93- 63) 2. Findings of Fact: Upon review of the application and information presented at the public hearing, the Board shall consider and adopt findings of fact sustaining each of the following criteria, which are consistent with the rules provided to govern determinations of the Board of Appeals as referenced by the Illinois Compiled Statutes. 18-3 January 2007 Edition a. The property in question cannot yield a reasonable return if permitted to be used only under the conditions allowed by the regulations in that district. b. The extraordinary or exceptional conditions of the property, requiring the request for the variance, were not caused by the applicant. c. The proposed variance will alleviate a peculiar, exceptional, or undue hardship, as distinguished from a mere inconvenience or pecuniary hardship. d. The denial of the proposed variance will deprive the applicant the use of his/her property in a manner equivalent to the use permitted to be made by the owners of property in the immediate area. e. The proposed variance will result in a structure that is appropriate to and compatible with the character and scale of structures in the area in which the variance is being requested. 3. Variances: When a property owner shows that a strict application of the terms of this ordinance relating to the construction or alteration of buildings or structures imposes upon him practical difficulties or particular hardship, then the Board may grant a variance to said ordinance in harmony with its general purpose and intent, when the Board is satisfied under the evidence heard before it, that a granting of such variation will not merely serve as a convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate some demonstrable hardship or difficulty so great as to warrant a variation from the comprehensive plan by this ordinance created and set forth, in the following instances: a. To permit the extension of a district where the boundary line of a district provides a lot in single ownership as shown of record. b. To permit the reconstruction of a non-conforming building which has been destroyed or partially destroyed by fire or act of God where the Board shall find some compelling public necessity requiring a continuance of the non-conforming use and in no case shall such a permit be issued if its primary function is to continue a monopoly. c. To permit the erection of a building in any location for a public service corporation for public utility purposes which the Board deems reasonably necessary for the public convenience or welfare. d. To make a variance where, by reason of an exception situation, surroundings, or condition of a specific piece of property, or by reason of exceptional narrowness, shallowness or shape of a specific piece of property or record, or by reason of exceptional topographical conditions the strict application of any provision of this ordinance would result in peculiar and exceptional practical difficulties or particular hardship upon the owner of such property and amount to a practical confiscation of property as distinguished from a mere inconvenience to such owner, provided such relief can be granted without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantial detriment to the public good and without substantially impairing the general purpose and intent of the comprehensive plan as established by the regulations and provisions contained in this ordinance. e. To interpret the provisions of this ordinance where the street layout actually on the ground varies from the street layout as shown on the map fixing the several districts which map is made a part of this Ordinance. In considering all proposed variations to this Ordinance, the Board shall first determine that the proposed variation will not impair an adequate supply of light and air to adjacent property or unreasonably increase the congestion in public streets, or increase the danger of fire or endanger the public safety, or unreasonably diminish or impair established property values within the surrounding area, or in any other respect impair the public health, safety, comfort, morals, or welfare of the inhabitants of the City of DeKalb. The concurring vote of four (4) members of the 18-4 January 2007 Edition Board shall be necessary to reverse any order, requirement, decision, or determination of the Building and Community Services Director or to decide in favor of the applicant any matter upon which it is authorized by this Ordinance to render decision, or to effect any variance. (Ord. 93-63) 4. Non-conformity as Basis for Variance: The existence of any non-conformity anywhere in the City shall not itself be considered grounds for the issuance of a variance for other property. 5. Conditions imposed on Variances: a. In granting variances, the Board may impose such reasonable conditions as will ensure that the use of the property to which the variance applies will be as compatible as practicable with the surrounding properties. b. A variance may be issued for an indefinite duration or for a specified duration only. c. The nature of the variance and any conditions attached to it shall be entered on the face of the Board's order, or the Board's order may simply note the issuance of the variance and refer to the written record of the variance for further information. All such conditions are enforceable in the same manner as any other applicable requirement of this Ordinance. 6. Notification of Decision: All final orders, requirements, and decisions of the Board shall bear the signature of the Chairman (or Acting Chairman if the Chairman is unavailable). It shall be the duty of the secretary of the Board to give proper notification of the final orders, requirements and decisions and draft them if so instructed by the Board. 