Muyni
← Back to Skokie

Zoning Board of Appeals

Regular Meeting

Skokie, IL · May 7, 2025

AgendaMinutes

Minutes

APPROVED on 5/21/2025 Zoning Board of Appeals Meeting Minutes Date: May 7, 2025 Village of Skokie, Council Chambers ZBA MEMBERS PRESENT: Brian O’Donnell - Chair Nicholas Werth- Vice-Chair Israel Pollack, Sean Arden, Elaine Jacobson, Sharon Roos-Kirkpatrick, David Putrus, and David Solovy ZBA MEMBER ABSENT: None Currently, there is 1 vacancy on the Board. STAFF PRESENT: Tyler Kobylski, Asst Corporation Council, Brian Augustine, Zoning Administrator, and Marlene Bargamian, Administrative Asst. (I) CALL TO ORDER A quorum being present, Chair O’Donnell called the meeting to order at 7:31 PM. (II) APPROVAL OF MINUTES A motion to approve the minutes of the March 5, 2025 meeting was made by ZBA member Jacobson and seconded by ZBA member Roos-Kirkpatrick. Ayes: Unanimous voice vote in unison (III) RULING ON NOTICE Assistant Corporation Counsel Kobylski announced that notice was proper and correct in all 3 cases. (IV) CASE DESCRIPTIONS Case 2025-02Z – 7656 Crawford Avenue Daniel & Maria Toma request a variation in order to construct a second-floor addition resulting in the continuation of the existing 7.86-foot side yard rather than the 10-foot minimum as required by Section 118-125(6) e. of the Skokie Zoning Ordinance in a R2 Single-Family district. PIN: 10-27-231-048-0000 Case 2025-03Z – 8950 East Prairie Road Katherine & Samuel Garfinkel, on behalf of Andrew Venamore of Heartland Garage Builders, LLC, request a variation in order to construct an attached garage resulting in a 5-foot front yard rather than the 25-foot minimum as required by Section 118-124(5) of the Skokie Zoning Ordinance in an R1 Single-Family district. PIN: 10-14-414-001-0000 Case 2025-04Z – 5011 Estes Avenue Admir & Ajla Rosic request a variation in order to construct a 2nd floor addition resulting in the continuation of 3.62-foot side yard rather than the 4.00-foot minimum as required by Section 118- 125(6) a, of the Skokie Zoning Ordinance in a R2 Single-Family district. PIN: 10-33-209-042-0000 # 626483 Zoning Board of Appeals meeting minutes May 7, 2025 APPROVED on 5/21/2025 Brian Augustine, Zoning Administrator, stated the Case 2025-03Z has been continued by staff for further discussion & review. It will be on the agenda for the next meeting; May 21, 2025 and no further notice is needed. Case 2025-02Z Nathan Kriska, architect for the petitioners, gave a simple overview of the project. Daniel & Maria Toma have been residents of Skokie for 23 years. They are a family of 4 with two young boys and want to stay in the area. The 2nd floor addition will be going straight up maintaining the existing setbacks. Zoning Board member Elaine Jacobson, on a site visit, noted that the residence is a corner property with the main entry on Brummel. There are other houses in the area with the same type of addition. She sees no objection to granting the variance. Staff is supportive of the request as all existing setbacks will be maintained with no further encroachment into the yard. There were no questions from the ZBA panel. Maria Toma was in the audience but chose not to speak. Mr. Kriska had nothing more to add. Case 2025-04Z Admir Rosic, petitioner and home owner described his project. The family of 4 have lived in the house since 2015. A 1st floor addition was constructed in 1966 and placed too close to the lot line. The children are growing and they need more space. The family wishes to stay put. The proposed addition will be built over the1st floor addition maintaining the same setback. The 3.62- foot side yard is only on the rear addition which is only 18.81 feet. Staff is supportive of the request. On a site visit, ZBA member Israel Pollack noted that the home fits in the neighborhood and acknowledged the letters of support from the neighbors. There were no questions from the ZBA members. In closing Mr. Rosic stated that the project was slowed down for being less than 5” too short. (V) RECOMMENDATIONS AND VOTING Case 2025-02Z A motion was made to grant the variance request without conditions to construct a 2nd floor addition resulting in a 7.86-foot side yard rather than the 10-foot minimum as required by Section 118-125(6) e. of the Skokie Zoning Ordinance in a R2 Single-Family district. Motion: Jacobson Second: Putrus Ayes: 8 Nays: 0 A covenant is required. Case 2025-04Z A motion was made to grant the variance request without conditions to construct a 2nd floor addition resulting in a 3.62-foot side yard rather than the 4-foot minimum as required by Section 118-125(6) a. of the Skokie Zoning Ordinance in a R2 Single-Family district. Motion: Pollack Second: Solovy # 626483 Zoning Board of Appeals meeting minutes May 7, 2025 APPROVED on 5/21/2025 Ayes: 8 Nays: 0 A covenant is required. (VI) ITEMS FOR COMMUNICATION Case 2025-03Z, assigned to Dave Putrus, has been continued to the May 21, 2025 meeting. (VII) ADJOURNMENT Chair O’Donnell adjourned the meeting at 7:58 PM. Respectfully submitted, Marlene Bargamian, Administrative Assistant # 626483 Zoning Board of Appeals meeting minutes May 7, 2025

Agenda

