Historic Design Review Commission

City of San Antonio AGENDA Historic Design Review Commission Meeting Development and Business Service Center 1901 South Alamo San Antonio, Texas 78204 Wednesday, July 19, 2023 3:00 PM The Historic and Design Review Commission will hold its regular meeting in the Board Room at 1901 South Alamo, beginning at 3:00 p.m. Once a quorum is established, the Historic and Design Review Commission will take up the following items no sooner than the designated times. To watch and listen to this meeting, visit www.sanantonio.gov/DSD/Boards/MeetingVideos. To call to listen to audio only, in English or Spanish, call 210­206­LIVE (5483). Members of the public can comment on items on the agenda, consistent with procedural rules governing HDRC meetings and state law. Public comments may also be provided as follows: 1. Leave a voice message a maximum of two minutes by dialing 210­206­HDRC(4372) by 12 noon on the day of the meeting. Voicemail messages will be played during the meeting. Please include your full name, home or work address, the item number and item address of the request. 2. Submit written comments to HistoricDesignReviewCommission@sanantonio.gov by 12 noon on the day of the meeting. Please include your full name, home or work address, the item number and item address of the request. Written comments will be part of the official written record only. 3. Attend the in­person hearing and signup to speak before the meeting begins at 3 PM. Each member of the public will have two minutes to speak unless otherwise directed by the Chair. 3:00 P.M. – Call to Order Roll Call Chairman’s Statement Public Comments Approval of Minutes Approval of minutes for the February 1, 2023, February 15, 2023, and June 21, 2023, Historic and Design Review Commission meetings. 3. Attend the in­person hearing and signup to speak before the meeting begins at 3 PM. Each member of the public will have two minutes to speak unless otherwise directed by the Chair. 3:00 P.M. – Call to Order Roll Call Chairman’s Statement Public Comments Approval of Minutes Approval of minutes for the February 1, 2023, February 15, 2023, and June 21, 2023, Historic and Design Review Commission meetings. CONSENT AGENDA Items are placed on the consent agenda when staff recommends approval or recommends approval with stipulations that the applicant agrees to. Any member of the public desiring to speak on a consent agenda item may sign up and be heard prior to voting on the consent agenda. Commissioners may request to remove any item from the consent agenda and have it placed on the individual consideration agenda. All items on the consent agenda will be considered for approval by one motion adopting the items with staff findings and recommendations. 1. Address/Description: 11115 WURZBACH RD HDRC Case No.: 2023­273 Applicant: JAYHAWK GROUP LP (by Caroline McDonald, Brown and McDonald PLLC, Auth. Rep.) Request: Historic Landmark Designation City Council Dist.: 8 2. Address/Description: 720 N ST MARYS ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­221 RIO District: RIO­3 Applicant: Jimmy Serenil/Brothers Excavation & concrete LLC Request: Exterior and fenestration modifications, storefront system modifications, construction of an addition, canopy installation City Council Dist.: 1 3. Address/Description: 219 VILLITA ST/145 NAVARRO HDRC Case No.: 2023­258 RIO District: RIO­3 Applicant: Peter Ketter/Sandvick Architects Request: Amendment to previously approved design of rooftop addition; infill of windows City Council Dist.: 1 4. Address/Description: 1210 E ELMIRA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­261 RIO District: RIO­2 Applicant: Michael Elder/Oxbow Real Estate, LLC Request: Construction of an 8­story hotel City Council Dist.: 1  Applicant: Peter Ketter/Sandvick Architects Request: Amendment to previously approved design of rooftop addition; infill of windows City Council Dist.: 1 4. Address/Description: 1210 E ELMIRA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­261 RIO District: RIO­2 Applicant: Michael Elder/Oxbow Real Estate, LLC Request: Construction of an 8­story hotel City Council Dist.: 1 5. Address/Description: 250 LAUREL HEIGHTS PLACE HDRC Case No.: 2023­262 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: Mauricio Tafoya/Leon Studio, LLC Request: Construction of a 1­story, rear accessory structure City Council Dist.: 1 6. Address/Description: 123 N ST MARYS ST/St. Mary’s Street Bridge, River Level HDRC Case No.: 2023­229 Public Property: St. Mary’s Street Bridge, River Level RIO District: RIO­3 Applicant: Grace Boudewyns/Lake Flato Architects Request: Installation of site elements and construction of an outdoor bar beneath the N St Mary's river bridge City Council Dist.: 1 7. Address/Description: 510 E LOCUST HDRC Case No.: 2023­259 Historic District Name: Tobin Hill Applicant: Kandice Lauderdale/Wholehearted Real Estate Request: Historic Tax Verification City Council Dist.: 1 8. Address/Description: 109 MAGNOLIA DR HDRC