7. Period of Validity: No order of the Board permitting the erection or alteration of a building shall be valid for a period longer than six months, unless a building permit for such erection or alteration is obtained within such period and such erection or alteration is started and proceeds to completion in accordance with the terms of such permit. No order of the Board permitting a use of a building or premises shall be valid for a period longer than six (6) months, unless such use is established within such period; provided, however, that where such use is permitted is dependent upon the erection or alteration of a building, such order shall continue to force and effect if a building permit for said erection or alteration is obtained within such period and such erection or alteration is started and proceeds to completion in accordance with the terms of such permit. 18.04 Appeal of Final Actions No decision of the Board shall be subject to review, reversal or modification by the City Council but shall be subject to judicial review pursuant to the provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure concerning Administrative Review Law. 18-5 January 2007 Edition ARTICLE 19 NON-CONFORMING SITUATIONS 19.01 Scope of Provisions The provisions of the section shall apply to all non-conforming uses, lands and structures. A non-conforming land use or structure is one which existed lawfully, whether by variance or otherwise, on the date this Ordinance or any amendment thereto became effective, and which fails to conform to one or more of the applicable regulations of this Ordinance or such amendment thereto. 19.02 Statement of Intent Non-conforming situations may be incompatible with, and detrimental to, permitted land uses and structures in the zoning districts in which they are situated; may inhibit present and future development of nearby properties; and/or may confer upon their owners and users a position of unfair advantage. Non-conforming situations should be abolished or brought to conformity as quickly as the fair interest to the parties will permit. 19.03 Non-Conforming Uses of Lots Where, on the date of adoption or amendment of this Ordinance, a lawful use of a parcel or lot, on which no buildings exist, no longer conforms to the provisions of this Ordinance or amendment thereto, such principal use may be continued so long as it remains otherwise lawful, subject to the following provisions: 1. No such non-conforming use of a parcel or lot shall be enlarged, expanded or extended to occupy a greater area of land than was occupied on the date of adoption or amendment of this Ordinance and no additional accessory use, building or structure shall be established thereon. 2. No such non-conforming use of a parcel or lot shall be moved in whole or in part to any other portion of such parcel or lot not so occupied on the date of adoption of this Ordinance or amendment thereto or to a parcel or lot not in conformance with this Ordinance. 3. When a non-conforming use of a parcel or lot is discontinued or abandoned for more than six (6) months (except where government action prevents access to the premises), the parcel or lot shall not thereafter be used except in conformance with the regulations of the district in which it is located. 19.04 Non-Conforming Buildings and Structures Where, on the date of adoption or amendment of this Ordinance, a lawful building or structure exists that could not be built under the regulations of this Ordinance, or amendment thereto, by reason of restrictions upon lot area, lot width, lot coverage, height, open spaces, off-street parking, loading spaces and setbacks, or other characteristics (other than use), such building or structure may be continued so long as it remains otherwise lawful, subject to the following provisions: 1. Such building or structure may be enlarged, expanded, extended, or altered only if such building or structure modification conforms to the requirements of this Ordinance and does not expand any dimensional nonconformity. 2. Should any such building or structure be damaged by any means to an extent of more than fifty percent (50%) of its replacement cost at the time of damage, it shall not be reconstructed except in conformity with the provisions of this Ordinance. UPDATED April 2015 19-1 January 2007 Edition 3. Should any such building or structure be moved for any reason for any distance, it shall thereafter conform to the regulations of the district in which it is located after it is moved. 19.05 Non-Conforming Uses of Buildings and Structures Where, on the date of adoption or amendment of this Ordinance, a lawful use of a building or structure exists that is no longer permissible under the regulations of this Ordinance or amendment thereto, such use may be continued so long as it remains otherwise lawful, subject to the following provisions: 1. An existing building or structure shall not be enlarged, constructed, reconstructed, moved or structurally extended or altered except to change the use of such building or structure to a use permitted in the district in which such building or structure is located. 2. Although an existing non-conforming use may continue, except as hereinafter limited, it may not be changed to another use, except to a use of the same or of a less intense nature, or a use permitted in the district in which it is situated. 3. When a non-conforming use of a building or structure is discontinued or abandoned for more than six (6) months(except where government action prevents access to the premises), the building or structure shall not thereafter be used except in conformance with the regulations of the district in which it is located. 4. When a non-conforming use of a building or structure changes ownership, use or tenancy the legal non-conforming use must be discontinued. 19.06 Repairs and Maintenance 1. Nothing in this Ordinance shall be deemed to prohibit the restoration of any structure and its use where such structure has been damaged by any means out of the control of the owner to an extent of less than fifty percent (50%) of its replacement value (excluding the value of the land, the cost of preparation of land, and the value of any foundation adaptable to a conforming use) at the time of damage, provided the restoration of such structure and its use in no way increases any former non- conformity. 