Agenda for ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS May 7, 2025 | 7:30 PM Council Chambers – Village of Hall – 5127 Oakton Street, Skokie, IL 60077 1) Call to Order & Declaration of Quorum 2) Roll Call 3) Approval of March 5, 2025 Meeting Minutes 4) Old Business 5) New Business a. 2025-02Z – 7656 Crawford Avenue Daniel & Maria Toma request a variation in order to construct a second-floor addition resulting in the continuation of the existing 7.86-foot side yard abutting a street rather than the 10-foot minimum as required by Section 118-125(6)e. of the Skokie Zoning Ordinance in an R2 Single- Family zoning district. PIN: 10-27-231-048-0000 b. 2025-03Z – 8950 East Prairie Road Katherine and Samuel Garfinkel, on behalf of Andrew Venamore of Heartland Garage Builders LLC, request a variation in order to construct an attached garage resulting in a 5-foot front yard rather than the 25-foot minimum as required by Section 118-124(5) of the Skokie Zoning Ordinance in a R1 Single-Family zoning district. PIN: 10-14-414-001-0000 c. 2025-04Z – 5011 Estes Avenue Admir & Ajla Rosic request a variation in order to construct a second-floor addition resulting in the continuation of the 3.62-foot side yard rather than the 4-foot minimum as required by Section 118-125 (6) a. of the Skokie Zoning Ordinance in an R2 Single-Family zoning district. PIN: 10-33-209-042-0000 Individuals with questions or feedback about an agenda item may contact Brian Augustine, Zoning Administrator at brian.augustine@skokie.org or 847.933.8223 All emails and comments submitted will be made public and shared with this body. The Village, in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, requests that persons with disabilities who require certain accommodations to allow them to observe or participate in this hearing, or who have questions about the accessibility of the meeting facilities, contact the Village’s ADA coordinator Angel Schnur at angel.schnur@skokie.org or 847.933.8400. The Village encourages individuals to sign-up for its eNews for important information from the City and its government partners by visiting www.skokie.org VOSDOCS-#623226-v3-May_7__2025_Zoning_Board_of_Appeals_meeting_agenda 6) Public Comment 7) Communications from Staff 8) Adjournment Individuals with questions or feedback about an agenda item may contact Brian Augustine, Zoning Administrator at brian.augustine@skokie.org or 847.933.8223 All emails and comments submitted will be made public and shared with this body. The Village, in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act, requests that persons with disabilities who require certain accommodations to allow them to observe or participate in this hearing, or who have questions about the accessibility of the meeting facilities, contact the Village’s ADA coordinator Angel Schnur at angel.schnur@skokie.org or 847.933.8400. The Village encourages individuals to sign-up for its eNews for important information from the City and its government partners by visiting www.skokie.org VOSDOCS-#623226-v3-May_7__2025_Zoning_Board_of_Appeals_meeting_agenda DRAFT/ NOT APPROVED Zoning Board of Appeals Meeting Minutes Date: March 5, 2025 Village of Skokie, Council Chambers ZBA MEMBERS PRESENT: Brian O’Donnell - Chair Nicholas Werth- Vice-Chair Sean Arden, Elaine Jacobson, Sharon Roos-Kirkpatrick, and David Putrus, ZBA MEMBER ABSENT: Israel Pollack and David Solovy Currently, there is 1 vacancy on the Board. STAFF PRESENT: Tyler Kobylski, Asst Corporation Council, Brian Augustine, Zoning Administrator, and Marlene Bargamian, Administrative Asst. (I) CALL TO ORDER A quorum being present, Chair O’Donnell called the meeting to order at 7:30 PM. (II) APPROVAL OF MINUTES A motion to approve the minutes of the January 15, 2025 meeting was made by ZBA member Jacobson and seconded by ZBA member Roos-Kirkpatrick. Ayes: Unanimous voice vote in unison (III) RULING ON NOTICE Assistant Corporation Counsel Kobylski announced that notice was proper and correct. (IV) CASE DESCRIPTION Case 2025-01Z – 9221 Tripp Avenue Rajeev & Shreekirit Kapur request a variation in order to construct an addition resulting in a 3.5- foot side yard rather than the 6-foot minimum as required by Section 118-124(6)a. of the Skokie Village Code in a R1 Single-Family district. PIN: 10-15-226-046-0000 Mr. Rajeev Kapur, property owner & applicant, presented the case. They were planning to add on to their house for a long time. When COVID hit, they put their plans aside. They recently decided to move forward with their proposal of building a 2-car garage, utility room and bedroom on the north side of the property. After reviewing staff’s negative recommendation and alternative suggestion of the rear yard placement of the garage and upper story bedroom options, the petitioner stated that a rear yard garage will take up the back yard space and they don’t want a 2nd floor bedroom. Construction will be too disruptive while living in the house. He noted that there are some properties in the neighborhood that do not conform to the 6-ft side yard requirement. Mr. Kapur stated that his adjacent neighbor has no objections and aesthetically, his proposal is the cleanest and most efficient use of the north side space. Brian Augustine, Zoning Administrator, gave some background of the area. Sprinkled throughout Skokie are sub-standard lots that became buildable in the 1950s and 60s by way of a variance. The subject site is one of 2 homes on the block that were built on sub-standard lots. The addition will be 3.5-feet from the north lot line. # 625118 Zoning Board of Appeals meeting minutes March 5, 2025 DRAFT/ NOT APPROVED Zoning Board member Sean Arden, on a site visit, noted that there is no alley and a rear yard garage would need a long driveway to access it; therefore, increasing the impermeable surface. There was no neighbor complaint to the request and building a rear yard garage would be a violation of rear yard space. It was also noted that a rear yard garage would possibly be disturbing to neighbors whom might have bedrooms facing the rear yards. A garage in the front would be less noisy. To him, the request does not seem obsessive. Chairman O’Donnell stated that when reviewing the report, he had the opinion of concurring with staff’s recommendation but after hearing from the petitioner and comments from board member Arden, he has reversed his decision. He also noted that even if a 1½ car garage was constructed, the bedroom addition would still intrude into the rear yard. Additionally, mature trees would need to be ripped out to place the garage in the rear yard. When asked, the petitioner did not have anything more to add. Staff, in closing, reminded all that the case still needs to be presented