Case No.: 2023­270 Historic District Name: River Road RIO District: RIO­1 Applicant: Shelley Ann Bourgeois & Edward Michael Chapa Request: Historic Tax Certification City Council Dist.: 1 9. Address/Description: 620 S PRESA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­279 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Eluterio Tenorio/ETDesign Studio Request: Roof and parapet modifications City Council Dist.: 1 10. Address/Description: 217 VANCE ST  City Council Dist.: 1 9. Address/Description: 620 S PRESA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­279 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Eluterio Tenorio/ETDesign Studio Request: Roof and parapet modifications City Council Dist.: 1 10. Address/Description: 217 VANCE ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­227 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Vicki Yuan Request: Demolition of a rear accessory structure and new construction of a 1­story rear accessory structure City Council Dist.: 11. Address/Description: 434 ADAMS ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­250 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Jake Dady /DADY JACOB MATTHEW Request: Conceptual approval of a two­story accessory structure City Council Dist.: 1 12. Address/Description: 211 LOSOYA ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­248 Historic District Name: Alamo Plaza RIO District: RIO­3 Applicant: Joseph Marroquin Sr/Colt Professional Facility Repair Request: Fencing City Council Dist.: 1 13. Address/Description: 1020 BURNET ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­249 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Yolanda Guajardo/BRIDGE GROUP LLC Request: New construction of a one­story accessory structure City Council Dist.: 2 14. Address/Description: 1431 E COMMERCE ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­272 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Roxanne Lozano/Industry Signs, LLC Request: Signage City Council Dist.: 2 15. Address/Description: 502 SHERMAN ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­277 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Rogelio Dipp Fuentes /Arangon Builders Request: Window replacement, porch construction, porch modifications  HDRC Case No.: 2023­272 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Roxanne Lozano/Industry Signs, LLC Request: Signage City Council Dist.: 2 15. Address/Description: 502 SHERMAN ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­277 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Rogelio Dipp Fuentes /Arangon Builders Request: Window replacement, porch construction, porch modifications City Council Dist.: 2 16. Address/Description: 606 DAWSON ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­252 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Cotton Estes/Cotton Estes Architect PLLC Request: New construction of a rear accessory building City Council Dist.: 2 17. Address/Description: 311 CEDAR ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­224 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: Robert Alvarado Request: Roofing replacement City Council Dist.: 1 18. Address/Description: 210 NOLAN ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­242 Historic District Name: Healy­Murphy Applicant: Patrick Partch/City of San Antonio Request: Park modifications City Council Dist.: 2 19. Address/Description: 813 BURLESON ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­230 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Kyle Braunlich/BRAUNLICH KYLE W Request: Deconstruction of a rear accessory City Council Dist.: 2 20. Address/Description: 823 CAMDEN ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­253 Applicant: Michael McCrea/Pawneem, LLC Request: Demolition of rear shed and carport, detached garage construction, and roofing replacement City Council Dist.: 1 21. Address/Description: 335 KING WILLIAM HDRC Case No.: 2023­254 Historic District Name: King William RIO District: RIO­4 Applicant: Cameron Smith/Smithdish Architecture 20. Address/Description: 823 CAMDEN ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­253 Applicant: Michael McCrea/Pawneem, LLC Request: Demolition of rear shed and carport, detached garage construction, and roofing replacement City Council Dist.: 1 21. Address/Description: 335 KING WILLIAM HDRC Case No.: 2023­254 Historic District Name: King William RIO District: RIO­4 Applicant: Cameron Smith/Smithdish Architecture Request: Shade structures installation City Council Dist.: 1 22. Address/Description: 2507 FREDERICKSBURG RD HDRC Case No.: 2023­246 Historic District Name: Monticello Park Applicant: Cynthia Garcia/four brothers fences Request: Fence and gate installation City Council Dist.: 7 INDIVIDUAL CONSIDERATION New cases 23. Address/Description: 616/618 WILMINGTON AVE – POSTPONED HDRC Case No.: 2022­557 Applicant: Office of Historic Preservation Request: Recommendation for Historic Landmark Designation City Council Dist.: 1 