2. Whenever such structure has been damaged to an extent of more than fifty percent (50%) of its replacement value (excluding the value of the land, the cost of preparation of land and the value of any foundation adaptable to a conforming use), at the time of damage, as determined by the Director of Community Development or by any means within the control of the owner to any extent whatsoever, the structure shall not be restored except in full conformity with all regulations of the district in which such structure is situated. 3. When a structure is determined to be in violation of any applicable health or safety code by the Director of Community Development under any applicable Code or Ordinance of the City and the cost of placing the structure in condition to satisfy the standards under such ordinance shall exceed fifty percent (50%) of the replacement cost of the structure, such non-conforming structure shall not be restored for the purpose of continuing a non-conforming use. 4. Repair or replacement of a damaged structure as permitted in Paragraph 1, above, shall be commenced in full compliance with the City’s Building Codes and other codes, within twelve (12 months of the occurrence of the damage and diligently managed to completion. Failure to begin repair within that twelve (12) month period, or the commencement of repairs in violation of other Codes, will result in the forfeiture of the rights provided by this Article and after that period, the building or structure may only be repaired and/or used in full compliance with the provisions of this Ordinance. UPDATED April 2015 19-2 January 2007 Edition 19.07 Reversion Prohibited Whenever any part of a nonconforming lot, structure or use has been amortized, changed, converted to or replaced by a conforming structure or use, or if the previous nonconformity is brought into conformity with this Ordinance, such building, structure or lot shall not thereafter be altered, used or occupied by the same, nor any other, nonconformity, or nonconforming use or structure. 19.08 Enlargement / Replacement of Non-conforming Residential Dwellings Within Commercial Districts Within the NC, LC, GC and CBD zoning districts, a non-conforming residential dwelling, where such was created by adoption of this ordinance, or amendment thereto, and not by actions of the property owner, may be enlarged, altered or replaced, provided such activity does not increase a dimensional non-conformity. 19.09 Change of Tenancy or Ownership Provided there is no change in the nature or character, extent or intensity of such non-conforming use, building or structure (other than signage), there may be a change of tenancy, ownership or management of an existing non- conforming use, building or structure. 19.10 Completion of Pending Construction and Building Permits To avoid undue hardships, nothing in this Ordinance shall be deemed to require a change in plans, construction, or designated use of any building on which actual construction was lawfully begun prior to the effective date of adoption or amendment of this Ordinance and upon which actual building construction has been carried on diligently. Nothing herein contained shall require any change in the site plan or designated use of a building for which a building permit had been heretofore issued, or plans or preliminary or final subdivision plats which have been approved by the City at the time of the passage of this Ordinance or amendment provided that actual construction is begun within one-hundred eighty (180) days of such permit issuance or approval thereto. 19.11 Special Uses Any use existing at the time of adoption or amendment to this Ordinance and which is permitted as a special use in the district in which said use is located under the terms of this Ordinance or amendment, shall be deemed a legal non-conforming use in such district until such time as a Special Use Permit may be issued to bring the property into conformity. 19.12 Existence of a Non-Conforming Use A non-conformity shall not be deemed to have existed on the date this Ordinance or any amendment thereto became effective; unless: 1. It was being used on a continuous basis and to its fullest extent on such date. 2. If such non-conformity is a use, such use had not been abandoned or discontinued. In cases of doubt, and on specific questions raised, whether a non-conforming use exists shall be a question of fact and shall be decided by the Council after notice, a public hearing, and receipt of a report and recommendation of the Planning and Zoning Commission. UPDATED April 2015 19-3 January 2007 Edition 19.13 Non-conforming Lots of Record Lots of record, established prior to the effective date of this Ordinance or amendments thereto, that have size and/or dimensional non-conformities may be used for purposes allowable by this Ordinance, provided that all buildings placed on such lots meet the required setbacks in that Zoning District. 19.14 Non-conformity as Basis for Variance The existence of any non-conformity anywhere in the City shall not itself be considered grounds for the issuance of a variance for that property or any other property. UPDATED April 2015 19-4 January 2007 Edition ARTICLE 20 AMENDMENTS 20.01 Authority to Amend Ordinance The regulations imposed and districts created under this Ordinance may be amended from time to time by Ordinance, after the Ordinance establishing them has gone into effect. Amendments shall be made in accordance with the regulations of this Article and applicable Illinois State Statutes. 20.02 Types of Amendments Amendments shall be classified as follows: 1. Text Amendments: Amendments to the regulations contained in this Ordinance shall be referred to as "Text Amendments." 