to the Appearance Commission for a Certificate of Appropriateness before submitting building plans for permit. Brian also mentioned the passing of an ordinance recently which states variance requests in residential districts will not be accepted for front yard garages if a rear alley is present. He also spoke about future cases coming before the Zoning Board when standard regulations regarding outdoor dining requests are being modified; such as longer hours, or a longer season outside the April through October period. (V) RECOMMENDATIONS AND VOTING Case 2025-01Z A motion was made to approve the variance request to construct an addition resulting in a 3.5- foot side yard rather than the 6-foot minimum as required by Section 118-124(6)a. of the Skokie Village Code in a R1 Single-Family district. Motion: S. Arden Second: S. Roos-Kirkpatrick Ayes: 6 Nays: 0 A covenant is required. (VI) ITEMS FOR COMMUNICATION The March 19th and April 2nd, 2025 Zoning Board of Appeals meetings have been cancelled due to lack of cases. The next regularly scheduled meeting will be on April 16, 2025. (VII) ADJOURNMENT Chair O’Donnell adjourned the meeting at 7:56 PM. Respectfully submitted, Marlene Bargamian, Administrative Assistant # 625118 Zoning Board of Appeals meeting minutes March 5, 2025 STAFF REPORT 2025-02Z: Variation Community Development Department Council Chambers, 7:30 PM, May 7, 2025 To: Brian O’Donnell, Chairman, Zoning Board of Appeals From: Brian J. Augustine, Zoning Administrator Re: 7656 Crawford Ave – Side Yard Abutting a Street Variation General Information Location 7656 Crawford Ave Request Variation in order to construct a second-floor addition resulting in a 7.86-foot side yard abutting a street. Zoning Requirement 10-foot minimum side yard abutting a street (118-125(6)e.) Petitioner Daniel & Maria Toma Existing Zoning & R2 Single-Family – Detached residence Land Use North R2 Single-Family – Detached residence South R2 Single-Family – Detached residence East R2 Single-Family – Detached residence West R2 Single-Family – Detached residence Assigned to Elaine Jacobson SITE INFORMATION  The house was built without a variation in 1957.  The site abuts a public alley. PETITIONER’S SUBMITTAL The petitioner is requesting a variation in order to construct a second-floor addition over the existing first floor, resulting in a 7.86-foot side yard abutting a street rather than the 10-foot minimum. APPEARANCE COMMISSION The petitioner will need to submit architectural drawings and appear before the Appearance Commission if this request is approved. ZBA Staff Report for 2025-2Z – 7656 Crawford Ave – Doc 626230 STAFF ANALYSIS AND RECOMMENDATION Staff Comment and Review sheets were sent to all pertinent divisions and departments. Based on the proposed Findings of Fact, Staff recommends that the petitioner’s request to construct a second-floor addition resulting in a 7.86-foot side yard abutting a street, be granted. The petitioner is proposing to construct a second-floor addition over the existing detached residence. The home was constructed in 1957, without a variation. The proposed addition will maintain all of the existing setbacks of the existing first floor. Staff is supportive of the petitioner’s request to construct the second-floor addition because the applicant is maintaining all existing setbacks and is not further encroaching into any yard. ATTACHMENTS 1. Proposed Findings of Fact for 2025-02Z 2. Application for 2025-02Z 3. Petitioner Statement 4. Plat of Survey, dated March 7, 2025 5. Site Plan for 2025-02Z 6. Floor Plan for 2025-02Z 7. Zoning Information Worksheet 8. Aerial and Zoning Map, dated April 7, 2025 9. Photograph of subject site 10. Affidavit of Public Notice 11. Certificate of Publication ZBA Staff Report for 2025-2Z – 7656 Crawford Ave – Doc 626230 Proposed Findings of Fact 2025-02Z: Variation Community Development Department Council Chambers, 7:30 PM, May 7, 2025 1 Consideration Limitation on the use of the property due to physical, topographical, and geologic features. Finding The existing building was constructed without a variation in 1957. If the building was constructed with today’s setback requirements a variation would not be required. 2 Consideration The applicant can demonstrate that without a variance there can be no reasonable use of the property. Finding The applicant could demonstrate that without a variance there can be a reasonable use of the property. The addition could be built with a 10-foot setback with structural upgrades not typically found in second floor addition. 3 Consideration The granting of the variance is not based solely on economic reasons. Finding The granting of the variance does not appear to be based solely on economic reasons. 4 Consideration The necessity for the variance was not created by the property owner. Finding The necessity for the variance was not created by the property owner as the home was constructed without a variation in 1957 and met setback requirements at the time. 5 Consideration The variance requested is the minimum variance necessary to allow reasonable use of the property. Finding The request is the minimum to allow for reasonable use of the property. The proposed addition will be constructed over the existing building and continue the same setbacks. 6 Consideration The granting of the variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, or welfare. Finding The granting of the variance will not be injurious to public health, safety or welfare as the proposed addition will have to be constructed per building code regulations. The continuation of the existing setback should not impact public welfare. 7 Consideration The property subject to the variance request possesses one or more unique characteristics generally not applicable to similarly situated properties Finding The subject property is similar in size to other lots in the area. Some corner lots in area are similar and have substandard side yards abutting a street and some meet the code requirement. ZBA Staff Report for 2025-2Z – 7656 Crawford Ave – Doc 626230 01023104ÿ3ÿ6727ÿ89 9ÿ  ÿÿ!"