24. Address/Description: 415 N MESQUITE ST/105 ­ 113 BROWN ALLEY HDRC Case No.: 2023­247 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Luisa Naves/VERGEL CONSTRUCTION LLC Request: Construction of six, multi­story residential structures City Council Dist.: 2 25. Address/Description: 116 CAMARGO HDRC Case No.: 2023­271 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Nate Manfred/French & Michigan Request: Amendment to a previously approved design; removal of caliche wing and reconstruction with wood framing City Council Dist.: 1 26. Address/Description: 119 E MAGNOLIA AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­278 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: charles ramon/RAMON CHARLES  HDRC Case No.: 2023­271 Historic District Name: Lavaca Applicant: Nate Manfred/French & Michigan Request: Amendment to a previously approved design; removal of caliche wing and reconstruction with wood framing City Council Dist.: 1 26. Address/Description: 119 E MAGNOLIA AVE HDRC Case No.: 2023­278 Historic District Name: Monte Vista Applicant: charles ramon/RAMON CHARLES Request: Construction of a brick site wall City Council Dist.: 1 27. Address/Description: 1921 FREDERICKSBURG RD HDRC Case No.: 2023­276 Historic District Name: Monticello Park Applicant: Alberto Salazar Request: Fence installation City Council Dist.: 7 28. Address/Description: 814 N OLIVE ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­268 Historic District Name: Dignowity Hill Applicant: Brad Clawson/Elise Construction Request: Amendment to previously­approved design for new construction of three two­story residences City Council Dist.: 2 29. Address/Description: 114 DEWBERRY ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­257 Historic District Name: River Road RIO District: RIO­1 Applicant: Andrea Longoria/Brio Builders Request: New construction of a two­story house City Council Dist.: 1 30. Address/Description: 300 SAN FERNANDO ST HDRC Case No.: 2023­251 Applicant: Robert Belden JR/Accu­Rite Roofing and Construction Services Request: Signage City Council Dist.: 5 31. Address/Description: 411 E EVERGREEN HDRC Case No.: 2023­243 Historic District Name: Tobin Hill Applicant: GLADYS AYARZAGOITIA/GMAM Request: Fenestration modifications City Council Dist.: 1  Applicant: Robert Belden JR/Accu­Rite Roofing and Construction Services Request: Signage City Council Dist.: 5 31. Address/Description: 411 E EVERGREEN HDRC Case No.: 2023­243 Historic District Name: Tobin Hill Applicant: GLADYS AYARZAGOITIA/GMAM Request: Fenestration modifications City Council Dist.: 1 32. Address/Description: 2119 N IH 35 HDRC Case No.: 2023­265 Historic District Name: Government Hill Applicant: Pedro Ramos/PR Custom Signs Request: Signage City Council Dist.: 2 33. Address/Description: 328 MADISON ST – WITHDRAWN BY APPLICANT HDRC Case No.: 2023­244 Historic District Name: King William Applicant: George Torres III/George Torres Architect PLLC Request: Conceptual review of porch floor replacement, porch roof replacement (shingle to metal), partial demolition, rear porch addition, fenestration changes, hardscaping, fencing, and garage modifications City Council Dist.: 1 Adjourn At any time during the meeting, the Historic and Design Review Commission may meet in executive session for consultation with the City Attorney's Office concerning attorney­client matters under Chapter 551 of the Texas Government Code. ACCESSIBILITY STATEMENT The City of San Antonio ensures meaningful access to City meetings, programs and services by reasonably providing: translation and interpretation, materials in alternate formats, and other accommodations upon request. To request these services call (210) 207​2098 or Relay Texas 711 or by requesting these services online at https://www.sanantonio.gov/gpa/LanguageServices. Providing at least 72 hours’ notice will help to ensure availability. DECLARACIÓN DE ACCESO La Ciudad de San Antonio garantiza acceso a las reuniones, los programas y los servicios de la Ciudad proporcionando: traducción e interpretación, materiales en formatos alternativos y otras adaptaciones a pedido. Para solicitar estos servicios llame al (210) 207¬2098 o Relay Texas 711 o solicite estos servicios en línea en https://www.sanantonio.gov/gpa/LanguageServices. Dando un aviso al menos 72 horas antes ayudará a garantizar la disponibilidad. requesting these services online at https://www.sanantonio.gov/gpa/LanguageServices. Providing at least 72 hours’ notice will help to ensure availability. DECLARACIÓN DE ACCESO La Ciudad de San Antonio garantiza acceso a las reuniones, los programas y los servicios de la Ciudad proporcionando: traducción e interpretación, materiales en formatos alternativos y otras adaptaciones a pedido. Para solicitar estos servicios llame al (210) 207¬2098 o Relay Texas 711 o solicite estos servicios en línea en https://www.sanantonio.gov/gpa/LanguageServices. Dando un aviso al menos 72 horas antes ayudará a garantizar la disponibilidad. Posted on: 07/19/2023 08:45 AM