2. Map Amendments: Amendments to the location of district boundaries on the Official Zoning Map shall be referred to as "Map Amendments" (also referred to as a rezoning). 20.03 Text Amendments 20.03.01 Initiation of Text Amendments Text amendments may be initiated by the City Council or the Plan Commission, or which may be initiated by them in response to a request by any City Board or staff member. A text amendment may also be requested by any other person provided an appropriate application for such is submitted in accordance with this section. 20.03.02 Application for Text Amendment Persons applying for a text amendment shall do so by completing and submitting the appropriate application forms provided by the Department of Planning. The application must state the exact section of this Ordinance proposed for amendment, the proposed substitute wording, the reasons for requesting the amendment, and any other information that the Community Development Director may require. Graphic materials may also be submitted if it will assist in understanding the benefits of the amendment. 20.03.03 Public Notice Requirement The Community Development Director shall be responsible that notice of the time, date, and place of the required public hearing be given not more than thirty (30) nor less than fifteen (15) days before the hearing by publishing a notice thereof at least once in a newspaper having general circulation in the City of DeKalb. 20-1 January 2007 Edition 20.03.04 Text Amendment Review Procedure 1. The Community Development Director shall review the proposed text amendment. The Community Development Director shall solicit the opinions and comments of other City staff members and shall recommend to the Plan Commission the approval or denial of the proposed text amendment or approval of a modified version of the proposed text amendment. 2. The Plan Commission shall hold a public hearing and shall consider the proposed text amendment and relevant facts presented by the applicant or his/her representative, City staff, or by any interested citizen. Once the Plan Commission is satisfied that they have heard all relevant facts, they shall recommend to the City Council approval or denial of the proposed text amendment or the approval of a modified version of the proposed text amendment. 3. Upon receipt of the Plan Commission's recommendation, the City Council shall consider the proposed text amendment. The adoption of an ordinance that amends any of the following Articles shall require a favorable vote of two-thirds (2/3) of the City Council members then holding office: Article 5 (Zoning District Regulations); Article 6.02 (South Annie Glidden Corridor Overlay District); Article 7 (Supplementary District Regulations); Article 12 (Off-Street Parking and Loading Requirements); Article 13 (Signs) The adoption of an Ordinance that amends any portions of all other Articles not otherwise mentioned above shall require a simple majority vote of the City Council members present. (ORD 98-86) 20.04 Map Amendments (Rezoning) 20.04.01 Initiation of Map Amendments Map amendments may be initiated by the City Council or the Plan Commission, which may be in response to a request by any City board or staff member. A map amendment may also be requested by the owner(s), or authorized representative(s) of the owner(s), of property within the area subjected to the proposed map amendment provided an appropriate application for such is submitted in accordance with this section. 20.04.02 Application for Map Amendment 1. A request for a Map Amendment, or change of zoning, is called a petition to rezone and is filed with the City Clerk. The application form for a petition to rezone is available from the Department of Planning. In addition to submitting the completed application, the petitioner shall be required to submit the following information: a. Legal owners of the property(s) to be rezoned. If the property is held in an Illinois Land Trust, a Statement of Beneficiary Interest is also required; b. Legal Description of the property(s) to be rezoned; c. Common street address of property(s) to be rezoned; d. Size of property (in square feet or acres); 20-2 January 2007 Edition e. Current zoning of property; f. Requested zoning of property; g. Narrative description of the reasons for requested rezoning; h. Estimated impact of rezoning on surrounding neighborhood; I. Vicinity map showing the area to be rezoned; 2. At the time of submitting a petition to rezone, the petitioner may submit to the City certified petitions of signatures of area residents supporting the rezoning. Such petitions are optional. 3. At the time of submitting a petition to rezone, the applicant shall also furnish to the City a list of owners and their mailing addresses of all property within two-hundred fifty (250) feet of the property that is the subject of the proposed rezoning. This distance shall be measured in all directions from the boundaries of the subject property and shall not include distances devoted to adjoining or nearby public rights-of-way. In all instances, the furnished list shall include the names and addresses of a minimum of ten (10) property owners. Should the two-hundred fifty (250) foot notification area not result in a list of ten (10) property owners then the notification shall be appropriately expanded until this minimum has been met. In expanding the notification area, preference shall be given towards those properties comprised of urban-sized lots or in areas most likely to be affected by the proposal. 4. Nothing shall preclude an applicant from submitting a single petition that includes requests for two or more zoning districts on a single tract of land and which would be subjected to only one application fee and one public hearing process. However, this shall not preclude the City Council from considering and possibly adopting separate ordinances that would approve the individual rezoning requests. 