#$  %&'ÿ(##)*! +&'ÿ,!-.#!/ 0 100 200 5967ÿ8 79ÿ:;6;0102 a 7b 34 <=>?@A=BCDEÿGHCÿIJKÿLMN>MDO=PBÿANQÿRISÿJN?TÿADCÿNMOÿ@=AU@CÿVMDÿANWÿP>CXÿB=>P>CXÿBMQ=V=?AO=MNÿMDÿQ=>?@M>PDCÿMVÿANWÿBAYÿYDMZ=QCQÿPNQCDÿAYY@=?AU@Cÿ@A[TÿÿGH=>ÿBAYÿ=>ÿVMDÿ\CNCDA@ÿ=NVMDBAO=MNÿYPDYM>C>ÿMN@WTÿ]@OHMP\HÿOHCÿ=NVMDBAO=MNÿ=>ÿUC@=CZCQÿOMÿUCÿ\CNCDA@@WÿA??PDAOCXÿCDDMD>ÿBAW C^=>OÿANQÿOHCÿP>CDÿ>HMP@Qÿ=NQCYCNQCNO@Wÿ?MNV=DBÿVMDÿA??PDA?WTÿGHCÿBAYÿQMC>ÿNMOÿ?MN>O=OPOCÿAÿDC\P@AOMDWÿQCOCDB=NAO=MNÿANQÿ=>ÿNMOÿAÿUA>CÿVMDÿCN\=NCCD=N\ÿQC>=\NTÿ]ÿ_C\=>OCDCQÿ̀ANQÿKPDZCWMDÿ>HMP@QÿUCÿ?MN>P@OCQÿOMÿQCOCDB=NCÿYDC?=>Cÿ@M?AO=MNÿUMPNQAD=C>ÿMNÿOHCÿ\DMPNQT !s.^iM '^K^SS :v^i^^?^ '^^w L^;®il ;'' ;'• :r^t';A'^ ^:'^^ i?';",'..^-^ v;l:''.^al .i-;'tl'.^1 AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLiC NOT1C1 ".). STATE OF ILLFNOIS Case Nn. ^^//^: "fl.^'/ /j COOK COUNTY Address ^^ ^.4/-/^^ Reciiicst//^7^^/^-//^^/A',/ 7^ ^77T^^^^ //' Please complcle & rciurn /., / /-) affidavil by __JJ____^_ ,^/^^i The undersigned petitioner, on oath. states: !, Thai they m-c [lie owner or duly authorized ngcnl of the petiLioner k)i- the properly locukd in Skokic. IL, in the above nnt.ed cac)e(s) now pending for pubiic iienring before the Skokie Zoning Board of Appeals or before thu .Skokic Illan Commission, 2. Tliisl they noliHcci, in writiiig, all prnpcrlies \viSliin 250 feet of llie sii!ijec'[ site by mail, using ihc dttachcd list jirnvidcd by staff, no less ihan ] 5 days prsor tu llic scheduled liciu-ing 3. Thai the icgai notice lcilcr w^is mailed OUE on { ___|f(^_J'^_L/__~:- T^KX ^W\C^ Applicant PriiUcd Numc iU^Q- App!ic;uU Signature OFFICIAL SEAL Subscribed 9nd .swpm to heForc me on this MARLENE JOYCE BARGAMIAN Notary Public - State of Ifiinois Commission No. 982126 day of Duv it Monl YcDf Mv Commission Expires December 1, 2027 Notary Pu VOSDUCS^hS66!3 -v! 1 Puhiic Hearing Notsl'ication InslrucLions ZBA &. Plan Commission CHICAGO TRIBUNE media group Sold To: Village of Skokie - CU00031224 51270aktonSt SkokieJL 60077-3633 Bill To: Village ofSkokie - CU00031224 51270aktonSt Skokie,!L 60077-3633 Certificate of Publication: Order Number: 7796236 Purchase Order: Zoning Board State of Illinois - Cook Chicago Tribune Media Group does hereby certify that it is the publisher of the Skokie Review. The Skokie Review is a secular newspaper, has been continuously published Weekly for more than fifty (50) weeks prior to the first publication of the attached notice, is published in the City of Skokie, Township of Niles, State of Illinois, is of general circuiation throughout that county and surrounding area, and is a newspaper as defined by 715 IL CS 5/5. This is to certify that a notice, a true copy of which is attached, was published 1 time(s) in the SkokEe Review, namely one time per week or on 1 successive weeks. The first publication of the notice was made in the newspaper, dated and published on 4/17/2025, and the last publication of the notice was made in the newspaper dated and published on 4/17/2025. This notice was also placed on a statewide public notice website as required by 715 fLCS 5/2. 1. PUBLICATION DATES:Apr 17, 2025. Skokie Review in witness, an authorized agent of The Chicago Tribune Media Group has signed this certificate executed in Chicago, Illinois on this 18th Day of Aprif, 2025, by Chicago Tribune Media Group M B. i!'/] -vi"r. I/ I/ '<i- Jeremy Gates Chicago Tribune - chicagotribune.com 160 N Stetson Avenue, Chicago, IL 60601 (312) 222-2222 - Fax: (312) 222-4014 CHICAGO TRIBUNE media group NOTICE OF PUBUC HEARING skokie zoning Board of Appeals, Wednesday, May 7,2025 village of Skokie,'5l2/ oakton Street, skokie/'iilirib'is' 60677', at "7:3^ P.M. to consider the following: 202$-022-7656 crawford Avenue Daniel a Maria Toma request a variation in order to construct a second-floor addition resultine in the continuation of the exist- ing 7.86-fopt side yard abutting a street rather than the.ic^focfl minimum as required t3y sec- ticm 118-125(6) e. of the skokie zoning ordinance in a R2 single- Famitj? district. PIN: 10-27-231-0486-0000 2025-03Z - 8950 East Prairie Road Katlierine a Samuel Garfinkel, on behalf of Andrew venamore of Heartland Garage BtiJjders/ LLC, requests a variation in. or- d&r to 'construct an attaclied garage resulting in a 5-footfront yard" rather tRan the 25rfoot minimum as required by section ns~l24(5.).oftHe skokie zoning ordinance in a R1 single-Family district. PIN: 10-14-414-001-0000 202504Z-5011 Estes Avenue Admir and Ajla .Rosic request a variation in order to construct a 2nd floor addition resulting in the continuation of the 3.62-fbot side yard rather than the 4-foot miniriunn as required I'jy.sec- tion ns-125 (6:i a. of the 'skokie zoning ordinance in a R2 siiigle- Family district. PIN 10-33-209-042-0000 FOR YOUR INFORMA'nON: pLtns and related documefits. are cf-'ailable at the Planning Di~ yision.office atyillage.Hall Mon- day through Friday from 8:30 Ar.h6"5 fd^PM ."8^-933-S447' SPECIAL. AID: Available .upon request for the disabled, call &47^673-0500 or email jnfoo skokie.org. This notice is for information purposes only. Published in the Skbkie Review on April 10,2025. Brian o'Donnel!, chairman 4/17/2025 7796236 Chicago Tribune - chicagotribune.com 160 N Stetson Avenue, Chicago, IL 60601 (312) 222-2222 - Fax: (3L2) 222-4014 STAFF REPORT 2025-04Z: Variation Community Development Department Council Chambers, 7:30 PM, May 7, 2025 To: Brian O’Donnell, Chairman, Zoning Board of Appeals From: Brian J. Augustine, Zoning Administrator Re: 5011 Estes Ave - Side Yard Variation General Information Location 5011 Estes Ave Request Variation in order to construct a second-floor addition resulting in the continuation of the 3.62-foot side yard. Zoning Requirement 4-foot minimum side yard (118-125(6)a.) Petitioner Admir & Ajla Rosic Existing Zoning & R2 Single-Family – Detached residence Land Use North R2 Single-Family – Detached residence South R2 Single-Family – Detached residence East R2 Single-Family – Detached residence West R2 Single-Family – Detached residence Assigned to Israel Pollack SITE INFORMATION  The building permit for the house did not have a date, staff estimates the home was built in the mid 1950’s.  The first-floor addition in the rear of the property was constructed in 1966. PETITIONER’S SUBMITTAL The petitioner is requesting a variation in order to construct a second-floor addition over the existing first floor, resulting in a 3.62-foot side yard rather than the 4-foot minimum. APPEARANCE COMMISSION The petitioner’s request was approved at the December 11, 2024 Appearance Commission hearing. ZBA Staff Report for 2025-4Z – 5011 Estes Ave – Doc 626293 Proposed Findings of Fact 2025-04Z: Variation Community Development Department Council Chambers, 7:30 PM, May 7, 2025 1 Consideration Limitation on the use of the property due to physical, topographical, and geologic features. Finding The addition was constructed in 1966. It appears the addition was constructed in error and was placed about 4 inches to close to the side lot line. 2 Consideration The applicant can demonstrate that without a variance there can be no reasonable use of the property. Finding The applicant could demonstrate that without a variance there can be a reasonable use of the property. The addition could be built with a 4-foot setback with structural upgrades not typically found in second floor addition. 3 Consideration The granting of the variance is not based solely on economic reasons. Finding The granting of the variance does not appear to be based solely on economic reasons. 4 Consideration The necessity for the variance was not created by the property owner. Finding The necessity for the variance was not created by the property owner as the addition was constructed in 1966. 5 Consideration The variance requested is the minimum variance necessary to allow reasonable use of the property. Finding The request is the minimum to allow for reasonable use of the property. The proposed addition will be constructed over the existing building and continue the same setbacks. 6 Consideration The granting of the variance will not be injurious to the public health, safety, or welfare. Finding The granting of the variance will not be injurious to public health, safety or welfare as the proposed addition will have to be constructed per building code regulations. The continuation of the existing setback should not impact public welfare. 7 Consideration The property subject to the variance request possesses one or more unique characteristics generally not applicable to similarly situated properties Finding The subject property is similar in size to other lots in the area. The addition that was completed in the 1960’s appears to be constructed 4 inches too close to the side lot line. ZBA Staff Report for 2025-4Z – 5011 Estes Ave – Doc 626293 3456ÿ78ÿ%*+9:&++ÿ;/&8 %<=>*?@AÿB+8ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ3C343 ÿ8!ÿ"#$ K oÿÿ]  LDL89 1<@'&ÿÿÿÿÿÿdeefgÿ3f5h6ij6 k*lÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿdeefgÿee6hiCe5 :::8%&'()*+m.)/&08>@n K8ÿO`ÿN Dÿ ÿ ÿPFÿ! ÿ 8!ÿ9ÿ ÿ ÿ`ÿ! ÿ8!ÿK8ÿOPÿL9ÿ– 99ÿ9ÿ]8Gÿ  ÿK—Lÿ˜L"LL89™ÿ˜ L9o %&'()*+ÿ-.)/&0ÿ122% ÿ˜L"LL89ÿL9ÿ ÿH8  ÿšÿ8!ÿ! L89ÿ L89ÿ__™ÿ›8^9LDÿaÿH8 ™ÿV9o ÿ_ÿMÿ8!ÿ ÿ›Lÿ L9LD W LL9™ÿÿD ÿDÿ 8!ÿ 8 ÿoÿEE™ÿPEaÿÿ]8— 9ÿH8ÿ̀OE_O™ÿL9ÿ788ÿ789™ÿœL98L 78——89ÿ–98^9ÿÿOFÿÿM ÿ"™ÿ8L™ÿœL98L  ÿ8!ÿK9ÿ]  L˜ ÿO™EFbÿcÿ ŸSÿÿÿ¡¢£¤¢ÿÿÿ¥¦¤S 89ÿ78ÿEFGÿHÿIÿJ9ÿKL9 ÿMN 9  89ÿ78ÿEFGÿHÿIÿJ9ÿKL9 ÿMN 9  789 ÿ7˜ 789 D89 789 D89 789 V ÿIÿW ÿX QRSTU `Pp_FGPq  ”&>ÿ•ÿÿj585rs ir8eis fC8Crs MÿKL9 ÿ8!ÿK ÿ7L ÿ"9 tuÿwxyzÿt{{|ÿwz}yzÿ~{€ÿu‚ƒ„ÿu tuÿwxyzÿ‡ˆx‰}ÿЉ}‹ÿwz}yzÿ~{€ÿuƒ“„ÿu 789 J9ÿKL9 bF ÿI E  bFG ÿc L 3855sF FOF 558ejs O`O YRZS[\U aF OFE YRZS[\U aE 88D ]L"^ Eÿ8ÿžLÿI 789 ÿ]L"^ — ÿV L 9 V ÿIÿW ÿX ` _`_ V ÿIÿW ÿX J9ÿKL9 789 f83is EOF FaGÿM tuÿwxyzÿt{{|ÿwz}yzÿ~{€ÿuƒ‘„ÿu `` EF 558rCs 88 PO ] ÿI L f83es aaO KL9 ÿž ^ 9ÿK8 F_GÿM  ÿKL9 ÿ8!ÿK8ÿO` 88 5 01E2aÿF4G 6 012ÿ4 PFG `FG OFG MÿKL9 ÿ8!ÿK8ÿOP EbaG 88D 88 FEbGÿM EFF 68ees — ÿ§o E_E — ÿ§o 789 EFEE †tuÿwxyzÿt{{|ÿwz}yzÿ~{€ÿuƒŒ„ÿuÿÿuŒ„ÿu EbbG EO 68j3s OF` 789 ÿD89 K o 9 V ÿIÿW ÿX QRSTU HÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿH8  ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ8 MÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿM ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ  ›¯ ÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿÿÿ›DL ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ7ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ8ÿ9ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ V ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿÿÿV 8 †tuÿwxyzÿt{{|ÿwz}yzÿ~{€ÿu„ÿuÿÿu‘’„ÿu W ÿÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿW  ª8´&')= ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ †tuÿwxyzÿ‡ˆx‰}ÿЉ}‹ÿwz}yzÿ~{€ÿuŒ‚„ÿtuÿÿŽ}ÿЉ}z "ÿÿÿÿÿÿXÿÿÿÿÿÿ"9 FFFFEGGÿÿXXÿÿ°̀q FFFFa_GGÿÿXXÿÿ_°°°̀q ] L—°œ9ÿ789" L89 aq FF`Gÿ X ÿEqq FFO`bGGÿÿXXÿÿ̀qbq ¶@<' E` Eq F F  Eb OG Gÿ X ÿ ÿXÿaq F`_GÿXÿPqFq ÿ X ÿ _ q F  b O G ÿ X ÿ 8!K9L89  µm&' œL"98ÿL88! FFFFOGGÿÿX ÿO °̀qaq F__G FFbGÿXXÿ ÿ_b°°̀q F Fa OEGÿÿXXÿÿOqq FPFEFGGÿÿXXÿÿEqq FG  ÿ8!ÿœL98Lÿÿÿ =>*? B= %< '@= ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ m HJ›Mÿ® 8D ÿ89 ÿ^ ÿHJ›ÿÿD ÿ8— ®žLL9o ÿÿL9 ÿ9ÿ— 9™ÿL!ÿ9™ÿ8^9ÿ 89ÿ ÿ˜LL9oÿL9 ÿ9 789ÿ8!ÿ788ÿÿ @A B+ ÿÿ— 9ÿÿ8^9ÿ89ÿ ÿ 8 ÿ˜L"LL89ÿD®789 ÿÿÿ7 9 ÿ"ÿKK7ÿ8 ÿ ˜ÿ L!ÿÿ9ÿ89ÿ ÿo89ÿ"ÿD ÿ 8ÿ  LDL89ÿ8! «¬­ ÿÿ8ÿ8LLÿ!8ÿ˜LL9oÿL9 ÿ˜L ÿ˜ÿ8ÿÿÿ8L9   ÿ9ÿ8^9ÿ 89ÿ^ÿD !8— ÿ89ÿWÿP™ÿEFEOÿ9ÿÿ ÿ—Dÿ8ÿDÿ 89ÿ^9ÿL ®78—D ÿÿD8L9ÿ˜ !8 ÿ˜LL9oÿ9ÿ D8 ÿ9ÿL!! 9 ÿ8 ÿ D 9L89ÿ8!ÿLÿ"ÿÿÿ 9ÿ˜ L9oÿ ÿ8^9ÿ ÿ˜ L9oÿ˜ÿLÿ—  ÿÿL—— L ÿ®— ÿ98ÿL— 9L89ÿ!8—ÿL9oÿD89ÿLÿD ]L— 9L89ÿ ÿ8^9ÿL9ÿ! ÿ9ÿ9 ÿ9ÿ ÿ8 ÿÿÿ —D  ÿ8!