20.04.03 Public Notice Requirement 1. The Community Development Director shall be responsible that notice of the time, date, and place of the required public hearing, along with a legal description of the property that is the subject of the public hearing, be given not more than thirty (30) nor less than fifteen (15) days before the hearing by publishing a notice thereof at least once in a newspaper having general circulation in the City of DeKalb. 2. The Community Development Director shall mail a notice of the public hearing to those property owners whose names are furnished by the applicant. Notice of public hearing shall also be mailed to all applicable governmental agencies, including but not limited to: School District, Park District, Sanitary District, Drainage District, and the Soil and Water Conservation District. 3. The Community Development Director may require the applicant to erect a sign or signs on the subject property not less than fifteen (15) days before the scheduled public hearing by the Plan Commission. The sign(s) shall have on their surface a notice that the property is to be the subject of a public hearing and shall not be removed until the City Council has taken final action on the rezoning petition. There shall be one (1) sign erected for every public street frontage and it shall be clearly visible from the adjacent or nearest public rights-of-way. All signs shall be furnished by the City after receiving from the applicant any appropriate deposits. The deposits shall be returned to the applicant upon the timely return of the sign or signs in good condition. 20-3 January 2007 Edition 20.04.04 Map Amendment Review Procedure 1. The Community Development Director shall review the rezoning petition. The Community Development Director shall solicit the opinions and comments of other City staff members and, along with the comments received from property owners, governmental agencies, etc., shall forward to the Plan Commission his/her recommendation of approval or denial of the rezoning petition or approval of a modified version of the rezoning petition. 2. The Plan Commission shall hold a public hearing and shall consider the rezoning petition and relevant facts presented by the applicant or his/her representative, City staff, other governmental agencies, or by any interested citizen. Once the Plan Commission is satisfied that they have heard all relevant facts, they shall recommend to the City Council that the rezoning petition be approved or denied for all or part of the subject property. Alternatively, the Plan Commission may recommend approval of an amendment to the rezoning petition to a zoning district classification more restrictive than the zoning district classification originally requested by the applicant. For the purpose of this section, the SFR-1 District shall be considered the most restrictive classification and the HI District shall be considered the least restrictive classification. In making their recommendation, the Plan Commission shall consider and adopt findings in each of the following: a. The proposed rezoning conforms to the Comprehensive Plan; or conditions or trends of development have changed in the area of the request, since the adoption of the Comprehensive Plan, to warrant the need for different types of land uses or densities. Furthermore, the proposed rezoning is appropriate considering the length of time the property has been vacant, as originally zoned, and taking into account the surrounding area's trend of development; b. The proposed rezoning conforms to the intent and purpose of this Ordinance; c. The proposed rezoning will not have a significant detrimental effect on the long- range development of adjacent properties or on adjacent land uses; d. The proposed rezoning constitutes an expansion of an existing zoning district that, due to the lack of undeveloped land, can no longer meet the demand for the intended land uses; e. Adequate public facilities and services exist or can be provided. 3. Upon receipt of the Plan Commission's recommendation, the City Council shall consider the proposed map amendment. The adoption of an ordinance that affirms or reverses the Plan Commission's recommendation for a map amendment shall require a favorable vote of a simple majority of the City Council members present. 20.04.05 Protest Procedure 1. If a formal written protest to a proposed map amendment, signed and acknowledge by certain property owners as hereinafter described, is filed with the City Clerk not less than twenty-four (24) hours prior to the City Council meeting at which the proposed map amendment is to be considered, the proposed map amendment shall not be approved except by a favorable vote of two-thirds (2/3) of the City Council members then holding office. In order for the written protest to be valid, property owners whose signatures 20-4 January 2007 Edition appear on the protest shall own property in the following manner: a. Owners of twenty percent (20%) of the property proposed to be rezoned, or b. Owners of property comprising twenty percent (20%) of the frontage directly opposite the frontage of the property proposed to be rezoned or across an alley therefrom, or c. Owners of property comprising twenty percent (20%) of the property that is immediately adjacent and contiguous to the property proposed to be rezoned. 2. Further, in order for the written protest to be valid, a copy of said protest shall be served by the protester(s) on the applicant(s) for the proposed map amendment and a copy upon the applicant's attorney, if any, by certified mail at the address of such applicant and attorney shown on the application for the proposed map amendment. 20.04.06 Resubmission of Application From the date of the City Council action on the Planning Commission's report on an application for a Map Amendment, no subsequent application requesting the same classification with reference to the same property, or part thereof, shall be filed within twelve (12) months from said receipt and filing. 20-5 January 2007 Edition