ÿ`pÿ 9 L ®87ÿ!Lÿ^Lÿ98ÿ˜ ÿD8"L ÿ9 ÿLÿ89    ÿÿœ9ÿcÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿOÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ  ¨*(&9ÿ(<=mÿ5r(<ÿ9*0ÿ@©ÿª*)><ÿiCi6 J  ÿžÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ—LÿV8Lÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ±89ÿWÿ² 9L9ÿKÿ³E`ÿND°_F°EFEÿ 8!L89ÿ] Lo9ÿL—ÿK9ÿ"L9oÿKK7ÿÿ³`aFFOab J  ÿH—˜ ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿOFMÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ ›LÿD8!L89ÿ "L ÿ89!8—ÿ8ÿ 9ÿœL98Lÿ—L9L——ÿ9ÿ!8ÿÿ˜89ÿ" 012324ÿ67 7 ) 'ÿ ÿ*"ÿ'&ÿ&ÿ&   & + +    ÿ ÿ ÿ'& /:####! ./*#0##!  ÿ(' &ÿ  ÿ ÿÿ ÿ*.!ÿÿ"ÿ#$ *2!"1$  ÿ(' ÿ ÿÿ ÿÿ!"#$ 1!"2$ÿ3ÿ44$"44$  ÿ(' *ÿÿ& ÿÿ- ÿ-  ÿ ÿÿ ÿ*!"ÿ,$ 2!"44$  ÿ(' %'ÿÿ& ÿ +  *ÿÿ& ÿÿ- %'ÿÿ& ÿ +  %ÿ&'ÿ('( %ÿ*2!"ÿ#$ÿ/ÿ-ÿ*1!"#$ %ÿ*1!"ÿ:$ÿ/ÿ-ÿ*4!".$  ÿ(' *##!  1/4*ÿÿÿ7#2ÿ8ÿ& ÿ ÿ9 */*42ÿ *2!"1$ *.!"#$ %ÿ&'ÿ - ' #5ÿ&  *045ÿ&  ÿ ÿ(' &ÿÿ%'ÿ ÿ ÿ &ÿÿ%'ÿ ÿ ÿ 'ÿ ÿ  'ÿ ÿ  012324ÿ6786987 312 nh p|yooyk       mnj ghijk pym ' ' ljmnhoojkp & =ÿ & =ÿ -&&'ÿ  -&&'ÿ  qqrsqtuvwx hln ÿ&  ÿ&  oylhk mhg jzl{yn ;ÿ %'ÿ(  ÿ %' >?@ABÿ>D@GAHED FBD *ÿ  @N?NADOÿAPÿQHHRR  ;ÿ %'ÿ ÿ !"#$ !"#$ *1!":ÿ4<$ ÿ ÿ - ÿÿ&ÿ"ÿ ÿ %ÿ*2!"#$ 1!"2$ %'ÿ( ÿ 44!"44ÿ1<:$ *4!".ÿ1<:$ %'ÿ ÿ ( ÿ - ÿÿ&ÿ"ÿ   ÿ%ÿ*1$ 4*1,:! 4*1,:! IIÿD@JD@ÿKLDFMD ;ÿÿ"  ÿ& ÿ  ÿ%'ÿ ) 'ÿ' ÿ"('(ÿ3ÿ&ÿ & ÿ +  ;ÿ ÿ  -ÿ%'ÿ4  ÿ+ %'  - 2!"44ÿ4<*$ &ÿÿ%'ÿ ÿ ÿ *!",ÿ.<:$ %' ' ' &ÿÿ%'ÿ ÿ ÿ >DLA@A?F@ ƒ€„€HG }?>ÿ~D>AJ IH€IG€H‚ *##! Aÿ@ÿ@ÿMÿDEÿKÿJÿD ‡ÿEAKˆ>K@ ˆIHH B?EDÿKJ>A†  4 ÿ+&ÿÿÿÿ # *! :! 4*! *! &ÿ4<:$ÿ‰ÿ4!"#$ &ÿ4<:$ÿ‰ÿ4!"#$ STSUÿWXYZ[ÿ\Z]^X__Z[`ÿWX]ab[ÿcd`ef ÿ0ÿ2ÿ7ÿ6ÿÿÿÿÿÿ8ÿ9ÿÿ4ÿ7ÿÿÿ4 834" ÿÿ0ÿ'ÿÿ3ÿÿÿ-ÿÿÿ(ÿ4ÿ2ÿ3ÿ0ÿÿÿ3ÿ0ÿ6ÿ2ÿÿÿ8ÿ9ÿÿ4ÿ7ÿÿÿ4 3' 34 2 93 545 845048 3450 ' 88ÿ34 344547 804 4345065ÿ0208 02345065ÿ0208 5754 '50 48 8954428 5458 9674ÿ54& 0544238 2ÿ93  566ÿ 566ÿ24 665ÿ54 23 5ÿ0' 3ÿ-ÿ(423 49 ÿ(423 23 5ÿ0' 3ÿ-ÿ(423 49 209ÿ(42303062 26348 0583ÿ665ÿ-ÿ849627ÿ665ÿ263ÿ02ÿ8964ÿ6ÿ65ÿÿ ÿ408302'ÿ36ÿ5402 +8&ÿ3, ' 88ÿ54 (423ÿ54 9 ' 88ÿ54 (423ÿ54 9 2ÿ3' +8&ÿ3,ÿR +8&ÿ3,ÿ#R +8&ÿ3, +8&ÿ3,  9 37 37  ÿ97 945 48 4083(0 3702347ÿ ÿ" 5047 37 2624 48 344547ÿ' 88 ) 47566ÿ ! *# #* #$*! *)   37 37  ÿ97 945 !ÿÿ#$ÿ 3702347ÿ ÿ" 5047 37 2624 48  505ÿ47566 $) $  #$*! *) 505ÿ47566ÿ642ÿ36ÿ80702'ÿ7665ÿSÿ345594"655647ÿ0' 3ÿ-ÿ(423 !  37 37  ÿ97 945 ÿÿ#$ÿ 3702347ÿ ÿ" 5047 37 2624 48 * 505ÿ3 #$ 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 6454ÿ0276Qÿ26ÿ54& 054423ÿ 3ÿ49 ÿ4  83ÿ2ÿ36ÿ4ÿ56(0747  505ÿ96843 )* 25 25 25 25 25 25 25 #  37 37  ÿ97 945 48 ÿÿ#$ÿ 3702347ÿ ÿ" 5047 37 2624 48 344547ÿ' 88 $  37 37  ÿ97 945 48 $ÿÿ ÿ 3702347ÿ ÿ" 5047 37 2624 48 344547ÿ' 88 2634%ÿ62ÿ5668ÿ3 3ÿ54ÿ02ÿ3 4ÿ8964ÿ6ÿ65ÿ54ÿ029 747ÿ02ÿ3 08ÿ89 47 4ÿÿ ÿ63 45ÿ548ÿ54ÿ408302'ÿ36ÿ5402  ÿ' 02'ÿ36ÿ96ÿ03 ÿ9 55423ÿ059ÿ4245'ÿ9674 39 ÿ408302'ÿ5604Qÿ96 65Qÿ'50 4Qÿ' 02'ÿ-ÿ0208 ÿ6ÿ408302' 39 ÿ40830'ÿ80 ÿ-ÿ47ÿ40' 38ÿ26 (450ÿ"ÿ6245ÿ5065ÿ36ÿ6574502' D 4ÿÿ3ÿ4ÿ5ÿ0ÿ6ÿ5ÿÿ7ÿ6ÿ6ÿ5ÿ8ÿÿ-ÿÿÿ0ÿ2ÿ7ÿ6ÿÿÿ3ÿÿÿ4ÿ8 894%ÿ263ÿ36ÿ894 8ÿ89 47 47 844 89 47 4 844 89 47 4 844ÿ89 47 4 844ÿ89 47 4 8ÿ89 47 47 3 3  9 76 4ÿ 2' 76 4ÿ 2'  ÿ0276 ÿ0276 4345065ÿ80702'ÿ7665ÿ8834 ÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿÿ65ÿ37ÿ0208 962359365ÿ36ÿ(450ÿ802'"80702'ÿ705493062ÿ"ÿ6245ÿ5065ÿ36ÿ6574502' 7ÿÿ89ÿ6ÿ 6ÿ5ÿÿÿ3ÿÿÿ4ÿ8 4%ÿ263ÿ36ÿ894 ÿÿÿ89ÿ54%ÿÿ263ÿÿ 4ÿÿÿ3ÿÿÿ4ÿ8 ÿ36ÿ894 ƒ„€ ’ „~ †   }~€ †ƒ ‚€ƒ„~ €† 8ÿ89 47 47 ‡‡ˆ‰‡Š‹ŒŽ ~‚„ 8ÿ89 7 ‚~ ƒ~} €‚‘„ 8ÿ89 47 47 8ÿÿ89 47 47 TUVWXÿTZV]W^[Z \XZ   VdUdWZeÿWfÿg^^hh 802' 4ÿ!"#ÿ86 07ÿ667 962359365ÿ36ÿ(450ÿ802'"80702'ÿ705493062ÿ"ÿ6245ÿ5065ÿ36ÿ6574502' 667ÿ54ÿ"ÿ0234'5" +,ÿ24ÿ7665ÿ65ÿ37ÿ0208 54347ÿ836 7665ÿ2634% ÿ39 ÿ ÿ56048ÿ36ÿ408302'ÿ76658 ÿ24ÿ7665ÿ984ÿ56048ÿ-ÿ350ÿ36ÿ39 ÿ408302' 0ÿ2ÿ3ÿ4ÿ5ÿ0ÿ6ÿ5ÿÿÿ7ÿ6ÿ6ÿ5ÿÿÿ8ÿ9ÿÿ4ÿ7ÿÿÿ4ÿÿ8ÿ9ÿ6ÿÿ4ÿÿ6ÿÿÿÿ6ÿ5ÿÿÿ6ÿ2ÿÿ __ÿZV`ZVÿabZ\cZ 7665 54 7665ÿ 566ÿ 566ÿ24 34 3 804 3 09 0208 34 3 743 0208 5754ÿ843 5458 84423ÿÿÿ26ÿ65 0583ÿ665ÿÿÿ26ÿ65 849627ÿ665ÿÿ62ÿ76658ÿ03 02ÿ8964ÿ6ÿ65ÿ54ÿ08347ÿ46   505  7 ÿÿÿ ÿ!"# 3  7 $ 3  96843 7665ÿ26348% ÿÿ7ÿ.ÿ667 ÿÿ3ÿ.ÿ023 7665ÿ26348% /  ÿ76658ÿ27ÿ7665ÿ9802'ÿ3 3ÿ08ÿ408302'ÿ36 D ÿÿ' ÿ.ÿ' 88 ÿ4083ÿ.ÿ408302'ÿ36ÿ5402 5402ÿ54ÿ36ÿ02347ÿ36ÿ39 ÿ24ÿ76658 ÿ7ÿ6ÿ6ÿ5ÿÿÿÿÿ5ÿ7ÿÿÿ5ÿ4ÿÿÿ8ÿ9ÿÿ4ÿ7ÿÿÿ4 843ÿ2 45 5754ÿ 293062 7489503062 2 93 545 674ÿ2 45 0208 & 2303 5458  ÿ88'4ÿ39 ÿ843 702 37 37   88'4ÿ843  33ÿ02'48ÿÿ#ÿ8& 54 '45 37 37 ÿ"ÿ058  ÿ50(9ÿ39 ÿ843 702 37 37   50(9ÿ843  33ÿ02'48ÿÿ#ÿ8& 54 '45 )* 37 ÿ"ÿ058  4235294ÿ69ÿ843  ÿ4235294ÿ69ÿ843 37 37 37   ÿ7665ÿ836 702 #$ 37  309 309 56(074ÿ403 45ÿ+,ÿ ÿ836ÿ65ÿ+,ÿ665ÿ836ÿ65ÿ4(45ÿ802'ÿ7665 665ÿ7665ÿ836 702 #$$ÿ65ÿ 37  D TZbWVWU\V ™–—š–—^—] 70458ÿ27ÿ8039 48% “UTÿ”ZT•Ẁ _^–_]–—^—˜ ÿ70458ÿ27ÿ8039 48ÿ36ÿ4ÿ 3562ÿ70( ÿ6 3438ÿ36ÿ4ÿ 3562ÿ7480'245ÿ834 ÿ 034ÿ0208 ÿ62ÿ'ÿ0208 ÿ62ÿ0 65ÿ27ÿ304ÿ37ÿÿ(450ÿ03 ÿ6245ÿ27ÿ59 03493ÿ5065ÿ36ÿ6574502' ÿ8954 488ÿ94ÿ34 WÿVÿVÿcÿZ[ÿaÿ̀ÿZ ÿÿ0ÿ'ÿÿ3ÿÿÿÿ0ÿÿ3ÿÿ5ÿ4ÿÿÿ8ÿ9ÿÿ4ÿ7ÿÿÿ4 a^^™ 012341563787 98:57;<6;=2 4D E32= 7858::89ÿ512ÿFÿGHÿ7=329 >=3:;2?ÿAÿ0=98B 67;0 ;5IDB89?GFJCFD DKLFL> B10<: B89 0=326;2? 7858::89 78017C: =7ÿ8M31B VX›Z[cfZVÿ 4N =L287ÿ<7=O;989Pÿ5=267156=7ÿ;2:61BB89ÿ4;N6378 58;B;2?ÿAÿL1BB ijikÿmnopqÿrpstnuupqvÿmnswxqÿyzv{| 0ÿ1ÿ2ÿ3ÿÿÿÿÿ3ÿÿÿÿÿ1ÿÿ1ÿ6ÿ9ÿÿÿÿÿ3ÿÿ1ÿÿ( 0ÿ1ÿ2ÿ3ÿÿÿÿÿ3ÿÿÿÿÿ1ÿÿ1ÿÿ0ÿ( 31 ÿ3ÿ0123 3ÿ9ÿ961ÿ3ÿ1010ÿ3ÿ091ÿ1ÿ8 ÿ11ÿ38ÿ0123 3ÿ9 36936 ÿ2 ÿ1321ÿ89296ÿÿ1ÿ11ÿ38ÿ1ÿ36ÿ0910ÿÿ1 1 1ÿ3 63ÿ3ÿ6129 069 ÿ7ÿ1ÿ1ÿ3ÿ1321ÿ89296ÿÿ1ÿ303 ÿ90ÿ01ÿÿ16 0ÿ9 ÿ0123 3ÿ5ÿ612301ÿ 1 96 ÿ3ÿ9171ÿ1ÿ1ÿ36ÿ0910 9 ÿ12 ÿ3ÿ6129ÿ36ÿ3ÿ1ÿ61 10ÿ961ÿ3ÿ1ÿ63110ÿ06ÿ0123 3ÿ90 1ÿ3 63ÿ3ÿ1ÿ6123710 633ÿ1ÿ3 63ÿ631 ÿ09291ÿ3ÿ1ÿ12 ÿ3ÿ1ÿ61 10ÿ36ÿ3 6129ÿ961ÿ3ÿ1ÿ619610ÿ61810ÿ36ÿ619103ÿ1ÿ9893ÿ38ÿ1ÿ316ÿ 1ÿ1169ÿ36936ÿ9ÿ3ÿ90039ÿ3 ÿ3ÿ1ÿ316ÿ36ÿ961 9 ÿ0123ÿ29169 ÿ961ÿ1010ÿ3ÿ1ÿ6123710ÿ388ÿ1ÿ1 ÿ310ÿ3161ÿ11ÿ9 1ÿ1636ÿ330ÿ0336 ÿ90ÿ960961ÿ90ÿ9 ÿ316ÿ1121ÿ9 ÿ310ÿÿ1 069ÿ1ÿ11ÿ101 ÿ836ÿ 63 ÿ3ÿ97910ÿ29169ÿ9ÿÿ3ÿ1ÿ61 10 ! 9791ÿ9 ÿ3"61 10ÿ29169ÿ16ÿ316#ÿ0613 $1ÿ1169ÿ36936ÿÿ61 3  1ÿ836ÿ6370ÿ9 ÿ123696 ÿ90ÿ16291 36ÿ9 ÿ11 96 ÿ3ÿ299ÿ16ÿ38ÿ1ÿ661 ÿ90ÿ 12  %9ÿ90ÿ6196ÿ9 ÿ1ÿ9 ÿ90ÿ8336ÿ6891 ÿ9 ÿ11 96 ÿ01ÿ3ÿ612379ÿ36 61393ÿ38ÿ1ÿ12 ÿ1ÿ36ÿÿ3ÿ1ÿ16910ÿ3ÿ1ÿ29169 ÿÿ9 192 1 ÿ2916ÿ3ÿ9 ÿ093ÿ38ÿ69 3 ÿ111ÿ1ÿ1ÿ90ÿ1 &1ÿ1169ÿ36936ÿÿ61 3  1ÿ836ÿ6370ÿ9 ÿ031ÿ"388ÿ90 9 ÿ3ÿ1ÿ2199ÿ1169ÿ90ÿ2 ÿ 12 ÿÿ9619 ÿ161ÿ0123 3 ÿ3ÿ36ÿ1ÿ1169ÿ36936ÿÿ61 3  1ÿ836ÿ33609ÿ0123 3ÿ90 3 63ÿ38ÿ9 ÿ 12 ÿÿ1ÿ316ÿ90ÿ1  '61816ÿ3ÿ90039ÿ0123 3ÿ31 ÿ3ÿ669ÿ2199ÿ1169ÿ90 2 ÿÿ069  i Z[W [U ] f\\fX TUVWX ]fZ YWZ[U\\WX] X ^^_`^abcde UY[ \fYU ZUT WgYhf[ 61-27ÿ6/-925./ ,7/ -<1<2/=ÿ2*ÿ>55?? 0123ÿ5ÿ612371ÿ1ÿ6338 3 ÿ9 ÿ61610ÿ836ÿ1 44ÿ/-3/-ÿ+:/,;/ 6338ÿ16ÿ1ÿ6338ÿ9 0123ÿ5ÿ612371ÿ1  10ÿ21 0123ÿ5ÿ612371ÿ1 16 ÿ5ÿ03 3 0123ÿ5ÿ612371ÿ6338 9ÿ86 ÿ8336ÿ6338 9 12 ÿ661ÿ 9010ÿ9619ÿÿ1ÿ1 5ÿ1ÿ3ÿ3ÿ6129 0123ÿ5ÿ612371ÿ6338 9 12 ÿ661ÿ 9010ÿ9619ÿÿ1ÿ1 5ÿ1ÿ3ÿ3ÿ6129 0123ÿ5ÿ612371ÿ9 11636ÿ0ÿ3 6173 ÿ9003ÿ61 836ÿ1ÿ3 900 0123ÿ5ÿ612371ÿ9 11636ÿ0ÿ3 6173 ÿ9003ÿ61 836ÿ1ÿ3 900 p 6/:2-21,- nklokl5l9 j16ÿ)/6023 45k49kl5lm 0123ÿ5ÿ612371ÿ6338ÿ9 12 ÿ661 2ÿ-ÿ-ÿ;ÿ/.ÿ+ÿ3ÿ/ ÿ9010ÿ9619ÿÿ1ÿ1ÿ5ÿ1 3ÿ3ÿ6129ÿ61ÿ836ÿ1ÿ130 ./01*2321, 8336 .455 )*+,- q r sttuÿ Dvwtxyzyt{ÿ|x}{ÿÿ ‰ # !# %# # ~I}xvr€‚ÿƒÿr„A‚ 91(ÿ†!‡ÿˆÿ#"‰‡ @A@BÿDEFGHÿIGJKELLGHMÿDEJNOHÿPQMRS CDEF6F6G7ÿ7GFIH &ÿÿ4ÿ4ÿÿÿ7ÿÿÿ1ÿÿÿ4ÿ1ÿÿ1ÿÿ0 B CDEF6F6G7HÿDEIÿ67J6KDFIJÿG7ÿLMGGEÿCMD7HÿNOÿPEDCQ6KÿJIH6P7DF6G7ÿD7J1GEÿNO B L6EIÿD7J1GEÿH5GWIÿEIH6HFD7FÿEDF67PHÿDEIÿFGÿKG7F67RIÿÿÿDNGVIÿDMMÿGCI767PHÿ67 B CEGV6JIÿTDFIEÿEIH6HFD7FÿPOCHR5ÿNGDEJÿDFÿDMMÿTDMMHÿ67ÿÿÿNDFQEGG5HÿD7J 7GFIu 1%67ÿ&44 CDEF6F6G7ÿFOCIÿHO5NGMÿ*ÿEILIEÿFGÿCDEF6F6G7ÿMIPI7J8 EDFIJÿCDEF6F6G7H8 MDR7JEOÿEGG5HÿFQDFÿT6MMÿ7GFEIKI6VIÿF6MIÿL676HQÿDHÿTIMMÿDHÿDMMÿGFQIEÿ7G7*F6MIJ TGGJÿLED567PÿDNGVI DMMÿFOC8ÿCDEF6F6G7Hÿ67 TDMMHÿFQDFÿKG7FD67ÿCMR5N67PÿL6SFREIH8 NDH5I7FÿFGÿRHIÿ012- 1&ÿ&44 B M67IÿGLÿHFERKFREIÿ67J6KDFIJÿLGEÿIDKQÿCDEF6F6G7ÿ6HÿJ6DPED55DF6KÿG7MOÿD7JÿJGIH B NGSIHÿMGKDFIJÿ67ÿDKGRHF6KÿCDEF6F6G7HÿHQDMMÿNIÿFEIDFIJÿT6FQÿDKGRHF6KDM 012-ÿFOCIÿ)S)ÿPOCHR5ÿNGDEJ QIDJ FOCIÿ-S-ÿRHPÿHQIIFEGKW 7GFÿ67J6KDFIÿISDKFÿÿÿKG7HFERKF6G7ÿKG7J6F6G7HÿGEÿPIG5IFEOÿ*ÿEILIEÿFG HIDMD7FÿDEGR7JÿÿÿCIE65IFIEÿD7JÿNIQ67JÿIDKQÿNGSÿvLRMMÿKMGHREIÿNIJw8ÿ67 B CEGV6JIÿCDCIEMIHHÿ5G6HFREIÿEIH6HFD7FÿPOCHR5ÿCD7IMHÿ67ÿDMMÿNDHI5I7FÿMIVIM KI6M67P NED7JÿPMDHH*5DF HFERKFREDMÿJEDT67PHÿLGEÿLREFQIEÿ67LGE5DF6G78 DJJ6F6G7UÿGRFMIFÿD7JÿxR7KF6G7ÿNGSIHÿHQDMMÿNIÿHICDEDFIJÿNOÿ67HFDMM67PÿDÿ5IFDM L676HQIJÿHCDKIH8 CD7IMH8ÿÿF6MIÿTDMMHÿFG HFRJÿNIFTII7ÿFQI5ÿ67ÿFQIÿCDEF6F6G78 012-ÿPOCHR5ÿNGDEJÿFG RHIÿ012-ÿKI5I7F6F6GRH B KRFÿCDEF6F6G7ÿHFRJHÿHQGEFÿGLÿFGCÿGLÿ5IFDMÿKI6M7PÿER77IEÿD7JÿJGÿ7GFÿLDHFI7 B RHIÿPDMVD76YIJÿ5IFDMÿKGE7IEÿNIDJHÿD7JÿIJPIÿFE65HÿvGEÿHKEIIJHÿDHÿEIXR6EIJwÿ67 HFERKFREIÿ[ÿDÿ\ÿN NDKWIEÿCD7IMH8 CDEF6F6G7ÿHFRJHÿD7JÿPOCHR5ÿNGDEJÿFGÿ5IFDMÿKI6M67PÿER77IEUÿFGÿDMMGTÿLGE B KG5CMIFIMOÿHIDMÿT6FQÿKG7F67RGRHÿDKGRHF6KDMÿHIDMD7FÿDMMÿÿÿCDEF6F6G7ÿQIDJHU DMMÿISCGHIJÿTGEWUÿCGH6F6VIMOÿDFFDKQIJÿT6FQÿLDHFI7IEH8 CMD7 HFERKFREDMÿJILMIKF6G78 NDHIHUÿD7JÿI7JHUÿCMRHÿHIDMÿDMMÿÿÿCI7IFEDF6G7HUÿ67KMRJ67PÿNRFÿ7GFÿM656FIJÿFG 4ÿSÿTGGJÿHFRJ 5IKQD76KDMUÿÿÿIMIKFE6KDMUÿD7JÿCMR5N67PÿTGEW8 B FDCIÿD7JÿDCCMOÿxG67FÿKG5CGR7JÿFGÿDMMÿ67FIE6GEÿKGE7IEHÿD7Jÿ5GVI5I7F 012-ÿFOCIÿ)S)ÿPOCHR5ÿNGDEJÿID8ÿH6JI B CEGV6JIÿNEDK67PÿTQIEIÿCDEF6F6G7ÿQI6PQFÿISKIIJHÿ5D7RLDKFREIE)HÿDMMGTDNMI KG7FEGMÿxG67FHÿ67ÿPOCHR5ÿNGDEJÿCDEF6F6G7HÿR878G8 QI6PQF8ÿJGÿ7GFÿNEDKIÿFGÿÿÿJRKFTGEWÿGEÿGFQIEÿHRKQÿKG5CG7I7FH8ÿVIE6LO B CEGV6JIÿR7LDKIJÿ567IEDMÿTGGMÿ67HRMDF6G7ÿLGEÿDMMÿHGR7JÿDFFI7RDF6G7ÿNMD7WIFH8 HGR7JÿDFFI7RDF6G7 DMMGTDNMIÿÿÿQI6PQFÿCHLÿEIXR6EI5I7FHÿT6FQÿMGKDMÿKGJIÿDRFQGE6F6IH8 ISFI7JÿNMD7WIFHÿLRMMÿQI6PQFÿGLÿCDEF6F6G7ÿRCÿFGÿNGFFG5ÿGLÿHFERKFREIU B CEGV6JIÿVIEF6KDMÿKG7FEGMÿxG67FHÿLGEÿD7OÿR767FIEERCFIJÿCDEF6F6G7ÿMI7PFQÿDF NMD7WIFÿ[ÿDÿ\ÿN 67HFDMMIJÿ67ÿF6PQFUÿKG5CEIHH6G7ÿL6FÿFGÿHFRJHUÿHFERKFREIÿD7JÿDJxDKI7F 3,)*,-ÿG8K8ÿ67ÿFQIÿQGE6YG7FDMÿJ6EIKF6G7ÿTQIEIÿ67J6KDFIJÿGEÿDHÿEIXR6EIJ8ÿVIE6LO 312-ÿKG7FÿHIDMD7FÿIDÿH6JI NDHI B TDMMÿDHHI5NM6IHÿD7JÿCDEF6F6G7HÿFQDFÿEIKI6VIÿL6EIÿEIH6HF6VIÿEDF67PHÿHQDMMNI HRELDKIH8 MGKDF6G7HÿT6FQÿDEKQ6FIKFÿNILGEIÿ67HFDMMDF6G78 KG7HFERKFIJÿCIEÿFIHFIJÿDHHI5NM6IHUÿ5D7RLDKFREIE)HÿEIKG55I7JDF6G7HÿD7J HRNLMGGEÿNIMGT FQIÿEIXR6EI5I7FHÿGLÿDMMDCCM6KDNMIÿKGJIHÿD7JÿMGKDMÿPGVIE767PÿDRFQGE6F6IH8 B L67DMÿMGKDF6G7ÿD7JÿCMDKI5I7FÿGLÿ5ICLCÿ6FI5HÿvNGFQÿÿÿQGE6YG7FDMÿD7JÿVIEF6KDMw B DMMÿ67FIE6GEÿL676HQIHÿDEIÿFGÿNIÿ7GÿMIHHÿFQD7ÿKMDHHÿ+ÿLGEÿEIH6JI7F6DMÿD7J HQDMMÿNIÿKGGEJ67DFIJÿHRKQÿFQDFÿFQIOÿJGÿ7GFFGRKQÿHFRJÿCDEF6F6G7ÿDHHI5NM6IH DHHI5NMOÿRHIÿD7JÿKMDHHÿ4ÿLGEÿNRH67IHHÿRHIUCIEÿKNKÿ.ÿv+2*2*(4,w8 B DMFIEDF6G7HÿFGÿIS6HF67PÿEDFIJÿDHHI5NM6IHÿDEIÿFGÿNIÿJG7Iÿ67ÿDKKGEJD7KIÿT6FQ D7JÿKEIDFIÿD7ÿDKGRHF6KDMÿCEGNMI5ÿHRKQÿDHÿV6NEDF6G7Uÿ65CDKFÿ7G6HIUÿIFK8 JFJ8HFRJÿH6YI HFRJ L6EIÿEDF67Pÿ1 67HRM8 TDMM HFK 5D67FD6767PÿEDF67PH8ÿÿKG7FEDKFGEÿEIHCG7H6NMIÿLGEÿDMMÿ5DFIE6DMHÿD7J B FOC6KDMÿJIFD6MHÿDEIÿNDHIJÿG7ÿ0ÿCHLÿR76LGE5ÿMGDJ67PÿD7JÿJILMIKF6G7ÿGLÿM14(, 7G8 HCDK67P FIHFÿ7G8 FQ6KW8 FQ6KW8 EDF67P 67HFDMMDF6G7ÿEIXR6EIJÿFGÿ5D67FD67ÿEDF67P8 B CEGV6JIÿL6EIÿEIFDEJD7FÿTGGJÿNMGKW67Pÿ67ÿ5IFDMÿHFRJÿCDEF6F6G7HÿDHÿEIXR6EIJ R7MIHHÿ7GFIJÿGFQIET6HIUÿT6FQÿPDPIÿVDE6IHÿDHÿ67J6KDFIJ8ÿCQOH6KDMÿD7J D 4ÿSÿ( +Z-ÿG8K8 * 3- (*31(- LGEÿHRCCGEFÿD7J1GEÿ67HFDMMDF6G7ÿGLÿJGGEÿLED5IHUÿ5GRMJ67PHUÿ56MMTGEWUÿTDMM HFERKFREDMÿCEGCIEF6IHÿ5DOÿVDEOÿNOÿEIP6G7ÿD7Jÿ5D7RLDKFREIE8ÿÿEIXRIHFÿDKFRDM N 4ÿSÿZ +Z-ÿG8K8 * 0- Z*31(- B CEGV6JIÿL6EIHFGCC67PÿDFÿCI7IFEDF6G7HÿFQEGRPQÿL6EIÿEIH6HFD7KIÿEDFIJ CD7IMHUÿQD7JED6MHUÿPEDNÿNDEHUÿT67JGTÿFEIDF5I7FHUÿFIMIV6H6G7HÿD7JÿDMMÿGFQIE CQOH6KDMÿD7JÿHFERKFREDMÿCEGCIEFOÿJDFDÿLEG5ÿLED567Pÿ5D7RLDKFREIE8 K 4ÿSÿ( +Z-ÿG8K8 * 7G7I (*31(- CDEF6F6G7HUÿNIDE67PÿTDMMHUÿLMGGEÿD7JÿKI6M67PÿD7JÿEGGLÿD7JÿKI6M67PÿDHHI5NM6IH8 TDMMÿ5GR7FIJÿ6FI5H8 J 4ÿSÿZ +Z-ÿG8K8 * 7G7I Z*31(- CI7IFEDF6G7HÿGEÿCEGJRKFHÿLGEÿRHIÿ67ÿFQIÿHCIK6L6KÿL6EIÿEDFIJÿCDEF6F6G7 B CEGV6JIÿ5IFDMÿx*NIDJÿG7ÿKI6M67PÿNGDEJÿDFÿTDMM1KI6M67PÿxG67Fÿ67ÿDMMÿEGG5H K 4ÿSÿ(ÿLREEIJ +Z-ÿG8K8 * 3- (*+12- DHHI5NM6IHÿHQDMMÿNIÿNDHIJÿG7ÿHRKKIHHLRMÿCIELGE5D7KIÿ67ÿL6EIÿFIHFH8ÿFQIHI B DMMÿTGGJÿNMGKW67PÿRHIJÿ67ÿCDEF6F6G7HÿHQDMMÿNIÿL6EIÿÿÿEIFDEJD7FÿFEIDFIJ8 T6FQGRFÿKEGT7UÿFOC8 J 4ÿSÿZÿLREEIJ +Z-ÿG8K8 * 0- Z*+12- CI7IFEDF6G7Hÿ5DOÿ67KMRJIÿNRFÿDEIÿ7GFÿM656FIJÿFGÿ6FI5HÿHRKQÿDHÿC6C67PUÿKG7JR6FU GEÿQVDKÿJRKFTGEW8 B CEGV6JIÿKI5I7F6F6GRHÿF6MIÿNDKWIEÿNGDEJÿ67ÿM6IRÿGLÿPOCHR5ÿNGDEJÿDFÿTDMMHÿ67 ] ^_`a bcdÿfcdcgbhiÿij_kcddÿ̀cj^a^algÿÿÿÿ EGG5HÿFQDFÿT6MMÿEIKI6VIÿF6MIÿL676HQ8 B TDMMNGDEJÿLDHFI7IEHÿDEIÿFGÿNIÿ+ÿ678ÿMG7PUÿHIML*JE6MM67PUÿHIML*FDCC67PÿHFIIM B IDKQÿCDEF6F6G7ÿHQGT7ÿG7ÿFQIÿJEDT67PHÿFGÿNIÿDÿL6EIÿD7J1GEÿH5GWIÿEIH6HFD7F HKEITHÿT6FQÿNRPMIÿQIDJHÿLDHFI7IJÿ[ÿ2-ÿG8K8ÿDFÿNRFFÿxG67FHÿD7Jÿ+4-ÿG8K8ÿ67ÿFQI CDEF6F6G7UÿHQDMMNIÿ6JI7F6L6IJÿDHÿHRKQÿT6FQÿDÿMDNIMÿDNGVIÿFQIÿKI6M67PÿG7ÿIDKQ L6IMJÿGLÿFQIÿNGDEJ8ÿÿxG67FHÿKGVIEIJÿT1CEI56SIJÿxG67FÿKG5CGR7JÿI5NIJJIJÿ67 CDCIEÿFDCIÿvCIEÿRMÿPR6JIM67IHw mbcdhnÿopÿqÿorstp HIP5I7FÿGLÿFQIÿTDMMUÿ2)*,-ÿG8K8 571 47ÿ:ÿ17ÿ57ÿ1;9 10ÿÿ7 55ÿ:ÿ245617 97ÿ 5010 1 166ÿ57ÿ1;9 10ÿÿ7 55ÿ:ÿ245617ÿ97 9 9 9 5010 8 8 8 71 1 10ÿ466ÿ1;9 10 5010<ÿ11 ÿ75 &05&ÿ6210941 1% 1% §¡ ©µ²̈¨²¤ 1% 1% 1% ¦§£ ¡¢£¤ ©²¦ ¥£¦§¡¨¨£¤© 1% ªª«¬ª­®¯°± ¡¥§ 245617 ¨²¥¡¤ 10 55ÿ9 88 1% ¦¡ £³¥´²§ 8 7 5ÿ&5 3 1% 89 17  1%67'ÿ8%9ÿ?ÿ9$ÿ5'2' 5ÿ&5 3 4ÿ55 |{„ÿ|†ˆ„ƒ‡† €† Œ{Œ„†ÿ„zÿŽƒƒ 1% 12 175ÿ55 1% 44 245617 8 5ÿ&5 3 5ÿ&5 3 41 245617 245617 8# 8 1% 57ÿ450@ÿ6540ÿ4523ÿ 5 1%67ÿ67114ÿ1 57ÿ450@ 55ÿ75ÿ1ÿ145& 1% 1%67 6540ÿ4523 1 166  5ÿ55 5ÿ&5 3 5&01 ÿ55 &05&ÿ8$ 75ÿ1 &01ÿÿ 1% 145& 245617 8$ ‚‚ÿ†‰†ÿІ€‹† &05& 1% 245617 5 1 5ÿ&5 3 =8> 57ÿ450 1% 51 5ÿ&5 3 1%67'ÿ8%9ÿ?ÿ9$ÿ5'2' 1%67'ÿ8%9ÿ?ÿ9$ÿ5'2' 1% =8> 98ÿ44ÿ1 + 5ÿ&5 3 675 1 75ÿ69 5 7 57ÿ450  ÿ10 55 10 55ÿ8 0ÿ55 3721  5ÿ01 8! 8" 1ÿ?ÿ55 8  8 5ÿ&5 3  8 =8> 57ÿ450  8 57ÿ450@ÿ6540ÿ4523ÿ 5 8 8 8 8 51 8 ()*+,- ()*.ÿ012- 3)*3- !ÿ 56710 55ÿ75ÿ1ÿ145& 1% 57ÿ450@ÿ65404523ÿ 5 466ÿ055 1%67 (-ÿ5678 55ÿ75ÿ1ÿ145& 2 17 1&ÿ1 0ÿ1 1 55ÿ9ÿÿÿ645 1 55ÿ&ÿ$ÿÿ491 7   &ÿ1&ÿ&550ÿ25 5671 3)*(ÿ31(- 1& 741 4)*.ÿ+14- 8# 0123ÿÿ5ÿ6411 1 6 51 .)*,ÿ+1(- 0123 $ÿ9 0 4ÿ&ÿ5  1367ÿ55 2 &4ÿ6 21 5 1ÿ 171 ÿ7ÿÿ89 7 5ÿ&5 3  1&ÿ640ÿ055 ÿ& 216'ÿ67110ÿ75 0)*,- 2549ÿ0ÿ1%71 5 245617 5ÿ&5 3 4)*2- 4)*4- 755  71 1 10ÿ466ÿÿ&ÿ67114 4714<ÿ11 ÿ75ÿ  &44 1%67'ÿ  8 8 5716ÿ5ÿ99ÿ5 ÿ6A $%$ÿ2549ÿ240<ÿ6 5ÿ&5 3 9 .)*.ÿ012- 70 9 9    89 10 55ÿ 1% 1%  00ÿÿÿ75 1 ÿ245617 61416ÿ5 ÿ744 675 1 !ÿ7 1%67 5ÿ&5 3 016ÿ& 89'9 59075 00ÿÿÿ75 &44ÿ 5 1%67 151 + |†Š„„{€ º·¸»·¸ƒ¸ˆ 98ÿ011 ÿ61416 5&1 0123 557ÿ5 59075   1%67ÿ60 1&ÿ 23 245617 0ÿ1 421ÿ& 5ÿ&5 3 &44ÿ 5 y{|ÿ~†|¶„‰ ‚ƒ·‚ˆ·¸ƒ¸¹ 89  23ÿ75ÿ72 151ÿ1%67 259 61ÿ51< 1%67'ÿ  557ÿ5 71ÿ75ÿ1%67@ 1&ÿ 23 120 1661 120 1661 7ÿ1%67  1ÿ0075 60ÿ0ÿ1 421 &ÿ 2375ÿ72ÿÿ7 1%67ÿ 1 0075 7 'ÿ7ÿ1%67  1ÿ0075 259 61ÿ51< 71ÿ75ÿ1%67@ 7 'ÿ7ÿ1%67 „ÿÿÿ‹ÿ†‡ÿÿ‰ÿ† 17 744 17  1ÿ0075 ‚ƒƒ yz{{|ÿ~z€ 88 8 1% ()*(- ()*(-    8 8 8  62415 5610ÿ61250ÿ455 ÿ4ÿÿÿ 81 %67ÿ 67ÿ455 ÿ4ÿÿÿ 91 %67ÿ6117ÿ4ÿÿÿ + + + ÿ9ÿÿ9 6241ÿ9ÿÿ9 6241ÿ9ÿÿ9 7 9  $ 98 6241ÿ9ÿÿ9 t‘ÿi’“”•ÿb”–—’˜˜”•™ÿi’–š›•ÿœ™žŸ 01023145ÿ3ÿ2177ÿ89 9ÿ    ÿÿ !  "#$ÿ%&' ( ) *+) ,)) /01ÿ23 4ÿ45650102 \] 9 -. 789:;<8=>?@ÿBC>ÿDEFÿGHI9H?J8K=ÿ<ILÿMDNÿEI:Oÿ<?>ÿIHJÿ;8<P;>ÿQH?ÿ<IRÿK9>Sÿ=89K9>Sÿ=HL8Q8:<J8HIÿH?ÿL89:;H9K?>ÿHQÿ<IRÿ=<TÿT?HU8L>LÿKIL>?ÿ<TT;8:<P;>ÿ;<VOÿÿBC89ÿ=<Tÿ89ÿQH?ÿW>I>?<;ÿ8IQH?=<J8HIÿTK?TH9>9ÿHI;ROÿX;JCHKWCÿJC>ÿ8IQH?=<J8HIÿ89ÿP>;8>U>LÿJHÿP>ÿW>I>?<;;Rÿ<::K?<J>Sÿ>??H?9ÿ=<R >Y89Jÿ<ILÿJC>ÿK9>?ÿ9CHK;Lÿ8IL>T>IL>IJ;Rÿ:HIQ8?=ÿQH?ÿ<::K?<:ROÿBC>ÿ=<TÿLH>9ÿIHJÿ:HI9J8JKJ>ÿ<ÿ?>WK;<JH?RÿL>J>?=8I<J8HIÿ<ILÿ89ÿIHJÿ<ÿP<9>ÿQH?ÿ>IW8I>>?8IWÿL>98WIOÿXÿZ>W89J>?>Lÿ[<ILÿFK?U>RH?ÿ9CHK;LÿP>ÿ:HI9K;J>LÿJHÿL>J>?=8I>ÿT?>:89>ÿ;H:<J8HIÿPHKIL<?8>9ÿHIÿJC>ÿW?HKILO CHICAGO TRIBUNE media group Said To: Village of Skokie - CU00031224 51270aktonSt SkokieJL 60077-3633 Bill To: Village ofSkokie - CU00031224 51270aktonSt Skokie,!L 60077-3633 Certificate of Publication: Order Number: 7796236 Purchase Order: Zoning Board State of Illinois - Cook Chicago Tribune Media Group does hereby certify that it is the publisher of the Skokie Review. The Skokie Review is a secular newspaper, has been continuously published Weekly for more than fifty (50) weeks prior to the first publication of the attached notice, is published in the City of Skokie, Township of Niles, State of illinois, is of general circulation throughout that county and surrounding area, and is a newspaper as defined by 715 IL CS 5/5. This is to certify that a notice, a true copy of which is attached, was published 1 time(s) in the Skokie Review, namely one time per week or on 1 successive weeks. The first publication of the notice was made in the newspaper, dated and published on 4/17/2025, and the last publication of the notice was made in the newspaper dated and published on 4/17/2025. This notice was also placed on a statewide public notice website as required by 715 ILCS 5/2. 1. PUBLICATION DATES:Apr 17, 2025. Skokie Review In witness, an authorized agent of The Chicago Tribune Media Group has signed this certificate executed in Chicago, Illinois on this 18th Day of April, 2025, by Chicago Tribune Media Group i\'! ^ .....w-^' ""^"l/i Jeremy Gates Chicago Tribune - chicagotribunexom 160 N Stetson Avenue, Chicago, IL 60601 (312) 222-2222 "Fax: (312) 222-4014 CHICAGO TRIBUNE media group NQTKE OF PUBUC HEARING skokie Zoning Bodrcl of A|)peals, wedne&day. May 7,2025Villae& of skokie/5127 oakton Street. skokie, Illinois 60077, at 7:30 P.M. to consider the following: 2025-02Z-7656 crawford Avenue Daniel a Maria Toma request a variation in order.to construct a second-floor addition resulting in the continuation of the exist- ing 7.&6r-foot side yard abuttinE a street rather than the 10-fool minimum as required by sec- tion. 118-125(6) e:.of the skokie zoning ordinance in a R2 siitgle- Fami^ district. PIN: 10-27-231-0486-0000 2025-0-3Z - 8950 East Prairie Road Katherine & Samuel Garfinkel on behalf of Andrew Venamore of Heartland Garage Builders, L.LC, requests a variation in or- der' to 'construct an attaclied in a 5-foot front yard" rather tlTan the 25-foot minimum as required by m:l24i:5)of the skokie zcining ordinance in a R1 sJngle-Family district. PIN: 10-14-414-001-0000 2025-04Z - 5011 EstesAvenue Admit and Ajla .Rosic request a variation in order to construct a 2nd floor addition resulting in the continuation of the 3.62-foot side. yard rather than the 4-foot miniriitim as required by.sec- tion 118-125 (6) a. of the 'skokie zoning ordinance in a R2Siiigie- Famit'7 district. PIN 10-33-209-042-0000 FOR YOUR . INFORMATION: Plans and. related documents are available at the Planning D)- vision office atVJIIage.Hall Mon- day througli Friday from 8:30 AM tO 5:0(yPM. 847-933-S447 SPECIAL. AID: Available .upon request for the disabled 'call S47-673-0500 or email infoc* skokie.org. This notice is for mfomiation purposes only. published in the Skdtde Review on April 10,2025. Brian o'Donnell, chairman 4/17/2025 7796236 Chicago Tribune - chicagotribune.com 160 N Stetson Avenue, Chicago, IL 60601 (312) 222-2222 - Fax: (312) 222-4014